Background Presbyterians trace their history to the
Protestant Reformation in the 16th century. The Presbyterian heritage, and much of its theology, began with the French theologian and lawyer
John Calvin (1509–1564), whose writings solidified much of the
Reformed thinking that came before him in the form of the sermons and writings of
Huldrych Zwingli. From Calvin's headquarters in
Geneva, Switzerland, the Reformed movement spread to other parts of Europe.
John Knox, a former Catholic priest from Scotland who studied with Calvin in
Geneva, took Calvin's teachings back to Scotland and led the
Scottish Reformation of 1560. As a result, the
Church of Scotland embraced Reformed theology and
presbyterian polity. Immigrants from Scotland and Ireland brought Presbyterianism to America as early as 1640, and immigration would remain a large source of growth throughout the colonial era. Another source of growth were a number of New England
Puritans who left the
Congregational churches because they preferred presbyterian polity. In 1706, seven ministers led by
Francis Makemie established the first American
presbytery at Philadelphia, which was followed by the creation of the
Synod of Philadelphia in 1717. The PCA has its roots in theological controversies over
liberalism in Christianity and
neo-orthodoxy that had been a point of contention in the
Presbyterian Church in the United States which had split from the mainline
Presbyterian Church in the U.S.A along regional lines at the beginning of the
Civil War. While the
Fundamentalist–Modernist Controversy had led to a split in the PC-USA in the mid-1930s, leading to the formation of the
Orthodox Presbyterian Church and
Bible Presbyterian Church, the PCUS remained intact. However, beginning in 1942, as the PCUS began to experiment with confessional revision, and later, when neo-orthodoxy and liberalism began to become influential in the PCUS' seminaries, and attempts were made to merge with the more liberal PC-USA and its successor, the
United Presbyterian Church in the U.S.A., renewal groups began to be formed, including the Presbyterian Churchmen United, which had been formed by more than 500 ministers and ran 3/4-page statements of their beliefs in 30 newspapers, the Presbyterian Evangelistic Fellowship, conducted revivals in PCUS churches, the Concerned Presbyterians, and the Presbyterian Churchmen United (PCU), an organization of conservative pastors in the Southern Presbyterian Church. They sought to reaffirm the
Westminster Confession of Faith as the fullest and clearest exposition of biblical faith, which many conservatives felt that presbyteries had been violating by receiving ministers who refused to affirm the
virgin birth and
bodily resurrection, and to expect all pastors and leaders to affirm the
inerrancy of scripture. Opponents of the merger took specific issue with the United Presbyterian Church's adherence to the
Auburn Affirmation and the
Confession of 1967; the Southern Presbyterian denomination rejected the adoption of these confessions as official standards, noting amorphous biblical doctrine, lax sexual ethic, and conversations with other church bodies that rejected the Reformed faith, such as those explored by the Consultation on Church Union. It remains controversial as to whether racial tensions may have contributed to the formation of the PCA. Many in the PCA have adamantly maintained that race played little role in the genesis of the new denomination, but many outside the PCA have a historical memory of racial animus irrefutably contributing to the desire for exodus from the Southern Presbyterian denomination, the PCUS. However, on June 23, 2016, the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in America voted to approve a statement on racial reconciliation that specifically recognized "corporate and historical sins, including those committed during the Civil Rights era, and continuing racial sins of ourselves and our fathers such as the segregation of worshipers by race; the exclusion of persons from Church membership on the basis of race; the exclusion of churches, or elders, from membership in the Presbyteries on the basis of race; the teaching that the Bible sanctions racial segregation and discourages inter-racial marriage; the participation in and defense of white supremacist organizations; and the failure to live out the gospel imperative that ‘love does no wrong to a neighbor’ (Romans 13:10)." This admission of "historical sins" during the Civil Rights era has helped to ameliorate the conflict that some black members of the PCA may have felt about the denomination's failure to fully embrace and protect the rights of African Americans both within and outside of the church during the PCA's formative years. Conservatives also felt the church should disavow the
ordination of women. They also criticized the PCUS Board of Christian Education's published literature and believed that the denomination's Board of World Missions no longer placed its primary emphasis on carrying out the
Great Commission. In 1966, conservatives within the PCUS, concerned about the denominational seminaries founded
Reformed Theological Seminary. Finally, when word came out that a planned Plan of Union between the UPCUSA and PCUS lacked an "escape clause" which would have allowed for PCUS congregations that wanted no part in the planned union to leave without forfeiture of property, the steering committee of several of the renewal groups called for conservative PCUS congregations to leave. In December 1973, delegates, representing some 260 congregations with a combined communicant membership of over 41,000 that had left the PCUS, gathered at Briarwood Presbyterian Church in Birmingham, Alabama, and organized the National Presbyterian Church, which later became the Presbyterian Church in America. After protests from a UPCUSA congregation of the
same name in Washington, D.C., the denomination at its Second General Assembly (1974) renamed itself the National Reformed Presbyterian Church, then adopted its present name the next day. At its founding, the PCA consisted of 16 presbyteries. Within a few years the church grew to include more than 500 congregations and 80,000 members.
Growth Kenyon Case – PCA growth in the Mid-Atlantic (1975) ,
Fairton, New Jersey the oldest congregation in the denomination (founded in 1680), left the UPCUSA in 1971, joined the PCA in 1980 During the 1970s, the denomination added a significant number of congregations outside the South when several UPCUSA churches in
Ohio and
Pennsylvania joined. This move was precipitated by a case regarding an ordination candidate, Wynn Kenyon, denied by the
Pittsburgh Presbytery because he refused to support women's ordination (a decision upheld by the UPCUSA General Assembly). The seceder churches formed the Ascension
Presbytery, officially organised on July 29, 1975. That year, a minister of that presbytery described its history as follows: For example, seceders from Union UPCUSA formed Providence Presbyterian Church in Pittsburgh under the leadership of Broadwick.
PCA expands in the Midwest Dozens of churches from the Midwest became part of the Presbyterian Church in America after leaving the Synod of the West of the PC(USA), formerly called the United Presbyterian Church in the USA. This became the Siouxlands Presbytery composed of only
South Dakota, but in 1982 when the Joining and Receiving took place with the Reformed Presbyterian Church, Evangelical Synod, boundaries were expanded to cover Minnesota,
North Dakota,
Nebraska and Iowa. In the state of Michigan, dissenting Christian Reformed and RCA church members formed Covenant Presbyterian Church in
Holland, MI in 1996 under the leadership of Tom Vanden Heuvel, former pastor of First Christian Reformed Church (Grand Rapids, Michigan), who claimed that the Christian Reformed Church(CRC) departed from its original commitment to the clarity and authority of Scripture. At that time, another CRC church joined the PCA in Texas, as well as in New York, the Monsey Christian Church.
Departures from the PCUS (1973–1990) Dissenting conservative Southern Presbyterian Churches joined the PCA until the early 1990s. Early PCA growth was largely through secessions from the Southern Presbyterian Church (PCUS), which from 1983 to 1990 allowed churches to leave with their property. About 110 to 120 churches did come in during that period of time to the PCA with their properties, allowed by various PC(USA) Presbyteries. Since that time, PCA growth has been largely through church planting and local congregational outreach rather than by transfers of entire churches from other denominations. PC(USA) ministers are now required to agree with the ordination of women, which the PCA opposes. However, since 1996 about 23 PC(USA) congregations have joined the PCA. As of the 2014 PC(USA) General assembly, most churches withdrawing from the PC(USA) are joining the Evangelical Presbyterian Church or the newly formed
ECO due to their acceptance of women ministers, though since then many conservative PC(USA) groups and even whole congregations have affiliated with the PCA.
Merger with the Reformed Presbyterian Church, Evangelical Synod (1982) in
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, which joined the PCA as part of the merger with the
Reformed Presbyterian Church, Evangelical Synod In 1982, the PCA merged with the
Reformed Presbyterian Church, Evangelical Synod (RPCES), with 25,673 communicant members and 482 ministers in 189 congregations in the United States as well as in a few Canadian provinces. Discussions had begun in 1979 with the Reformed Presbyterian Church, Evangelical Synod, which had itself come about due to a merger between the
Evangelical Presbyterian Church (formerly the Bible Presbyterian Church – Columbus Synod and not the current denomination of the same name) and the
Reformed Presbyterian Church, General Synod (a group of "New Light"
Covenanters). The RPCES brought to the PCA a more broadly national base of membership with a denominational college,
Covenant College, and a seminary,
Covenant Theological Seminary. Previously, the PCA had relied on independent evangelical institutions such as
Reformed Theological Seminary in
Jackson, Mississippi and
Westminster Theological Seminary in
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The PCA had originally invited three denominations to the merger, including the
Orthodox Presbyterian Church (OPC) and the
Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America (RPCNA). The OPC voted to accept the invitation to join the PCA, but the PCA voted against receiving them. The PCA presbyteries did not approve the application by the required three-quarters majority, and so the proposed invitation process was terminated without the OPC presbyteries voting on the issue. The RPCES was the only church to carry through with the merger. The merger was called "Joining and Receiving". When a sufficient number of RPCES and PCA presbyteries voted in favor of the plan, the final votes occurred at the respective annual meetings, both held in
Grand Rapids, Michigan: the RPCES Synod voted to join the PCA on June 12, 1982, and the PCA General Assembly voted to receive the RPCES on June 14. The Reformed Presbyterian Church, Evangelical Synod agencies and committees were united with their PCA counterparts. The history and historical documents of the RPCES were incorporated into the PCA. Graduates from Covenant College and Seminary were also officially recognized. In 1986 the PCA again invited the Orthodox Presbyterian Church to join them, but without success. Not everyone agreed with the decision. In the four years after 1986, there was a voluntary realignment as congregations left the OPC for the PCA, mainly from California,
Montana and
Pennsylvania, but also from as far as Alaska. By the 1970s, the OPC had grown a new ‘pietist/revivalist’ wing under the influence of
Jack Miller. According to
Tim Keller, the New Life Churches and their
Sonship course represented classic
revivalism, and it did not fit well with the more doctrinalist cast of the OPC. The New Life Churches were made to feel unwelcome and nearly all left in the early 1990s to swell the pietist ranks of the PCA.
Nationwide growth , founded 1824, left the
Christian Reformed Church in North America for the PCA in 2005. In 1983 several
PCUS churches had joined the PCA, instead of merging with the UPCUSA into the current
PC (U.S.A.); others joined the recently formed
Evangelical Presbyterian Church, unrelated to the 1950s and 1960s body of that name. A clause in the Plan of Union between the two mainline bodies allowed dissenting PCUS congregations to refrain from joining the merger and to join a denomination of their choosing. At the 20th anniversary of the PCA in 1993 there were 1,086 congregations and 242,560 members. The PCA Historical Center, a repository of archives and manuscripts, is located in St. Louis, Missouri. The PCA is one of the denominations in the United States, with some 1,700 churches and missions throughout the US and Canada. There were some 335,000 communicant and non-communicant members as of December 2000. Hospers Presbyterian Church in
Hospers, Iowa, was also PC(USA), joined the PCA in November 2006. Park Cities Presbyterian Church was formed when about 1,500–2,000 former
Highland Park Presbyterian Church (Dallas, Texas) member separated from the PC(USA) and joined PCA. In 2013 and 2014 a few disappointed conservative PC(USA) congregations from New York state and from the
Presbytery of Sheppards & Lapsley (Unity Presbyterian in Weogufka, Alabama, and Southwood Presbyterian in Talladega, Alabama) in the state of Alabama and Smyrna Korean Presbyterian Church in
Enterprise, Alabama, joined the Presbyterian Church in America instead of
ECO or EPC, which have women ministers. Several PC(USA) breakaway groups like New Covenant Presbyterian Church in
McComb, Mississippi, which broke from J.J. White Memorial Presbyterian Church in 2007, and First Scot's Presbyterian Church, PCA in
Beaufort, South Carolina (formerly First Scots Independent Presbyterian Church), voted to affiliate with the PCA. As well as several independent Anglo and till now unaffiliated Korean Presbyterian churches like Greater Springfield Korean Church in
Agawam, Massachusetts. According to the PC(USA) statistics 7 PC(USA) congregations with 550 members joined PCA, excluded the seceder groups since 2005. Doctrinal debate in the
Reformed Church in America led some RCA congregations like Grace Reformed Church in
Lansing, Illinois (Pastor Andy Nearpass), the Peace Community Church from
Frankfort, Illinois (Kurt Kruger), Crete Reformed Church in Crete, Illinois (Pastor David Smith), First Reformed Church in Lansing, Illinois (Pastor Ben Kappers), Mission Dei Church in
New Lenox, Illinois (Pastor Paul Vroom) and
University Reformed Church in
East Lansing, Michigan (Pastor
Kevin DeYoung) to join the PCA as a conservative alternative. Each of the churches was allowed to withdraw with their respective properties and assets after paying a varying settlement fee to the Illiana-Florida Classis. But if a church should withdraw from the PCA within five years of the approval of the agreement, then the property is to revert to the Classis of Illiana-Florida. University Reformed Church was also granted dismissal by the RCA Classis on March 21, 2015.
Kevin DeYoung, the pastor of University Reformed Church, summarized the reasons of withdrawing from the Reformed Church in America and affiliate with the PCA: ==Doctrine and practice==