According to historian Guido Ruggiero, love magic is seen as drawing "…heavily upon what was perceived as quintessentially feminine: fertility, birth, menstruation (seen as closely related to both fertility and birth), and a woman’s ‘nature’ or ‘shameful parts,’ that is, genitals". This feminine attribute is reflected within the literature such as the
Malleus Maleficarum and in the trials of the
Holy Office in which most of the cases brought before the council were women accused of bewitching men. This illustrates the common stereotype that men did not perform magic. According to historians Guido Ruggiero and Christopher A. Faraone, love magic was often associated with prostitutes and courtesans, but this has been questioned by other scholars such as Catherine Rider who, in a study of late medieval Western European pastoral manuals and
exempla, especially English, argues this was a development that happened around the time of the
early modern witch trials and may have been influenced by the fact that the women who were most often tried for love magic were women of ill-repute, in illicit relationships, or both. In the early Middle Ages, it was married women who were solely portrayed as practicing love magic on their husbands. In the
Early Middle Ages, there is some evidence that women were considered more likely to be practitioners of love magic. For instance, in the works of
Regino of Prüm,
Burchard of Worms, and
Hincmar the practitioners of love magic are usually gendered as female. However, in pastoral manuals and
exempla from this same time period, the practitioners are often not gendered at all or men are primarily singled out. How modern scholars interpret how medieval and early modern Europeans viewed women, witches, and magic has traditionally been heavily influenced by the 1487 misogynistic anti-witchcraft treatise
Malleus Maleficarum written by Heinrich Kramer. In the opening section of this text, it discusses the sexuality of women in relation to the devil.
Heinrich Kramer wrote within his book that, "All witchcraft comes from carnal lust, which in women is insatiable." But as Rider and others have noted, this may reflect the opinions of one man in one region and was not widespread in Europe as a whole. Matthew W. Dickie, a prominent magic scholar, argues that men were the main casters of love magic. Demographically, they suggest that the largest age group that practiced love magic were younger men targeting young, unobtainable women. There are a variety of explanations for why the literary world contrasted reality in this area, but a common interpretation is that men were trying to subtract themselves from association. == In literature and art ==