Pence was one of eight candidates who appeared at the
first Republican presidential debate on August 23, 2023. When asked what his strategy for the debate would be, Pence said he would be himself and that he felt "like I’ve been preparing for this first Republican presidential debate my whole life."
The Hill declared Pence,
Chris Christie, and
Nikki Haley the winners, furthering that Pence delivered "a number of forceful interventions" as he demonstrated fierceness and had seen "the best night of his campaign to date."
BBC News declared Pence the second-place winner, behind
Vivek Ramaswamy, and ahead of Haley.
The Washington Post declared Trump (who did not appear), Ramaswamy, and Pence the debate's winners. The reporters of
Politico had mixed responses, variously citing Pence, Ramaswamy, and
Ron DeSantis as the winners. After the debate, in a post on
Truth Social, Trump claimed that he "never asked Mike Pence to put me above the Constitution. Who would say such a thing? A FAKE STORY!" Pence appeared alongside six competitors at the second
Republican presidential debate on September 27. All competitors from the first debate returned, except Hutchinson who failed to qualify. After Trump announced he would skip the second GOP debate, Pence called it "a missed opportunity" for both Trump and Republican voters and said "the former president – just like all the rest of us vying for the Republican nomination – owe it to the American people to express what our agenda will be for turning this country around."
USA Today called Pence's comment about "sleeping with a teacher for 38 years" as "one of the most memorable one-liners of the debate".
The Hill noted Pence as one of the debate's losers, along with Ramaswamy and Burgum.
Politico mentioned the decline of Pence's performance from the first debate, asserting that he "didn’t do enough to highlight his bona fides as a religious conservative leader, which should be one of his selling points to the Republican Party."
The Washington Post, citing Pence's pivoting from answering if he wanted to repeal the Affordable Care Act, declared the health care law as one of the debate's winners. Opinion writers and contributors of
The New York Times gave Pence the lowest score of any candidate at 2.4 with Daniel McCarthy arguing that Pence did not say anything that "made an effective case for him over any of his competitors, who seem fresher and more energetic than he does."
FiveThirtyEight polled Republican voters on who performed the best and worst of the debate, with 24% responding that Chris Christie had the worst performance, while 20% chose Pence. == Withdrawal ==