The personal experiences of the novelist will often shape what they write and how readers and critics will interpret their novels. Literary reception has long relied on practices of reading literature through
biographical criticism, in which the author's life is presumed to have influence on the topical and thematic concerns of works. Some veins of criticism use this information about the novelist to derive an understanding of the
novelist's intentions within his work. However, postmodern literary critics often denounce such an approach; the most notable of these critiques comes from
Roland Barthes who argues in his essay "
Death of the Author" that the author no longer should dictate the reception and meaning derived from their work. Other, theoretical approaches to
literary criticism attempt to explore the author's unintentional influence over their work; methods like
psychoanalytic theory or
cultural studies, presume that the work produced by a novelist represents
fundamental parts of the author's identity.
Milan Kundera describes the tensions between the novelist's own identity and the work that the author produces in his essay in
The New Yorker titled "What is a novelist?"; he says that the novelist's "honesty is bound to the vile stake of his megalomania [...]The work is not simply everything a novelist writes-notebooks, diaries, articles. It is the end result of long labor on an aesthetic project[...]The novelist is the sole master of his work. He is his work." The close intimacy of identity with the novelist's work ensures that particular elements, whether for class, gender, sexuality, nationality, race, or place-based identity, will influence the reception of their work.
Socio-economic class Historically, because of the amount of leisure time and education required to write novels, most novelists have come from the upper or the educated middle classes. However, working men and women began publishing novels in the twentieth century. This includes in Britain
Walter Greenwood's
Love on the Dole (1933), from America
B. Traven's,
The Death Ship (1926) and
Agnes Smedley,
Daughter of Earth (1929) and from the Soviet Union
Nikolay Ostrovsky's
How the Steel Was Tempered (1932). Later, in 1950s Britain, came a group of writers known as the "
Angry young men," which included the novelists
Alan Sillitoe and
Kingsley Amis, who came from the working class and who wrote about
working class culture. Some novelists deliberately write for a working class audience for political ends, profiling "the working classes and working-class life; perhaps with the intention of making propaganda". Such literature, sometimes called
proletarian literature, maybe associated with the political agendas of the
Communist party or left wing sympathizers, and seen as a "device of revolution". However, the British tradition of working class literature, unlike the Russian and American, was not especially inspired by the Communist Party, but had its roots in the
Chartist movement, and
socialism, amongst others.
National or place-based identity Novelists are often classified by their national affiliation, suggesting that novels take on a particular character based on the national identity of the authors. In some literature, national identity shapes the self-definition of many novelists. For example, in
American literature, many novelists set out to create the "
Great American Novel", or a novel that defines the American experience in their time. Other novelists engage politically or socially with the identity of other members of their nationality, and thus help define that national identity. For instance, critic Nicola Minott-Ahl describes Victor Hugo's
Notre-Dame de Paris directly helping in the creation of French political and social identity in mid-nineteenth century France. Some novelists become intimately linked with a particular place or geographic region and therefore receive a
place-based identity. In his discussion of the history of the association of particular novelists with place in
British literature, critic D. C. D. Pocock, described the sense of place not developing in that canon until a century after the novel form first solidified at the beginning of the 19th century. Often such
British regional literature captures the social and local character of a particular region in Britain, focussing on specific features, such as dialect, customs, history, and landscape (also called
local colour): "Such a locale is likely to be rural and/or provincial."
Thomas Hardy's (1840–1928) novels can be described as regional because of the way he makes use of these elements in relation to a part of the West of England, that he names
Wessex. Other British writers that have been characterized as regional novelists, are the
Brontë sisters, and writers like
Mary Webb (1881–1927),
Margiad Evans (1909–58) and
Geraint Goodwin (1903–42), who are associate with the
Welsh border region.
George Eliot (1801–86) on the other hand is particularly associated with the rural English Midlands, whereas
Arnold Bennett (1867–1931) is the novelist of the
Potteries in
Staffordshire, or the "Five Towns", (actually six) that now make-up
Stoke-on-Trent. Similarly, novelist and poet
Walter Scott's (1771–1832) contribution in creating a unified identity for
Scotland and were some of the most popular in all of Europe during the subsequent century. Scott's novels were influential in recreating a Scottish identity that the upper-class British society could embrace. on Edinburgh's
Princes Street. In American fiction, the concept of
American literary regionalism ensures that many genres of novel associated with particular regions often define the reception of the novelists. For example, in writing
Western novels,
Zane Grey has been described as a "place-defining novelist", credited for defining the western frontier in America consciousness at the beginning of the 20th century while becoming linked as an individual to his depiction of that space. Similarly, novelist such as
Mark Twain,
William Faulkner,
Eudora Welty, and
Flannery O'Connor are often describe as writing within a particular tradition of
Southern literature, in which subject matter relevant to the South is associated with their own identities as authors. For example, William Faulkner set many of his short stories and novels in
Yoknapatawpha County, which is based on, and nearly geographically identical to, Lafayette County, of which his hometown of
Oxford, Mississippi. In addition to the geographical component of Southern literature, certain themes have appeared because of the similar histories of the Southern states in regard to
slavery, the
American Civil War, and
Reconstruction. The
conservative culture in the South has also produced a strong focus by novelists from there on the significance of family, religion, community, the use of the
Southern dialect, along with a strong sense of place.
The South's troubled history with
racial issues has also continually concerned its novelists. In
Latin America a literary movement called
Criollismo or costumbrismo was active from the end of the 19th century to the beginning of the 20th century, which is considered equivalent to American literary regionalism. It used a realist style to portray the scenes, language, customs and manners of the country the writer was from, especially the lower and peasant classes,
criollismo led to an original literature based on the continent's natural elements, mostly epic and foundational. It was strongly influenced by the wars of independence from
Spain and also denotes how each country in its own way defines
criollo, which in
Latin America refers to locally-born people of Spanish ancestry.
Gender and sexuality Novelists often will be assessed in contemporary criticism based on their gender or treatment of gender. Largely, this has to do with the impacts of cultural expectations of gender on the literary market, readership and authorship. It is not a question of the subject matter or political stance of a particular author, but of her
gender: her position as a woman within the literary marketplace. However, the publishing market's orientation to favor the primary reading audience of women may increasingly skew the market towards female novelists; for this reason, novelist
Teddy Wayne argued in a 2012
Salon article titled "The agony of the male novelist" that midlist male novelists are less likely to find success than midlist female novelist, even though men tend to dominate "literary fiction" spaces. However, other commentators, discussing the controversy also note that by removing such categories as "Women novelist" or "Lesbian writer" from the description of gendered or sexual minorities, the discover-ability of those authors plummet for other people who share that identity. Similarly, because of the conversations brought by feminism, examinations of masculine subjects and an author's performance of "maleness" are a new and increasingly prominent approach critical studies of novels. For example, some academics studying
Victorian fiction spend considerable time examining how masculinity shapes and effects the works, because of its prominence within fiction from the Victorian period. ==Genre==