Tube Alloys The
neutron was discovered by
James Chadwick at the
Cavendish Laboratory at the
University of Cambridge in February 1932, and in April 1932, his Cavendish colleagues
John Cockcroft and
Ernest Walton split
lithium atoms with accelerated
protons. In December 1938,
Otto Hahn and
Fritz Strassmann at Hahn's laboratory in
Berlin-Dahlem bombarded
uranium with slow neutrons, and discovered that
barium had been produced. Hahn wrote to his colleague
Lise Meitner, who, with her nephew
Otto Frisch, determined that the uranium
nucleus had been split, a conclusion they published in
Nature in 1939. By analogy with the
division of biological cells, they named the process "
fission". The discovery of fission raised the possibility that an extremely powerful
atomic bomb could be created. The term was already familiar to the British public through the writings of
H. G. Wells, with a continuously exploding bomb in his 1913 novel
The World Set Free.
George Paget Thomson, at
Imperial College London, and
Mark Oliphant, an Australian physicist at the
University of Birmingham, were tasked with carrying out a series of experiments on uranium. Oliphant delegated the task to two German refugee scientists,
Rudolf Peierls and Frisch, who ironically could not work on the university's secret projects like
radar because they were
enemy aliens and therefore lacked the necessary security clearance. In March 1940 they calculated the
critical mass of a metallic sphere of pure
uranium-235, and found that instead of tons, as everyone had assumed, as little as would suffice, which would explode with the power of thousands of tons of dynamite. Oliphant took the resulting
Frisch–Peierls memorandum to Sir
Henry Tizard, the chairman of the
Tizard Committee, and the
MAUD Committee was established to investigate further. It held its first meeting on 10 April 1940, in the ground-floor main committee room of the
Royal Society in
Burlington House in London. It directed an intensive research effort, and in July 1941, produced two comprehensive reports that reached the conclusion that an atomic bomb was not only technically feasible, but could be produced before the war ended, perhaps in as little as two years. The Committee unanimously recommended pursuing the development of an atomic bomb as a matter of urgency, although it recognised that the resources required might be beyond those available to Britain. A new directorate known as
Tube Alloys was created to coordinate this effort. Sir
John Anderson, the
Lord President of the Council, became the minister responsible, and
Wallace Akers from
Imperial Chemical Industries (ICI) was appointed the director of Tube Alloys.
Manhattan Project In July 1940, Britain had offered to give the United States access to its scientific research, and the
Tizard Mission's John Cockcroft briefed American scientists on British developments. He discovered that the American S-1 Project (later renamed the
Manhattan Project) was smaller than the British, and not as far advanced. The British and American projects exchanged information, but did not initially combine their efforts. British officials did not reply to an August 1941 American offer to create a combined project. In November 1941,
Frederick L. Hovde, the head of the London liaison office of the American
Office of Scientific Research and Development (OSRD), raised the issue of cooperation and exchange of information with Anderson and
Lord Cherwell, who demurred, ostensibly over concerns about American security. Ironically, it was the British project that had already been penetrated by
atomic spies for the
Soviet Union. The United Kingdom did not have the manpower or resources of the United States, and despite its early and promising start, Tube Alloys fell behind its American counterpart and was dwarfed by it. On 30 July 1942, Anderson advised the
Prime Minister of the United Kingdom,
Winston Churchill, saying: "We must face the fact that ... [our] pioneering work ... is a dwindling asset and that, unless we capitalise it quickly, we shall be outstripped. We now have a real contribution to make to a 'merger.' Soon we shall have little or none." (left), the head of the British Mission, confers with
Major General Leslie R. Groves, Jr. (right), the director of the
Manhattan Project|alt=A large man in uniform and a bespectacled thin man in a suit and tie sit at a desk. The British considered producing an atomic bomb without American help, but it would require overwhelming priority, would disrupt other wartime projects, and was unlikely to be ready in time to affect the outcome of the
war in Europe. The unanimous response was that before embarking on this, another effort should be made to secure American cooperation. At the
Quebec Conference in August 1943, Churchill and the
President of the United States,
Franklin Roosevelt, signed the
Quebec Agreement, which merged the two national projects. The Quebec Agreement established the
Combined Policy Committee and the
Combined Development Trust to coordinate their efforts, and specified that the weapons could only be used if both the US and UK governments agreed. The 19 September 1944 Hyde Park Agreement extended both commercial and military cooperation into the post-war period. A British mission led by Akers assisted in the development of
gaseous diffusion technology at the
SAM Laboratories in New York. Another, led by Oliphant, who acted as deputy director at the
Berkeley Radiation Laboratory, assisted with the
electromagnetic separation process. Cockcroft became the director of the Anglo-Canadian
Montreal Laboratory. The British mission to the
Los Alamos Laboratory was headed by Chadwick, and later Peierls. It included distinguished scientists such as
Geoffrey Taylor,
James Tuck,
Niels Bohr,
William Penney, Frisch,
Ernest Titterton and
Klaus Fuchs, who was later revealed to be a Soviet spy. As overall head of the British Mission, Chadwick forged a close and successful partnership with
Brigadier General Leslie R. Groves, the director of the Manhattan Project. He ensured that British participation was complete and wholehearted. Penney worked on means to assess the effects of a nuclear explosion, and wrote a paper on what height the bombs should be detonated at for maximum effect in attacks on Germany and Japan. He served as a member of the target committee established by Groves to select Japanese cities for atomic bombing, and on
Tinian with
Project Alberta as a special consultant. Because the Quebec Agreement specified that nuclear weapons would not be used against another country without mutual consent, British authorisation was required for their use. On 4 July 1945, Field Marshal
Henry Maitland Wilson agreed that the use of nuclear weapons against Japan would be recorded as a decision of the Combined Policy Committee. Along with
Group Captain Leonard Cheshire, sent by Wilson as a British representative, Penney watched the
bombing of Nagasaki from the observation plane
Big Stink. He also formed part of the Manhattan Project's post-war scientific mission to Hiroshima and Nagasaki that assessed the extent of the damage caused by the bombs.
End of American cooperation and the prime ministers
Clement Attlee and
Mackenzie King boarding for discussions about nuclear weapons, November 1945 With the end of the war, the
Special Relationship between Britain and the United States "became very much less special". The British government had trusted that America would share nuclear technology, which it considered a joint discovery. On 8 August 1945, the Prime Minister,
Clement Attlee, sent a message to President
Harry Truman in which he referred to themselves as "heads of the Governments which have control of this great force". But Roosevelt had died on 12 April 1945, and the Hyde Park Agreement was not binding on subsequent administrations. In fact, it was physically lost. When Wilson raised the matter in a Combined Policy Committee meeting in June, the American copy could not be found. On 9 November 1945, Attlee and the
Prime Minister of Canada,
Mackenzie King, went to Washington, D.C., to confer with Truman about future cooperation in nuclear weapons and nuclear power. A Memorandum of Intention they signed replaced the Quebec Agreement. It made Canada a full partner, continued the Combined Policy Committee and Combined Development Trust, and reduced the obligation to obtain consent for the use of nuclear weapons to merely requiring consultation. The three leaders agreed that there would be full and effective cooperation on atomic energy, but British hopes were soon disappointed; Groves restricted cooperation to basic scientific research. The next meeting of the Combined Policy Committee on 15 April 1946 produced no accord on collaboration, and resulted in an exchange of cables between Truman and Attlee. Truman cabled on 20 April that he did not see the communiqué he had signed as obligating the United States to assist Britain in designing, constructing and operating an atomic energy plant. The passing of the
Atomic Energy Act of 1946 (McMahon Act) in August 1946, which was signed by Truman on 1 August 1946, and went into effect at midnight on 1 January 1947, ended technical cooperation. Its control of "restricted data" prevented the United States' allies from receiving any information. The remaining British scientists working in the United States were denied access to papers that they had written just days before. This partly resulted from the arrest for espionage of British physicist
Alan Nunn May, who had worked in the Montreal Laboratory, in February 1946, while the legislation was being debated. It was but the first of a series of spy scandals. The arrest of Klaus Fuchs in January 1950, and the June 1951 defection of
Donald Maclean, who had served as a British member of the Combined Policy Committee from January 1947 to August 1948, left Americans with a distrust of British security arrangements.
Resumption of independent UK efforts Most leading scientists and politicians of all parties were determined that Britain should have its own nuclear weapons. Their motives included national defence, a vision of a civil programme for nuclear power, and a desire that a British voice should be as powerful as any in international debate. Attlee set up a
cabinet sub-committee, the
Gen 75 Committee (known informally by Attlee as the "Atomic Bomb Committee"), on 10 August 1945 to examine the feasibility of an independent British nuclear weapons programme. A
nuclear reactor and plutonium-processing facility was approved by the Gen 75 committee on 18 December 1945 "with the highest urgency and importance". The
Chiefs of Staff Committee considered the issue in July 1946, and recommended that Britain acquire nuclear weapons. They estimated that 200 bombs would be required by 1957. , Chief Superintendent Armament Research, was in charge of atomic bomb development.|alt=Head and shoulders of man in suit and tie The Tube Alloys Directorate was transferred from the
Department of Scientific and Industrial Research to the Ministry of Supply effective 1 November 1945. To coordinate the atomic energy effort, Marshal of the Royal Air Force
Lord Portal, the wartime Chief of the Air Staff, was appointed the Controller of Production, Atomic Energy (CPAE) in March 1946. The Gen 75 Committee considered the proposal in October 1946. In October 1946, Attlee called a meeting to discuss building a gaseous diffusion plant for
uranium enrichment.
Michael Perrin, who was present, later recalled that: The decision to proceed was formally made on 8 January 1947 at a meeting of Gen 163, a subcommittee of the Gen 75 Committee consisting of six
Cabinet members, including Attlee, and was publicly announced in the
House of Commons on 12 May 1948.
D notice No. 25 prohibited the publication of details on the design, construction or location of atomic weapons. The project was given the cover name "High Explosive Research". As Chief Superintendent Armament Research (CSAR, pronounced "Caesar"), Penney directed bomb design from
Fort Halstead. In 1951, his design group moved to a new site at
Aldermaston in Berkshire. Production facilities were constructed under the direction of
Christopher Hinton, who established his headquarters in a former
Royal Ordnance Factory (ROF) at
ROF Risley in
Lancashire. These included a uranium metal plant at
Springfields, nuclear reactors and a plutonium processing plant at
Windscale, and a gaseous diffusion uranium enrichment facility at
Capenhurst, near
Chester. The two Windscale reactors became operational in October 1950 and June 1951. The gaseous diffusion plant at Capenhurst began producing
highly enriched uranium in 1954. Uranium ore was stockpiled at Springfields. As the American nuclear programme expanded, its requirements became greater than the production of the existing mines. To gain access to the stockpile, they reopened negotiations in 1947. This resulted in the 1948
Modus Vivendi, which allowed for consultation on the use of nuclear weapons, and limited sharing of technical information between the United States, Britain and Canada.
Unsuccessful attempt to renew American partnership , in Australia in 1952 The United States feared the USSR obtaining British atomic technology after conquering the United Kingdom in an invasion of western Europe. In February 1949 General
Dwight D. Eisenhower offered to General Sir
William Duthie Morgan American atomic weapons if the British programme ended. Britain would have used the weapons with its own aircraft
for its own targets. Whether the McMahon Act would have permitted the transaction is unclear, but Britain refused because of its intention to develop its own weapons. By that year, international control of atomic weapons seemed almost impossible to achieve, and Truman proposed to the
Joint Committee on Atomic Energy in July a "full partnership" with Britain in exchange for uranium; negotiations between the two countries began that month. While the
first Soviet atomic bomb test in August 1949 was embarrassing to the British (who had not expected a Soviet atomic weapon until 1954) for having been beaten, it was for the Americans another reason for cooperation. Although they would soon have their own nuclear capability, the British proposed that instead of building their own uranium-enrichment plant they would send most of their scientists to work in the US, and swap plutonium from Windscale for enriched uranium from the US. While Britain would not formally give up building or researching its own weapons, the US would manufacture all the bombs and allocate some to Britain. By agreeing to subsume its own weapons programme within the American one, the plan would have given Britain nuclear weapons much sooner than its own target date of late 1952. Although Truman supported the proposal, several key officials, including the
United States Atomic Energy Commission's
Lewis Strauss and Senator
Arthur Vandenberg, did not. Their opposition, along with security concerns raised by the arrest of Fuchs, who was working at Harwell, ended the negotiations in January 1950. After Britain developed nuclear weapons through its own efforts, the engineer Sir
Leonard Owen stated that "the McMahon Act was probably one of the best things that happened ... as it made us work and think for ourselves along independent lines."
First test and early systems Churchill, now again prime minister, announced on 17 February 1952 that the first British weapon test would occur before the end of the year. During
Operation Hurricane, an atomic bomb was detonated on board the
frigate anchored in a lagoon in the
Monte Bello Islands in
Western Australia on 3 October 1952. Britain thereby became the third country to develop and test nuclear weapons. '' bomb, Britain's first nuclear weapon This led to the development of the first deployed weapon, the
Blue Danube free-fall bomb. It had a diameter, 32
explosive lens implosion system with a
levitated pit suspended within a natural uranium
tamper. The warhead was contained within a bomb casing measuring diameter and long, and it weighed approximately , of which about was high explosive. The first Blue Danube bombs were delivered to the Royal Air Force (RAF)
Bomber Command in November 1953, although the bombers to deliver them did not become available until 1955. On 11 October 1956, a
Vickers Valiant from
No. 49 Squadron RAF piloted by
Edwin Flavell became the first British aircraft to drop a live atomic bomb when a Blue Danube was exploded over
Maralinga, South Australia during
Operation Buffalo. About fifty-eight Blue Danube bombs were produced. The first bombs had plutonium
cores, but all service models were modified to use a composite core which used both uranium-235 and plutonium. The bomb had a nominal yield of . The cores were stored separately from the high explosive components in concrete "igloos" at
RAF Barnham in
Suffolk and
RAF Faldingworth in
Lincolnshire. Some casings were stored elsewhere in the UK and in Cyprus for "second strike" use. It remained in service until 1962, and was replaced by
Red Beard, a smaller tactical nuclear weapon. The Blue Danube cores were recycled, and the plutonium used in other nuclear weapons. Being so big and heavy, Blue Danube could only be carried by the
V bombers, so-called because they all had names starting with a "V". The three strategic bombers, known collectively as the V class, comprised the United Kingdom's strategic nuclear strike force during the 1950s and 1960s, which was known as V force of the Main Force. The three V bombers were the
Vickers Valiant, which entered service in February 1955; the
Avro Vulcan, which entered service in May 1956; and the
Handley Page Victor, which entered service in November 1957. The V Bomber force reached its peak in June 1964, when 50 Valiants, 70 Vulcans and 39 Victors were in service.
Thermonuclear development test on 31 May 1957, claimed to be Britain's first H-bomb test at the time, as reported by Universal International Newsreel a few days later. In fact, it was a large fusion-boosted fission weapon test, but the fusion boosting worked very poorly. A month after Britain's first atomic weapons test,
America tested the first
thermonuclear (hydrogen) bomb. The Soviets responded with
Joe 4, a
boosted fission weapon, in 1953. Penney feared that Britain could not afford to develop a hydrogen bomb, as did Tizard, who argued that the nation should focus on conventional forces instead of duplicating the nuclear capabilities of the American forces that were already defending Britain and Europe. He warned that: "We are a great nation, but if we continue to behave like a Great Power we shall soon cease to be a great nation. Let us take warning from the fate of the Great Powers of the past and not burst ourselves with pride." The government decided on 27 July 1954 to begin development of a thermonuclear bomb, and announced its plans in February 1955. British knowledge of thermonuclear weapons was based on the work done at the Los Alamos Laboratory during the war. Two British scientists,
Egon Bretscher and Klaus Fuchs, had attended the conference there on the Super (as it was then called) in April 1946, and Chadwick had written a secret report on it in May 1946, but the design was found to be unworkable. Some intelligence about Joe 4 was derived from its debris, which was provided to Britain under the 1948
Modus Vivendi. Penney established three megaton bomb projects at Aldermaston:
Orange Herald, a large boosted fission weapon;
Green Bamboo, an interim thermonuclear design similar to the Soviet Layer Cake used in Joe 4 and the American Alarm Clock; and Green Granite, a true thermonuclear design. A miniaturised Green Granite, known as Short Granite, was tested in the Grapple 1 test in the first of the
Operation Grapple test series. The bomb was dropped from a height of by a Vickers Valiant piloted by
Wing Commander Kenneth Hubbard, off the shore of
Malden Island in the Pacific on 15 May 1957. It was Britain's second airdrop of a nuclear bomb after the
Operation Buffalo test at
Maralinga on 11 October 1956, and the first of a thermonuclear weapon. Short Granite's yield was estimated at , far below its designed capability. Despite its failure, the test was hailed as a successful thermonuclear explosion, and the government did not confirm or deny reports that the UK had become a third thermonuclear power. The next test was Grapple 2, of Orange Herald, the first British weapon to incorporate an
external neutron initiator. It was dropped on 31 May, and exploded with a force of . The yield was the largest ever achieved by a single stage device, which made it technically a megaton weapon. The bomb was hailed as a hydrogen bomb, and the truth that it was actually a large fission bomb was kept secret by the British government until the end of the
Cold War. For the Grapple 3 test, Penney cancelled the planned Green Granite test and substituted Purple Granite, a Short Granite with some minor modifications. Its yield was a very disappointing , even less than Short Granite; the changes had not worked. Despite contemporary newspapers reporting the series as a success, the reports would not have fooled the American observers into thinking they were thermonuclear explosions, as they were involved in their analysis. When documents on the Grapple series began to be declassified in the 1990s, the tests were denounced as a hoax. An
Operational Requirement (OR1142) was issued in 1955 for a thermonuclear warhead for a
medium-range ballistic missile, which became
Blue Streak. This was revised in November 1955, with "megaton" replacing "thermonuclear". Orange Herald could then meet the requirement. Codenamed
Green Grass, the unsuccessful fusion boosting was omitted, and it used Green Bamboo's 72-lens implosion system instead of Orange Herald's 32. This allowed the amount of highly enriched uranium to be reduced from 120 to 75 kg. Its yield was estimated at . For use in the V bombers, it was placed in a Blue Danube casing to become
Violet Club. Road transport of the weapon was hazardous. As a safety measure 120,000 steel ball bearings were used to fill a cavity inside the core and keep the fissile components apart. In an accident, the steel bung was removed and the ball bearings spilled on the floor of an aircraft hangar, leaving the bomb armed and dangerous. About ten were delivered. The scientists at Aldermaston had not yet mastered the design of thermonuclear weapons. They produced a new design, called Round A. Another trial was scheduled, known as Grapple X. Round A was dropped on 8 November 1957. To save time and money, the target was off the southern tip of Christmas Island rather than off Malden Island, just from the airfield where 3,000 men were based. This time the yield of exceeded expectations. Round A was a true hydrogen bomb, but it used a relatively large quantity of expensive highly enriched uranium. was the aircraft that dropped the bomb in the Grapple 1 test in May 1957. Aldermaston had plenty of ideas about how to follow up Grapple X. A new design used
lithium deuteride that was less enriched in
lithium-6 (and therefore had more
lithium-7), but more of it, thereby reducing the amount of uranium-235 in the core. Because of the possibility of an international moratorium on atmospheric testing, plans for the trial, codenamed Grapple Y, were given verbal approval by the Prime Minister, and known only to a handful of officials. The bomb was dropped off Christmas Island on 28 April 1958. It had an explosive yield of about , and remains the largest British nuclear weapon ever tested. The design of Grapple Y was notably successful because much of its yield came from its thermonuclear reaction instead of fission of a uranium-238 tamper, making it a true hydrogen bomb, and because its yield had been correctly predicted—indicating that its designers understood what they were doing. Eisenhower, now US president, on 22 August 1958 announced a moratorium on nuclear testing. This did not mean an immediate end to testing; on the contrary, the United States, the Soviet Union and the United Kingdom all rushed to perform as much testing as possible before the deadline. A new British test series, known as Grapple Z, commenced on 22 August. It explored new technologies such as the use of external neutron initiators, which had first been tried out with Orange Herald. Core boosting using
tritium and external boosting with layers of lithium deuteride were successfully tested, allowing a smaller, lighter two-stage devices. The international moratorium commenced on 31 October 1958, and Britain ceased atmospheric testing for good.
An independent deterrent Believing that the United Kingdom was extremely vulnerable to a nuclear attack to which defence was impossible, the Chiefs of Staff and the RAF first advocated a British nuclear deterrence—not just nuclear weapons—in 1945: "It is our opinion that our only chance of securing a quick decision is by launching a devastating attack upon [enemy cities] with absolute weapons." In 1947, the Chiefs of Staff stated that even with American help the United Kingdom could not prevent the "vastly superior" Soviet forces from overrunning Western Europe, from which Russia could destroy Britain with missiles without using atomic weapons. Only "the threat of large-scale damage from similar weapons" could prevent the Soviet Union from using atomic weapons in a war. bombers
Air Chief Marshal Sir
John Slessor, who became Chief of the Air Staff in 1950, wrote that year that the Soviet superiority in European forces was so great that even "an ultimatum by Russia within the next two to three years" might cause Western Europe to surrender without a war. He feared that the United Kingdom might also do so "unless we can make ourselves far less defenceless than we are now." By 1952, the
Air Ministry had abandoned the concept of a conventional defence of Western Europe. The hydrogen bomb increased the threat to Britain. In 1957, a government study stated that although RAF fighters would "unquestionably be able to take a heavy toll of enemy bombers, a proportion would inevitably get through. Even if it were only a dozen, they could with megaton bombs inflict widespread devastation." Although disarmament remained a British goal, "the only existing safeguard against major aggression is the power to threaten retaliation with nuclear weapons." Churchill stated in a 1955 speech that deterrence would be "the parents of disarmament" and that, unless Britain contributed to Western deterrence with its own weapons, during a war the targets that threatened it the most might not be prioritised. The Prime Minister,
Harold Macmillan, advanced the position that nuclear weapons would give Britain influence over targeting and American policy, and would affect strategy in the Middle East and Far East. His
Minister of Defence,
Duncan Sandys, considered that nuclear weapons reduced Britain's dependence on the United States. The 1956
Suez Crisis demonstrated that Britain was no longer a great power, but increased the value to Britain of an independent nuclear deterrent that would give it greater influence with the US and USSR. While the military target of British nuclear weapons was the Soviet Union, the political target was the United States. Independent targeting was vital. The Chiefs of Staff believed that—contrary to Tizard's view—once the Soviet Union became able to attack the United States itself with nuclear weapons in the late 1950s, America might not risk its own cities to defend Europe, or not emphasise targets that endangered the United Kingdom more than the United States. Britain thus needed the ability to convince the USSR that attacking Europe would be too costly regardless of American participation. Part of the perceived effectiveness of an independent deterrent was the willingness to target enemy cities. Slessor saw atomic weapons as a way to avoid a third devastating world war given that the two previous ones had begun without them. When
Air Marshal Sir
George Mills became head of RAF Bomber Command in 1955 he similarly insisted on targeting Soviet cities.
Renewed American partnership The Soviet Union's launch of
Sputnik 1, the world's first
artificial satellite, on 4 October 1957, came as a tremendous shock to the American public, who had trusted that American technological superiority ensured their invulnerability. Now, suddenly, there was incontrovertible proof that, in some areas at least, the Soviet Union was actually ahead. In the widespread calls for action in response to the
Sputnik crisis, officials in the United States and Britain seized an opportunity to mend the relationship with Britain that had been damaged by the Suez Crisis. Macmillan wrote to Eisenhower on 10 October urging that the two countries pool their resources to meet the challenge. British information security, or the lack thereof, no longer seemed so important now that the Soviet Union was apparently ahead, and British scientists had demonstrated that they understood how to build a hydrogen bomb with a different form of the
Teller-Ulam design to the Americans. The opposition that had derailed previous attempts was now absent. The McMahon Act was amended, paving the way for the
1958 US–UK Mutual Defence Agreement (MDA). Much of the HEU supplied by the US was used not for weapons, but as fuel for the growing fleet of UK
nuclear submarines. Under the MDA, the US supplied the UK with not just nuclear submarine propulsion technology, but a complete
S5W pressurised water reactor of the kind used to power the US submarines. This was used in the Royal Navy's first nuclear-powered submarine, , which was
launched in 1960 and
commissioned in 1963. The S5W had a
nuclear reactor core that used uranium enriched to between 93 and 97 per cent uranium-235. Reactor technology was transferred from Westinghouse to
Rolls-Royce, which used it as the basis for its
PWR1 reactor used in the UK's nuclear submarines. The MDA has been renewed or amended many times. Most amendments merely extended the treaty for another five or ten years; others added definitions and made minor changes. On 14 November 2024, the Mutual Defence Agreement was extended indefinitely. The nuclear weapon
supply chain of the United Kingdom depends on the United States. A 1974 US proliferation report discussing British nuclear and missile development noted that "In many cases, it is based on technology received from the US and could not legitimately be passed on without US permission." ==Weapons systems==