Jagger and Richards wrote the lyrics and much of the chord progression of "Paint It Black" the previous December during the first sessions for the then untitled album
Aftermath, and while on the
1966 Australian tour. Initially, the first group of sessions were to be released as an album by themselves, then titled
Could You Walk on the Water? In mid-January 1966, the British press announced that a new Rolling Stones LP carrying that title would be released on 10 March. In
Rolling with the Stones, Wyman refers to the announcement as "audacity" on Oldham's part. A Decca spokesman said the company would not issue an album with such a title "at any price"; Oldham's idea upset executives at the company's American distributor,
London Records, who feared the allusion to
Jesus walking on water would provoke a negative response from
Christians. The title controversy embroiled the Stones in a conflict with Decca, delaying the Stones' next studio album's release from March to April 1966. The delay, however, gave the Stones more time to record new material for the upcoming album, which had now been retitled
Aftermath. Upon their return from Australasia, it was one of the new songs worked on for the revised new album. "Paint It Black" was recorded as the Stones had begun to take more time recording their material. Referring to the atmosphere of the Stones' sessions at the time, Richards told
Beat Instrumental magazine in February 1966: "Our previous sessions have always been rush jobs. This time we were able to relax a little, take our time."
Sound engineer Dave Hassinger recorded the song on 6 and 9 March 1966 at
RCA Studios in
Los Angeles.
Andrew Loog Oldham produced the track, as with all of the Stones' recordings until 1967. Both the single's US and UK B-sides were also recorded on these dates, as were a majority of album tracks for
Aftermath. "Paint It Black" follows a simple verse form that lacks a
refrain. It starts with five consecutive 16-bar verses before relaxing into a chanted section and finishing in a frantic
coda. The song was written originally as a standard
pop arrangement in a
minor key similar to "
The House of the Rising Sun", which Jagger humorously compared to "songs for
Jewish weddings". The Stones were dissatisfied with this version and considered scrapping the song altogether. During a session break,
Bill Wyman twiddled with a
Hammond organ in search of a heavier
bass sound; Wyman's playing inspired the
uptempo and Eastern melody. The sitar was brought into the
mix when Harihar Rao walked into the studio with one in hand. With the sitar, Jones combined his recent melodic improvisations with the chord progression and lyrics provided by Jagger and Richards. Soon after the recording session, Richards felt that the track's conclusion was over-recorded and that it could have been improved. This song may have the first recorded example of a
fretless bass guitar. Wyman had removed the frets from a bass intending to replace them, but became enamoured with the fretless sound. This can be most easily heard near the end of each vocal line, when Wyman plays high on the bass's neck, using the upper register. Wyman was later critical of Oldham listing Jagger and Richards as songwriters to the exclusion of the rest of the Stones. He felt that "Paint It Black" should have been credited to the band's pseudonym,
Nanker Phelge, rather than Jagger–Richards, since the song's final arrangement originated from a studio improvisation by Jones, Watts and himself, and Jones was responsible for providing the melody line on the sitar. In the view of pop historian Andrew Grant Jackson, "Paint It Black" bears a strong resemblance to
the Supremes' 1965 hit "
My World Is Empty Without You", which used "a foreboding minor key with harpsichord and organ". == Music and lyrics ==