In 1959, following a 17−0 loss to
USC, Hayes threw a punch at
Los Angeles Examiner sportswriter Al Bine, who had asked Hayes why he lost, but missed, and punched the brother of
Pasadena Independent sports editor Bob Shafer in the back instead. In a May 1965 meeting of Big Ten Conference athletic directors and coaches, Hayes nearly started a fight with
Iowa's athletic director,
Forest Evashevski, before being restrained. Prior to the
1973 Rose Bowl, Hayes shoved a camera into the face of a news photographer. As a result, Hayes was suspended for three games, fined $2,000, and left California with a
subpoena. In 1977, a late fumble at Michigan caused Hayes to charge at
ABC cameraman Mike Freedman, who recorded his frustration while laughing at him. Hayes was
ejected, put on
probation by the Big Ten Conference, and fined $2,000.
1962 Rose Bowl vote In the 1961 season, Ohio State won the Big Ten championship, qualifying automatically for the Rose Bowl. At the time, the Big Ten Conference rules stated that the school's Faculty Council must officially approve of the trip. In this unusual development, the Ohio State Faculty Council voted 28 to 25 against the
1962 Rose Bowl trip, prompted by the head of a university alumni group, on the grounds that the school's academic reputation was suffering because of over-emphasis on the football team. Other reports stated that the bid was declined because Ohio State had already beaten their would-be Rose Bowl opponent,
UCLA, during the regular season. The decision sparked minor rioting on the Ohio State campus and in the Columbus area. The
Columbus Dispatch published the names, addresses, and phone numbers of those Faculty Council Members who voted against the trip as well as the amount of university money that they spent on the trips. While Hayes was diplomatic with some faculty members who voted against the trip and urged the students to cease complaining, he did not spare his criticism of the alumni club president who led the charge against accepting the bowl bid. Hayes confronted the alumni president, launched a profanity-laced tirade against him, punched him in the stomach and knocked the wind out of him.
Comments on the My Lai Massacre Speaking at a football
banquet in 1969, Hayes spoke about the recently revealed
My Lai Massacre. He stated that the Vietnamese men in My Lai deserved to die, "and I wouldn't be so sure those women were innocent. The children are obviously innocent – if they are less than five."
Confrontation with Jerry Markbreit in 1974 Late in the 1971 rivalry game against
Michigan in
Ann Arbor, furious over what he thought was a missed defensive
pass interference foul by
Thom Darden of Michigan, Hayes stormed onto the field, launched a profanity-laced tirade at referee
Jerry Markbreit, and tore up the sideline markers, receiving a 15-yard
unsportsmanlike conduct penalty. Hayes then threw the penalty flag into the crowd, a kicking tee at Markbreit, began destroying the yard markers, and threw the first-down marker into the ground like a
javelin before being restrained by Buckeyes team officials; Hayes was then assessed an additional 15-yard penalty and ejected. Hayes was suspended for one game and fined $1,000 ().
1978 Gator Bowl incident and dismissal On December 29, 1978, the Buckeyes played in the
Gator Bowl against
Clemson. Late in the fourth quarter, Clemson was leading Ohio State 17–15. Freshman quarterback
Art Schlichter managed to get Ohio State into field goal range. On third and 5 at the Clemson 24-yard line with 2:30 left and the clock running, Hayes called a pass rather than a run, because Schlichter was having a great game up to that point. Schlichter's next pass was intercepted by Clemson
nose guard Charlie Bauman, who returned it toward the Ohio State sideline, where he was run out of bounds. After Bauman stood up facing the OSU sideline Hayes punched him in the throat, triggering a
bench-clearing brawl. Hayes stormed onto the field and in a profanity-laced tirade was abusive towards the referee. When one of Hayes' own players, offensive lineman
Ken Fritz, tried to intervene Hayes turned on him and had to be restrained by defensive coordinator George Hill. The Buckeyes were assessed two 15-yard unsportsmanlike conduct penalties for Hayes' attack on Bauman and his abuse towards the referee. Bauman was not injured by Hayes' punch and shrugged the incident off. Even though the game was being telecast by ABC, neither announcer
Keith Jackson nor co-announcer
Ara Parseghian saw or commented about the punch. The next morning, after a brief but heated meeting in which profanities were exchanged, Hindman told Hayes that he had been fired. A press conference was held at the hotel where the team had been staying. The team returned to Columbus around noon, and Hayes left the airport in a state police car. Regarding Hayes' dismissal, Enarson said that "there isn't a university or athletic conference in this country that would permit a coach to physically assault a college athlete." After the incident, Hayes reflected on his career by saying, "Nobody despises to lose more than I do. That's got me into trouble over the years, but it also made a man of mediocre ability into a pretty good coach." About two months after the incident, Hayes called Bauman in his dorm room, but did not apologize for his previous attack on him.
Earle Bruce succeeded Hayes as Ohio State's head coach. Many years later,
Leonard Downie, Jr., former executive editor of
The Washington Post and student journalist at Ohio State, said he regretted not reporting an incident in the 1960s where Hayes instructed a player to take off his helmet and then hit him in the head. “I could have prevented so much trauma for so many” he said. “For that I am truly regretful.” ==Final days and death==