First term Buttigieg ran for the Democratic nomination for
mayor of South Bend in 2011. In a
PBS Michiana – WNIT broadcast, he expressed his desire to reinvigorate South Bend, especially with respect to job creation and education. Buttigieg campaigned on other issues, such as pursuing international investment, increasing presence of police and other safety professionals, and improving city services. Buttigieg won his primary election against four opponents on May 3, 2011, receiving 7,663 votes. Buttigieg was elected mayor of South Bend in the
November 2011 general election with 10,991 of the 14,883 votes cast, or 74 percent of all votes. He defeated Republican nominee Norris W. Curry Jr. and
Libertarian nominee Patrick M. Farrell. Buttigieg took office in January 2012 at the age of 29, becoming the second-youngest mayor in South Bend history and the youngest incumbent mayor, at the time, of a U.S. city with at least 100,000 residents. Buttigieg also dismissed the department's communications director, who had discovered the recordings but continued to record the line at Boykins's command. Buttigieg has written that his "first serious mistake as mayor" came shortly after taking office in 2012, when he decided to ask for Boykins's resignation. Backed by supporters and legal counsel, Boykins requested reinstatement. When Buttigieg denied his request, Boykins, as the city's first African American police chief, sued the city for racial discrimination, arguing that the taping policy had existed under previous police chiefs, who were white. Buttigieg settled the lawsuits brought by Boykins and the four officers out of court for over $800,000. A federal judge ruled in 2015 that Boykins's recordings violated the
Federal Wiretap Act. As mayor, Buttigieg promoted a number of development and redevelopment projects. Buttigieg was a leading figure behind the creation of a nightly laser-light display along downtown South Bend's St.Joseph River trail as public art. The project cost $700,000, which was raised from private funds. The "River Lights" installation was unveiled in May 2015 as part of the city's 150th anniversary celebrations. Buttigieg's administration oversaw the sale of numerous city-owned properties. One of Buttigieg's signature programs was the "Vacant and Abandoned Properties Initiative". Known locally as
1,000 Properties in 1,000 Days, it was a project to repair or demolish blighted properties across South Bend. The program reached its goal two months before its scheduled end date in November 2015. By the thousandth day of the program, before Buttigieg's first term ended, nearly 40 percent of the targeted houses were repaired, and 679 were demolished or under contract for demolition. Buttigieg took note of the fact that many homes within communities of color were the ones demolished, leading to early distrust between the city and these communities. While mayor, Buttigieg served for seven months in Afghanistan as a lieutenant in the
U.S. Navy Reserve, returning to the United States on September 23, 2014. In his absence, Deputy Mayor Mark Neal, South Bend's city
comptroller, served as executive from February 2014 until Buttigieg returned to his role as mayor in October 2014. In 2015, during the controversy over
Indiana Senate Bill 101the original version of which was widely criticized for allowing discrimination against lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender peopleButtigieg emerged as a leading opponent of the legislation. Amid his reelection campaign, he
came out as
gay and expressed his solidarity with the LGBTQ community.
Second term Buttigieg announced in 2014 that he would seek a second term in
2015. He won the
Democratic primary with approximately 78 percent of the vote, defeating Henry Davis Jr., the city councilman from the second district. In November 2015, he was elected to his second term as mayor with over 80 percent of the vote, defeating Republican Kelly Jones by a margin of 8,515 to 2,074 votes. After winning reelection, Buttigieg signed an executive order helping to establish a recognized
city identification card in 2016. To improve South Bend's downtown area, Buttigieg proposed a Smart Streets urban development program in 2013. Smart Streets was a
complete streets implementation program aimed at improving economic development and urban vibrancy as well as road safety. Elements of the project were finished in 2016, The City of South Bend partnered with the State of Indiana and private developers to break ground on a $165-million renovation of the former
Studebaker complex in 2016, hoping that the redevelopment would facilitate industrial and housing units. This development is in the Renaissance District which includes nearby Ignition Park. In 2017, it was announced that the long-abandoned Studebaker Building84, also known as
Ivy Tower, would have its exterior renovated with $3.5million in Regional Cities funds from the State of Indiana and another $3.5million from South Bend tax increment financing, with plans for the building and other structures in its complex to serve as a technology hub. The website
Best Cities later ranked South Bend number 39 on its 2020 list of the 100 best small cities in the
United States, citing Buttigieg's efforts to revitalize the Studebaker factory and Downtown South Bend. Under Buttigieg, the city also began a smart sewer program, the first phase of which was finished in 2017 at a cost of $150million. The effort used federal funds and by 2019 had reduced the combined sewer overflow by 75 percent. The Common Council approved Buttigieg's request to enable his administration to develop a city climate plan in April 2019; Buttigieg signed a contract with the Chicago firm Delta Institute to help develop it. In late November 2019, the city's Common Council voted 7–0 to approve the resultant Carbon Neutral 2050 plan, setting the goal of meeting the Paris Agreement's 26-percent emission reduction by 2025, and aiming for a further reductions of 45 percent by 2035. Supporting private development in South Bend was another initiative Buttigieg continued during his second term. By 2019, the city had seen $374million in private investment for
mixed-use developments since Buttigieg had taken office, by one estimate.
station, from the airport to downtown With respect to infrastructure, Buttigieg promoted
the idea of moving the city's South Shore Line station from South Bend International Airport to the city's downtown in August 2018. He made it a goal to have the city complete this project by 2025. Also, South Bend launched Commuters Trust, a new
transportation benefit program created in collaboration with local employers and transportation providers, including
South Bend Transpo and
Lyft, in 2019. The program was made possible by a $1million three-year grant from
Bloomberg Philanthropies Mayors Challenge. Furthermore, under Buttigieg, South Bend invested $50million in the city's parks, many of which had been neglected during the preceding decades. Soon after Logan's death, Buttigieg presided over a
town hall meeting attended by disaffected activists from the African American community as well as relatives of the deceased man. The local police union accused Buttigieg of making decisions for political gain. Buttigieg secured $180,000 in November 2019 to commission a review of South Bend's police department policies and practices, to be conducted by Chicago-based consulting firm 21CP Solutions. Some African Americans have accused Buttigieg of racism for his response to this and other incidents. Former South Bend councilman Henry Davis Jr. alleged that Buttigieg "perpetuated and tolerated" systemic racism in the city. Michael Harriot, senior writer at
The Root, accused Buttigieg of "racist paternalism" for saying that children of color lack role models that promote the value of education. Many African Americans also point to Buttigieg's firing of Darryl Boykins, South Bend's first black chief of police. Boykins claimed that Buttigieg used a scandal—involving secret tapes of white police officers making racist comments—as a pretext for firing him.
Increased national profile In the
2016 U.S. Senate election in Indiana, he campaigned on behalf of
Democratic Senate nominee
Evan Bayh and criticized Bayh's opponent,
Todd Young, for having voiced support in 2010 for retaining the military's
don't ask, don't tell policy, which Bayh had
voted to repeal. In the
2016 Democratic presidential primaries, Buttigieg endorsed
Hillary Clinton. He also endorsed Democratic nominee Lynn Coleman in
that year's election for
Indiana's 2nd congressional district, which included South Bend.
Frank Bruni of
The New York Times published a 2016 column praising Buttigieg's work as mayor, with a headline asking if he might be "the first gay president".
Barack Obama cited him as one of the Democratic Party's talents in a November 2016 profile on the outgoing president conducted by
The New Yorker. As Buttigieg's national profile grew following his run in the
2017 Democratic National Committee chairmanship election, Buttigieg increased his out-of-city travel. By early 2018, there was speculation that Buttigieg would run for either governor or president in 2020. For the
2018 midterms, Buttigieg founded the political action committee (PAC)
Hitting Home PAC. That October, Buttigieg personally endorsed 21 congressional candidates. He also later endorsed Mel Hall, Democratic nominee in
the 2018 election for Indiana's 2nd congressional district. Buttigieg campaigned for Joe Donnelly's reelection campaign in the
United States Senate election in Indiana. Buttigieg campaigned for candidates in more than a dozen states, including early presidential primary states such as
Iowa and
South Carolina, a move indicating potential interest in running for president.
Succession as mayor Buttigieg announced that he would not seek a third term as mayor of South Bend in December 2018. Buttigieg endorsed
James Mueller in the
2019 South Bend mayoral election.{{cite web |title=South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg endorses James Mueller as his pick to replace him == DNC chairmanship campaign ==