Empire has been described by the
London Review of Books as "the most successful work of political theory to come from the Left for a generation." The book has been highly influential on numerous debates within the left, and has even been called "a bible of the anti-globalisation movement" by one critic and "the most influential book in recent decades on a classic sociological theme". In a review of the book,
Slavoj Žižek stated that the book "sets as its goal, writing the
Communist Manifesto for the twenty-first century", although he criticised it as "
pre-Marxist" in its failure to relate radical demands (such as
global citizenship and
guaranteed minimum income) to the "
inherent antagonisms" of the
capitalist process that would
make their realisation possible.
Gopal Balakrishnan, reviewing the book for the
New Left Review, wrote that when compared with influential conservative books such as
Francis Fukuyama's
The End of History and the Last Man, "Comparable totalizations from the Left have been few and far between; diagnoses of the present more uniformly bleak. At best, the alternative to surrender or self-delusion has seemed to be a combative but clear-eyed pessimism, orienting the mind for a Long March against the new scheme of things. In this landscape, the appearance of Empire represents a spectacular break. Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri defiantly overturn the verdict that the last two decades have been a time of punitive defeats for the Left."
Empire has created intellectual debates around its arguments. Certain scholars have compared the evolution of the world order with Hardt and Negri's world image in
Empire. A number of publications and debates centered on the book, both positively and negatively. Hardt and Negri's theoretical approach has also been compared and contrasted with works of 'the global capitalism school' whose authors have analyzed transnational capitalism and class relations in the global epoch. Hardt and Negri published an essay titled "
Empire 20 Years On" in the November/December 2019 edition of
New Left Review, in which they provide a critical analysis of the book's legacy and their perspective on it looking back. == See also ==