Economy and
LPR are shown as very similar ideologically to PiS. The party supports a state-guaranteed minimum
social safety net and extensive state intervention in the economy, and argues that a "more socially sensitive and less market-dominated" economic system is necessary. It seeks to increase healthcare spending to 6% of the Polish GDP, and nationalize hospital debts. During the 2015 election campaign, it proposed tax rebates related to the number of children in a family, as well as a reduction of the
VAT rate (while keeping a variation between individual types of VAT rates). In 2019, the lowest personal income tax threshold was decreased from 18% to 17%. Its policies have been described as redistributive, and that its 2015–2023 government marked "the first time in over two decades that a government had taken steps to curb the neoliberal dismantling of social services" in Poland. Law and Justice is described as state-interventionist and anti-privatisation, opposing flat tax and favoring a
welfare state based on extensively developed state-run health service. In its 2006-2007 government, it committed to expanding welfare spending and the role of the state in the economy, often at expense of foreign investors and the
European Commission. It halted the construction of foreign-owned supermarkets and prevent the existing ones from opening on Sundays in an effort to prevent monopolization. In 2006, it also set up commissions to investigate and scrutinize sale of Polish banks to foreign entities after 1989, and to investigate the role of the
Polish Central Bank in privatization. And subsequently on an annual basis starting in 2020. A
14th pension was introduced on 21 January 2021 and is now paid out with
13th pension. PiS opposes cutting social welfare spending, and also proposed the introduction of a system of state-guaranteed housing loans. The party also opposes foreign ownership of crucial industries and businesses, and proposed buying back the largest convenience store chain in Poland,
Żabka, from its foreign owners. It also supports state provided
universal health care. PiS has been also described as
statist,
protectionist,
solidarist, and
interventionist. It also holds
agrarianist views. Given the redistributive and protectionist agenda of the party as well as its focus on welfare and nationalization, political scientists classify Law and Justice as economically left-wing.
Reuters, and The Routledge Handbook of East European Politics. Political economist Cédric M. Koch wrote that PiS combines "political communitarianism with neo-socialist economic views". The economic policies of Law and Justice marked a notable departure from the economically liberal policies of other Polish governments. The party rallies against the "Republic of the Rich", highlighting the wealth inequality in Poland and the need for redistribution and welfare expansion. The party's former Prime Minister
Mateusz Morawiecki stated: "It turns out that the rules of capitalism are not sacred, inviolable and uniform... in the new Polish economic and social model we are demonstrating to Europe how social solidarity can be coupled with dynamic economic development. Solidarism should be that economic system." Morawiecki also asserted that the "socialist working-class thought is deeply rooted in the philosophy of Law and Justice". Jarosław Kaczyński in turn argued: "The left has completely lost its social sensitivity (...), social sensitivity is here today, among other places, right where I am at this moment. And if it were to be associated with left-wing politics — because it is obviously not true that social sensitivity has ever been the monopoly of the left — then it has to be said that the left is here, not there." Political scientists Haris Dajč and Natasza Styczyńska write of a political realignment that Law and Justice embodies: Writing on the economic policies of Law and Justice and their character, American political scientist wrote: Political scientists Michał Zabdyr-Jamróz, Olga Löblová, Alexandru D. Moise, and Iwona Kowalska-Bobko argued that PiS is ideologically "a combination of Christian conservatism in cultural policies and social-democratic welfare policies". They noted that PiS generally refrained from
welfare chauvinism, "making it look almost social-democratic in comparison to the chauvinism of Western European parties". Law and Justice's return to power in 2015 marked a departure from neoliberalism, and made PiS a competition not only to the nominally left
Lewica, but also even more economically left-oriented groups. Its economic approach has been described as left-wing, "neo-Weberian", and social-democratic; it focused especially on expanding healthcare access and guaranteeing free-of-charge services. and wrote: The economic views and policies of Law and Justice derive from the Polish political party
Self-Defence of the Republic of Poland (Samoobrona) led by
Andrzej Lepper. Law and Justice appropriated the economic rhetoric and views of Samoobrona following its complete collapse in the
2007 Polish parliamentary election. Samoobrona is an economically far-left party, much further left than parties of post-communist origin such as the social-democratic
Democratic Left Alliance. After Samoobrona and the far-right anti-capitalist League of Polish Families (LPR) formed a coalition with PiS in 2006 in order to prevent the neoliberal Civic Platform from coming to power, Law and Justice managed to claim the voters of both parties by "taking up economically inclusionary discourse from the originally left-wing Self-Defence and outbidding the LPR on cultural conservatism". Similarly, Polish political scientist Marek M. Kamiński described PiS as "culturally conservative, economically social democratic".
Foreign Affairs remarked that the program of PiS "amounts to a very leftist (or, rather, a Catholic socialist) set of economic policies", listing policies such as increasing minimum wage, abolishing short-term job contracts, limiting self-employment contracts abused by employers to avoid benefit payments, decreasing retirement age, increasing family benefits, implementing social payments for large families, and enacting a special tax on foreign banks' assets and foreign big stores. Igor S. Putintsev wrote that "the political views of PiS are 70% right-wing and socioeconomic ones 100% left-wing", arguing that PiS pursuses a "proactive and consistent social policy", which included its 500+ state program, annulment of neoliberal pension reforms carried out under Civic Platform and reduction in retirement age. Putintsev credited PiS with constructing "a Polish model of a modern welfare state". The party claims to represent the "marginalised vast majority of Poles" who had to bear the costs of capitalist transformation, and states that its main goal is to provide the "common man its fair economic share of societal resources". Law and Justice is highly critical of
neoliberalism, describing it as "anti-family" and arguing that neoliberal policies are responsible for social inequality, as well as maximizing profit at the cost of the "ordinary people" and "Catholic values". The party proposes increasing social benefit payments, raising the minimum wage, increasing expenditures on child nutrition and benefits to worse-off families. It also postulates more subsidies and state control of the Polish infrastructure, and expansion of the healthcare and education system. The party also opposes privatization, stating: "We cannot deprive the state of influence and responsibility for the social order, in particular for the weakest social groups whose situation as a result of the transformation has been rapidly deteriorating." The party moderated its policies in the wake of its coalition with far-left Samoobrona and far-right LPR in 2006, as both parties demanded withdrawal of Polish troops from Iraq and Afghanistan, and distancing Poland from the European Union. Ever since its founding in 2001, Law and Justice had a catalogue of complex reforms in the sphere of defence and national security, which it also connected to economic matters. The party postulates a national security law that would expand the legal capabilities of special and public security services. Law and Justice proposed monitoring key industries such as energy, telecommunications, banking as well as stock exchange, including taking note of the ownership situation in these economic sectors and the main companies operating in these fields. The national security act and extensive monitoring of the economy were to provide the basis for the Polish government to safeguard economic security by partial or complete compulsory state buyouts of companies "whose operation on the market creates a direct or potential threat to national security". In this way, the party connected its anti-privatization views with its law-and-order proposals. although the party supports integration with the
European Union on terms beneficial for Poland. It supports economic integration and tightening cooperation in areas of energy security and military operations, but is sceptical about closer political integration. It is against the formation of a European
superstate or federation. PiS is in favour of a strong political and military alliance between Poland and the United States. In 2006, Kaczyński spoke of the EU: "My opinion of the EU is the following: A super state which polarizes countries' areas of competence but which at the same time is rather helpless because it only has a symbolic budget... The EU is an artificial creation." and
anti-Russian stances. It has taken a hardline stance against Russia in its foreign policy since the party's foundation. The party vocally advocated for military aid to
Ukraine during the 2022
Russian invasion of Ukraine, but announced it would halt arms transfers in September 2023 following disagreements over the export of Ukrainian grain to Poland. The party has been described as divided between pro-Ukrainian and anti-Ukrainian factions. PiS has historically advocated for a
pro-Israel policy, although relations with Israel deteriorated following the 2018
Amendment to the Act on the Institute of National Remembrance and subsequent
diplomatic incidents. In opposition, PiS called for the expulsion of the Israeli Ambassador following the
World Central Kitchen drone strikes, in which a Polish citizen was killed. The PiS government supported
accession of Turkey to the European Union. PiS also advocates for a strong relationship with Hungary under
Viktor Orbán, though they diverged over the
Russo-Ukrainian War. Law and Justice criticised the Polish government's decision in 2008 to
recognise the independence of Kosovo from Serbia.
Social policies The party's views on social issues are much more traditionalist than those of
social conservative parties in other European countries, and its social views reflect those of the
Christian right. PiS has been described to hold
right-wing populist views. The party presents itself as a champion of Catholicism, and in accordance with the
Catholic social teaching, it opposes euthanasia and legal recognition of homosexual couples. It also supports strengthening restrictions on abortion. However, the party also took positions that conflicted with the Church's teaching, such as favoring the
death penalty or demonstrating flexible stances on
stem cell research and
vitro fertilization.
Family The party strongly promotes itself as a pro-family party and encourages married couples to have more children. Prior to 2005 elections, it promised to build three million inexpensive housing units as a way to help young couples start a family. Once in government, it passed legislation lengthening
parental leaves. In 2017, the PiS government commenced the so-called "500+" programme under which all parents residing in Poland receive an unconditional monthly payment of 500 PLN for each second and subsequent child (the 500 PLN support for the first child being linked to income). It also revived the idea of a housing programme based on state-supported construction of inexpensive housing units. Also in 2017, the party's MPs passed a law that bans most retail trade on Sundays on the premise that workers will supposedly spend more time with their families.
Abortion in Kraków (Five stars represent a
common profanity, three represent the party name.) The party is
anti-abortion and supports further restrictions on
Poland's abortion laws which are already one of the most restrictive in Europe. PiS opposes abortion resulting from
foetal defects which is currently allowed until specific foetal age. In 2016, PiS supported legislation to ban abortion under all circumstances, and investigate miscarriages. After the
black Protests the legislation was withdrawn. In October 2020, the Constitutional Court ruled that one of three circumstances (foetal defects) is unconstitutional. However, many constitutionalists argue that this judgement is invalid. The party is against
euthanasia and
comprehensive sex education. It has proposed a ban of
in-vitro fertilisation.
Disability rights In April 2018, the PiS government announced a PLN 23 billion (EUR 5.5 billion) programme (named "Accessibility+") aimed at reducing barriers for disabled people, to be implemented 2018–2025. Also in April 2018, parents of disabled adults who required long-term care protested in Sejm over what they considered inadequate state support, in particular, the reduction of support once the child turns 18. As a result, the monthly disability benefit for adults was raised by approx. 15 per cent to PLN 1,000 (approx. EUR 240) and certain non-cash benefits were instituted, although protesters' demands of an additional monthly cash benefit were rejected.
Gay rights The party opposes the
LGBT movement and many of its postulates, in particular
same-sex marriages and any other form of legal recognition of same-sex couples. In 2020, Poland was ranked the lowest of any European Union country for LGBT rights by
ILGA-Europe. The organisation also highlighted instances of
anti-LGBT rhetoric and hate speech by politicians of the ruling party. In
Bączkowski and Others v. Poland, the
European Court of Human Rights unanimously ruled that the ban of the parade violated Articles
11,
13 and
14 of the
European Convention on Human Rights. The judgement stated that "The positive obligation of a State to secure genuine and effective respect for freedom of association and assembly was of particular importance to those with unpopular views or belonging to minorities". In 2016,
Beata Szydło's government disbanded the Council for the Prevention of Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Intolerance, an advisory body set up in 2011 by then-Prime Minister
Donald Tusk. The council monitored, advised and coordinated government action against racism, discrimination and hate crime. Many local towns, cities, and
Voivodeship sejmiks comprising a third of Poland's territory have declared their respective regions as
LGBT-free zones with the encouragement of the ruling PiS. During his successful 2020 election campaign, he pledged he would ban teaching about LGBT issues in schools; he also proposed changing the constitution to ban LGBT couples from adopting children.
Nationalism Academic research has characterised Law and Justice as a partially nationalist party, but PiS's leadership rejects this label. Both Kaczyńskis look up for inspirations to the pre-war
Sanacja movement with its leader
Józef Piłsudski, in contrast to the nationalist
Endecja that was led by Piłsudski's political archrival,
Roman Dmowski. However, parts of the party, especially the faction around
Radio Maryja, are inspired by Dmowski's movement. Polish far-right organisations and parties such as
National Revival of Poland,
National Movement and
Autonomous Nationalists regularly criticise PiS's relative ideological moderation and its politicians for "monopolizing" official political scene by playing on the popular patriotic and religious feelings. However, the party does include several overtly nationalist politicians in senior positions, such as Digital Affairs Minister
Adam Andruszkiewicz, the former leader of the
All-Polish Youth; and deputy PiS leader and former Defence Minister
Antoni Macierewicz, the founder of the
National-Catholic Movement. It has been also described as
national-conservative.
Refugees and economic migrants PiS opposed the quota system for mass relocation of immigrants proposed by the European Commission to address the 2015
European migrant crisis. This contrasted with the stance of their main political opponents, the
Civic Platform, which have signed up to the commission's proposal. Consequently, in the campaign leading to the
2015 Polish parliamentary election, PiS adopted the discourse typical of the
populist-right, linking national security with immigration. Following the election, PiS sometimes utilised Islamophobic rhetoric to rally its supporters. Examples of anti-migration and anti-
Islam comments by PiS politicians when discussing the European migrant crisis: in 2015,
Jarosław Kaczyński stated that Poland can not accept any refugees because "they could spread infectious diseases." In 2017, the first Deputy Minister of Justice
Patryk Jaki stated that "stopping
Islamization is his
Westerplatte". In 2017, Interior minister of Poland
Mariusz Błaszczak stated that he would like to be called "
Charles the Hammer who
stopped the Muslim invasion of Europe in the 8th century". In 2017, Deputy Speaker of the Sejm
Joachim Brudziński stated during the pro-party rally in
Siedlce; "if not for us (PiS), they (Muslims) would have built mosques in here (Poland)." ==Structure==