Context Site The neighborhood of
Morningside Heights was thinly settled in the 17th century by the Dutch, then by the English. It remained rural through the mid-19th century, with two exceptions. The first was the
Bloomingdale Insane Asylum, which opened in 1821 and moved to Westchester in 1889. The other was
Leake and Watts Orphan Asylum, bounded by 110th Street to the south and 113th Street to the north, which later became the current cathedral site. The Leake and Watts asylum was incorporated in 1831 under act of the
New York State Legislature, and three years later, of land at the corner of Bloomingdale Road (now Broadway) and 110th Street was purchased from the Bloomingdale Asylum. The initial plans for the asylum were drawn up by
Ithiel Town, but were revised several times to keep the costs within the asylum's budget.
Need for a cathedral Meanwhile, the
Episcopal Diocese of New York started to grow in the early 19th century: there were 26 Episcopal parishes in the city by 1800, and a decade later, that number had nearly doubled to 50. In 1828, the first proposal for a grand cathedral for the diocese was made by Bishop
John Henry Hobart, who proposed a site near
Washington Square Park. The church would be called the Cathedral of St. John the Divine, or St. John's Cathedral for short, after
the Revelation by
John of Patmos (also called "John the Divine"). Yet another plot of land, at
Eighth Avenue and 74th Street, was offered to the church in 1882, but rejected due to the high cost of acquisition. By 1890, there were 40,000 Episcopalians in Manhattan, and Episcopalians made up the largest bloc of Protestants in the borough.
Planning Site selection When
Henry C. Potter, Horatio Potter's nephew, became the Diocese of New York's assistant bishop in 1883, he convened the trustees to look for an alternative site. that would rival the Catholic
St. Patrick's Cathedral in
Midtown Manhattan. In his announcement, Potter called on New Yorkers to give funds toward the new cathedral, which was expected to cost $10 million. The plans for the cathedral were well received by both Protestants and non-Protestants, as well as the media and other denominational leaders. The donors included the wealthy
Astor,
Vanderbilt, and Belmont families. Numerous sites in Manhattan were examined for the new cathedral's location, and by 1889, the Leake and Watts Asylum between 110th and 113th Streets had been chosen as the site for the future site of St. John's. News media such as
The New York Times and
Uptown Visitor praised the decision, as the site was located on a high point overlooking Central and
Morningside parks. The committee had wanted to build slightly further north, on a more elevated plot between
116th Street to the south and 119th Street to the north. However, that plot would be too difficult to acquire, as ownership of that tract was divided among several entities; by contrast, the Leake and Watts Asylum had full control over their entire city block. The asylum site was deeded to the cathedral in October 1891, and the asylum moved to
Westchester County, New York. The asylum site was then acquired for $850,000. At the time, Morningside Heights was quickly being developed as a residential neighborhood surrounded by numerous higher-education institutions.
Architecture competition There was also debate over the new cathedral's style. Because of the larger plot and more remote location from Midtown Manhattan it was anticipated it could be more elaborate than St. Patrick's. The competition closed in January 1889. In May 1889 the trustees formed a committee to review the more than 60 designs submitted. The board members then discussed the designs privately; some architects expressed concerns about the secret consultations, since the trustees generally did not have professional knowledge of architecture. "Gerona" used the
Gothic style based on Spanish cathedrals; "AMDG" and "Jerusalem the Golden" were in a regular Gothic style, and "Three Arabesque Scrolls" was mainly
Byzantine. Potter and Robertson were the only finalists with significant experience at the time, and the trustees had agreed not to release any designs without the consent of all competitors, although some contestants broke this agreement and revealed their designs to the media. but was later extended to November after a failed proposal to host the
World's Columbian Exposition in Morningside Park. This design had been the trustees' second choice but although the trustees liked Potter and Robertson's plan more, W. A. Potter was the bishop's half-brother and the trustees did not want to be accused of nepotism. To Kent's consternation, he was initially not recognized as a co-collaborator, and would not be acknowledged as such until the following year. The design proposed an apse of radiating chapels
apses; a square
crossing defined by four round-headed arches, supporting a dome over which was rise a massive tower; and
transepts with round edges. The interior was based upon Boston's
Trinity Church, and the crossing was based upon Istanbul's
Hagia Sophia, Venice's
St. Mark's Basilica, and the
Périgueux Cathedral. The "exotic" design was seen as an example of the unusual architecture that was prevalent at that time. That October, the trustees directed the firm to revise their design further. The following month, it was announced that work would begin in early 1892, provided that Heins & LaFarge submitted their revised plans that April. The original plans were then substantially revised because the board of trustees wanted a Gothic-style appearance. The western towers were modified to remove the spires and enlarge the windows, and various Gothic details were placed on the facade. The nave was realigned from north–south to east–west so that the
apse would face east, in the direction of the sunrise, to represent the
resurrection of Jesus as per Episcopal tradition. Heins & LaFarge objected to the realignment because it would result in the cathedral being hidden behind other buildings.
Construction and early years Construction on the Cathedral of St. John the Divine was begun with the
cornerstone-laying ceremony on December 27, 1892, St. John's Day. One thousand tickets for seats at the ceremony were distributed, though the actual attendance was 1,100. The following month, the remaining $175,000 for land acquisition had been secured, and the trustees moved to take title to the land, including the
cathedral close around the cathedral's main building, in April. Unlike the main building, the cathedral close was not designed under a single master plan, and during the 1890s and 1900s, several proposals would be made for the site.
Initial construction Construction work began in early 1893. One of these pockets was located directly below the site for one of the four massive
piers that were to support the cathedral's stone tower. The trustees briefly considered moving the entire cathedral slightly southward. They decided against moving the cathedral, believing it to be inauspicious to move the cornerstone. The pits were completed in late 1895 at a significantly higher cost than originally estimated. and as per an 1896 estimate, the cathedral was projected to cost at least $5 million when complete. As a temporary measure, the
Tiffany Chapel was purchased in mid-1898 so that services could be held there. The chapel was placed in the
crypt, within the basement. The first services were held in January 1899 within the Tiffany Chapel. The crossing arches, located in the cathedral plot's eastern portion, were completed the following year, By then, some $2 million had already been spent, even though little appeared to have been completed. Despite large donations from prominent figures such as financiers
John Jacob Astor IV and
William Waldorf Astor, governor
Levi P. Morton, banker
J. P. Morgan, and businessman
Cornelius Vanderbilt, the trustees continued to raise funds. In March 1903, the trustees announced that the next stage of St. John's construction would require $500,000 for building the choir and $200,000 for completing the loft, and that eight massive
granite columns would need to be procured to support the roof over the choir. Furthermore, the trustees would build three arches to support the rest of the roof. Quarried in
Vinalhaven, Maine, each column was tall with a diameter—at the time, the world's second-largest stone columns. Each column comprises two parts—a lower section tall and weighing , and the upper section of and weighing —jointed so that the columns appear to be
monoliths. Because of their size, three of the columns were cracked while being
turned. The columns were then transported using a specially constructed barge towed by the large
steam tug Clara Clarita. When the columns arrived at Manhattan in July and August 1903, they were rolled onto flatbed trucks and brought to the cathedral's site. The builders lacked a
derrick strong enough to lift the column pieces, so they ordered wood to build one. The columns were finally lifted in July 1904, more than a year after the initial announcement. The board of trustees implemented a new charter in early 1904, which provided for greater representation of laypeople on the board. By 1905, with $800,000 available for construction, the trustees anticipated that the cathedral would be completed within a decade. The church's great organ was ordered from
Skinner the following year at a cost of $50,000 (), following a gift by the Morton family. It was almost completed by 1911 with nearly 7,000 pipes; the cost of the organ had risen to $70,000. Work also continued on the exterior walls of the choir and the seven surrounding chapels in the
apse, which required of granite. Builders estimated that of stone would have been used for the walls once work was completed.
Gutzon Borglum was commissioned for some of the initial sculptural elements on St. John's, though his relation with the trustees was strained: he destroyed two angels after criticism of his work and threatened to quit in 1906. Because of the delays in construction, members of the public began to question the necessity of constructing such a large cathedral.
Crossing opening and change in design Although Heins died in 1907, LaFarge continued to design the crossing, choir, and apse of St. John's. The choir was nearly complete by October 1909, but there were insufficient funds to complete its construction, delaying its opening by at least six months. At that time, St. John's was earning about $24,000 per year and had a $500,000 endowment, while at least $1 million was needed to complete construction. In March 1911, trustees finally confirmed an opening date of April 19, 1911. The first service in the choir and crossing, the
consecration of the choir, occurred as scheduled on that day. The completed portions of the cathedral were widely praised, though few newspapers devoted extensive coverage to the event, except the
New York Herald. The original Byzantine-Romanesque design was switched to a
Gothic design, and Cram was asked to convert many existing features to Gothic style. The move was criticized in the local media, However,
The New York Sun reported that Cram had only reluctantly accepted the commission because the trustees had threatened to hire an overseas architect. and his revised designs for the main structure were completed in 1913. Regardless, there was still not enough money to complete the cathedral's construction, as the New York Episcopal Diocese Cathedral League had mentioned in 1912 that $5.5 million was still needed. The diocese was able to construct several structures to the south of the main building (see ),
Nave and north transept By January 1916, Bishop
David H. Greer announced that the diocese would construct St. John's nave and
narthex, along with a pair of towers on the western
elevation of the facade above the narthex. The project would cost $1.5 million, even though St, John's only had about $200,000 on hand as of June 1915. A groundbreaking ceremony for the nave was held on May 8, 1916. That November, construction stopped due to material and funding shortages during
World War I, and the trustees had decided against raising funds until after the war. Cram edited his plans in the interim. The new plans required $5–6 million, but would make St. John's the
third- or fourth-largest worldwide. The cathedral did not yet have the money to build the nave, and furthermore, in 1920 the trustees decided not to hold fundraising drives for said purpose. Because of an unstable economy, work did not resume for another four years, The New York campaign committee, headed by
Franklin D. Roosevelt, campaigned from 1923 to 1925 to raise $6 million (). By May 1924, Manning announced that $2.5 million had been donated within the previous three months, and that work on the nave would soon begin if that rate of donation were to continue. St. John's was seeking price estimates for the nave's construction by that November, and the
baptistery was donated the same year. and the laying of the nave's cornerstone occurred on November 9, 1925. Manning wanted the cathedral to be an interdenominational place of worship, but was still reluctant to add other denominations' members to the board of trustees. Notably, Manning rejected a request from
John D. Rockefeller Jr., a Baptist, despite the latter's $500,000 donation toward the cathedral's building fund. Cram's blueprint revisions, published in 1929, entailed building the square tower over the crossing, and adding two portals to the western elevation. Since the funds for that transept were donated solely by women, it was called the Women's Transept. Construction at St. John's was otherwise unaffected by the
Great Depression. When construction of the Women's Transept resumed in 1934, the nave and the western elevation were nearly complete except for the two towers above the western facade, but work on the crossing tower and south transept had yet to commence. By 1938, the nave was completed, but the temporary construction wall between the nave and crossing was still in place because the Byzantine-Romanesque crossing's design had yet to be harmonized with the Gothic nave. As such, Cram subsequently replaced the portions of the ceiling above the choir and the apse's eastern section. Additionally, the nave started to be used for services, even though it had not yet been dedicated.
Full-length opening and expansion The full length of the Cathedral of St. John the Divine was opened for the first time on November 30, 1941. At that time, St. John's was only three-fifths completed, yet it was the second-largest Christian church in the world by area, behind only
St. Peter's Basilica in Vatican City. With the consequent
entry of the United States into World War II, work on the cathedral stopped. The southern transept and tower had yet to start, while the northern transept remained one-third complete. The western towers, planned to be , reached only to the roof of the nave. In 1945, Manning had attempted to start a fundraising drive for $10 million so that the remaining funds could be raised for the cathedral's completion. However, during the late 1940s, his successor Bishop
Charles Kendall Gilbert turned efforts toward alleviating social issues in the vicinity of the cathedral. By that time, a total of $19 million had been spent on construction (equivalent to $ million in ). Several plans were proposed through the early 1960s, but none were examined in depth. The trustees had approved a smaller version of the western towers and the crossing, with a modern multicolored dome to be built atop the crossing. The project did not proceed, as Bishop
Horace W. B. Donegan said that such work would not occur during his administration; rather, he wanted the construction money to instead go toward helping the poor. In the 1970s, the cathedral's activities turned toward improving quality of life in Morningside Heights; helping the elderly, young, and the environment; and participating in the
civil rights movement and the
opposition to United States involvement in the Vietnam War. However, when
the Very Reverend James Parks Morton was installed as St. John's dean in 1973, he said that construction at St. John's would start again. Morton said he wanted St. John's to become "a holy place for the whole city". St. John's had become overcrowded because of its increasing focus on community activities, and even though the cathedral was losing $500,000 each year, Morton believed that an expansion would help make space for these extra activities.
Resumption of work Morton announced in December 1978 that construction would soon begin on constructing the two western towers, extending their height by and bringing their total height to . The job was expected to cost $20 million and take five years. However, by then, there was a shortage of qualified stone carvers in the area. planned to employ unskilled younger workers from the surrounding community. The architect was Hoyle, Doran and Berry, the successor to Cram's architecture firm. The expansions would be based primarily on Cram's revised designs, published before his death. Construction started first on the south tower, named for
Saint Paul, By 1984, St. John's was projected to be complete in 2000. Under the leadership of master stone carvers Nicholas Fairplay,
Simon Verity, and
Jean Claude Marchionni, work on the statuary of the central portal of the cathedral's western elevation was started in 1988 and completed in 1997. During this era, the cathedral expanded its cultural programming, hosting some 140 shows and performances in the 1987–1988 season, some of which drew up to 3,000 observers. By 1992, the construction budget had been depleted; work was halted, and the stone yard was closed. By then, another of height had been added to the south tower. other portions remained, rusting away for fifteen years. The Very Reverend
Harry H. Pritchett Jr., who succeeded Morton in 1997, decided against further expansion of St. John's, especially since the existing facilities needed $20–40 million in repairs. Despite the damage sustained, St. John's reopened two weeks later. Though the
pipe organ was not damaged, all its pipes and other component parts were removed and restored. Valuable tapestries and other items in the cathedral were damaged by the smoke. In January 2005, the cathedral began a major restoration to not only remove smoke damage resulting from the 2001 fire, but also clean the 80 years of dirt accumulation in the nave. The renovations temporarily depleted St. John's funds: the unaffected portions of the cathedral started to deteriorate, staff salary raises were deferred, and several staff positions were eliminated. The scaffolding around the south tower was removed in 2007, At the same time, St. John's officials wanted to lease out the lots at the northern and southern borders of the cathedral close for further development, a move that preservationists unsuccessfully attempted to prevent. Ultimately, two residential buildings were erected on these lots:
Avalon Morningside Park on the southern lot and the Enclave on the northern lot. In 2017, the cathedral close was re-designated a city landmark, except for the two new residential buildings. The next year, the first phase of the north transept's renovation was finally completed, --> and work began on a renovation of the crypt. On April 14, 2019, a small fire occurred in the crypt; except for smoke damage, the cathedral building was mostly unaffected. Many artworks stored in the crypt were reportedly damaged or destroyed in the fire. An initial cleaning removed smoke damage from the bottom 10 feet of the interior of the cathedral. A cleaning of the rest of the interior was also ongoing.
Ennead Architects proposed erecting a copper dome above the crossing so that the crossing's tiles could be rehabilitated. The restoration of the dome was completed in 2022. A restoration of the organ, which had been damaged in the 2019 fire, was completed in December 2024. == Main structure ==