''Assassin's Apprentice
was viewed as the debut work of a new author, though a reviewer for Asimov's Science Fiction
noted her use of a pseudonym and remarked that the first two books appeared to be the "work of a seasoned professional". Publishers Weekly'' described the book as a "gleaming debut" in a crowded fantasy market, praising Hobb's portrayal of political machinations within royalty. A similar review from
Kirkus termed it "a remarkably assured debut". The sequels
Royal Assassin and ''Assassin's Quest
received starred reviews from Publishers Weekly
. The first book was a finalist for the British Fantasy Award in 1997; the second and third volumes were nominees for the Locus Award for Best Fantasy Novel in 1997 and 1998. The series as a whole was commercially successful: worldwide, the Elderlings'' sold more than a million copies by 2003, and UK sales alone had exceeded 1.25 million copies by 2017. The characters Hobb created received acclaim from several reviewers, and the
Farseer novels have been praised as works of character-driven fantasy. Writing in
The Times in 2005, critic
Amanda Craig praised Hobb's depiction of Fitz and stated that his bond with the wolf Nighteyes was as "passionate as the deepest romantic love". In 2014, the
Los Angeles Review of Books reviewer Ilana Teitelbaum described the novels as offering "complete immersion in Fitz's complicated personality", and remarked on the psychological complexity of Fitz's characterization, as well as Hobb's depiction of trauma. Teitelbaum praised the portrayal of Fitz's internal conflicts, noting that his emotional scars shape his perspective and that Fitz isn't ever able to escape them completely. An
Interzone review of the first book drew attention to the "wonderfully enigmatic" character of the Fool, whose riddles and predictions were only gifted to others similarly lonely. However, the reviewer criticized Galen, the Skillmaster, as "too manic to be credible". The novels' prose and fictional setting also drew praise. Scholar Darren Harris-Fain felt that Hobb's "skill" at
worldbuilding and characters set the trilogy above most fantasy.
David Langford similarly remarked on her construction of a "convincingly textured society" with strong characters, including women, and added that "Hobb writes achingly well".
Publishers Weekly described the wolf Nighteyes as her best creation, and Teitelbaum wrote that Hobb's "generosity with detail" allowed the castle of Buckkeep to become a "memorable setting".
Publishers Weekly also praised Hobb's "shimmering language", and
Fantasy & Science Fiction called her prose in the first volume "skillful", and
Library Journal considered it "gracefully written".
Interzone noted that Hobb's had avoided the "more obvious clichés", and that the book was "very occasionally brilliant", but found it "stylistically patchy". Fellow novelist
Steven Erikson has remarked on Hobb's writing of Fitz's perspective, describing it as a "quiet seduction" and "handled with consummate control, precision and intent". He uses chapters from the trilogy as reading material in his workshops for writers. The plot of the trilogy, according to Harris-Fain, was an "effectively balance[d]" blend of dark occurrences and warm moments between characters. In a review of ''Assassin's Apprentice
, Booklist felt the plot was traditional but praised its execution. The second book contained plot twists that drew praise from reviewers including Kirkus
, though the reviewer found "ominous signs" of the narrative losing control. A year later, Kirkus
termed the sequel an "enthralling conclusion". The length of the third book was criticized by Booklist'' and Langford, although both critics praised other facets of Hobb's writing.
Booklist felt the extra pages delivered in terms of "emotionally compelling scenes of both magic and battle". A review for
Locus praised the pacing of the third volume, adding that its "lively dialog" and divergence from a typical quest narrative made it a "great read". The
Farseer novels led to Hobb receiving broader recognition as an exemplar of fantasy writing. The trilogy, as well as its sequels, were viewed by
Library Journal as "masterworks of character-based epic fantasy". Comparing the first nine
Elderlings novels with the works of
Le Guin and
Tolkien,
The Times described Hobb as "one of the great modern fantasy writers", and stated that her novels were "grown-up fantasy".
The Telegraph held that "Hobb is acknowledged – not least by her colleague, George RR Martin – as one of the pre-eminent writers of modern fantasy fiction", and
The Guardian described her as "the writer to press on those who turn up their noses at fantasy". In a discussion of the fantasy
canon, medieval scholar Patrick Moran commented that the
Elderlings series "undermines the heterosexual norms of traditional high fantasy" through the relationship between Fitz and the genderfluid Fool. While agreeing that Hobb promotes queer themes, Prater voiced disappointment at "conservative impulses" in the series due to a focus on monogamy and romance, which she sees as heteronormative and limiting its message. A more positive view was expressed by Melville, who contended that the concluding
Fitz and the Fool trilogy "confirms the series' place within the larger history of queerness in the fantasy genre". ==Sequels and adaptations==