Pre-release Nintendo World Report's Max Lake called the announcement of a multiplayer mode "exciting". In
IGNs Best of E3 awards for the Game Boy Advance, they named it the runner-up to Best of Show below
Metroid Fusion, calling it a "close one", but ultimately gave the award to
Fusion due to it not being a
remake. They described the multiplayer component as resembling
Diablo or
Gauntlet. They gave it the award for Biggest Surprise, citing its multiplayer mode, calling it a "brilliant addition" and "well worth the price of four
Legend of Zelda cartridges".
IGNs Craig Harris, in his preview of the game, called the port of
A Link to the Past "faithful". Although he noted that the controls would have to be modified due to the GBA's lack of two buttons that were both used in the Super NES version, he found the new controls to be adequate and praised the visuals for holding up well.
IGN reported that based on their then new wishlist tool,
A Link to the Past & Four Swords was consistently the second most anticipated Game Boy Advance game for the five weeks before its release.
Post-release Since its release,
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past & Four Swords has been met with highly positive reception. It holds an aggregate score of 91.70% and 95 at
GameRankings and
Metacritic respectively, indicating "universal acclaim". It sold 1.63 million copies in North America as of December 2007, and 0.29 million in Japan as of December 2009.
GamePros Star Dingo called it a "masterpiece", as well as an "important part of the Grand Renaissance of the Second Dimension". He praised the overworld for its secrets and "quirky random characters", adding that playing it required patience and exploring.
IGN named it the third best Game Boy Advance game, praising the Game Boy Advance for handling the game so well, and citing the multiplayer component for making the game "truly awesome". They included it on their list of most-wanted
Nintendo DSi Virtual Console games, a hypothetical service that in
IGNs view would offer handheld games similar to the
Wii's
Virtual Console. They once again praised the multiplayer mode, questioning why
Nintendo has yet to make a follow-up game on the
Nintendo DS or
DSiWare.
Eurogamers Tom Bramwell praised it, commenting that the port held up over the years, calling it "amazingly deep" and a "gateway drug into the genre". In reviewing the multiplayer component, he commented that while it was not as good as
A Link to the Past, it was still remarkable, but he found fault in the difficulty of finding three other players with Game Boy Advances and copies of the game to play it with.
Audiovisuals GamePros Star Dingo praised the port of
A Link to the Pasts ability to retain its visuals. He specifically praised its "clean sprites", calling its overworld a "colorful, happy place", sarcastically calling it "kiddy". Writing for
IGN, Craig Harris praised
Four Swords visuals and further called
The Legend of Zeldas overture "breathtaking", applauding the Game Boy Advance for recreating the graphics and audio for
A Link to the Past from the original Super NES game. ==Legacy==