Allen Dulles with C.I.A.
Counter-insurgency expert Colonel
Edward Lansdale,
United States Air Force Chief of Staff General
Nathan F. Twining, and
C.I.A. Deputy Director Lieutenant General
Charles P. Cabell at the Pentagon in 1955. In the
1948 Presidential election, Dulles was, together with his brother, an advisor to Republican nominee
Thomas E. Dewey. The Dulles brothers and
James Forrestal helped form the
Office of Policy Coordination. During 1949 he co-authored the
Dulles–Jackson–Correa Report, which was sharply critical of the Central Intelligence Agency, which had been established by the
National Security Act of 1947. Partly as a result of the report, Truman named a new Director of Central Intelligence, Lieutenant General
Walter Bedell Smith. Smith recruited Dulles into the
CIA to oversee the agency's covert operations as
Deputy Director for Plans, a position he held from January 4, 1951. On August 23, 1951, Dulles was promoted to deputy director of Central Intelligence, second in the intelligence hierarchy. In this capacity, in 1952–53 he was one of five members of the
State Department Panel of Consultants on Disarmament during the last year of the
Truman administration. After the election of Dwight Eisenhower in 1952, Bedell Smith shifted to the Department of State and Dulles became the first civilian Director of Central Intelligence. Dulles played a role in convincing Eisenhower to follow one of the conclusions of the State Department Panel report, that the American public deserved to be informed of the perils of possible nuclear war with the Soviet Union, because even though America held numerical nuclear superiority, the Soviets would still have enough nuclear weapons to severely damage American society regardless of how many more such bombs the United States might possess or how badly those U.S. weapons could destroy the Soviets. The Soviet Union
shot down and captured a U-2 in 1960 during Dulles's term as CIA chief. and his replacement with
Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, Shah of Iran. Rumors of a Soviet takeover of the country had surfaced due to the nationalization of the
Anglo-Iranian Oil Company. By coincidence, on August 18, 1953, Dulles was taking a vacation in Rome while the Shah fled there after a setback in the coup, and the two met while checking in to the
Hotel Excelsior. The meeting turned out to be fortuitous for the United States and the coup. CIA and independent historians say that the meeting was happenstance, but conspiracy theories abound.
Coup in Guatemala President
Jacobo Arbenz Guzman of
Guatemala was removed in 1954 in a
CIA-led coup carried out under the code name Operation PBSuccess.
Eduardo Galeano described Dulles as a former member of the
United Fruit Company's Board of Directors. However, in a detailed examination of the connections between the United Fruit Company and the Eisenhower Administration, Immerman makes no mention of Dulles being part of the United Fruit Company's Board, although he does note that Sullivan & Cromwell had represented the company.
Congo In 1960 a plan to kill
Patrice Lumumba. was considered and Dulles allocated $100,000 to the plan, but it never materialised. Dulles believed that Lumumba posed "a grave danger as long as he was not disposed of".
Bay of Pigs Several failed assassination plots utilizing CIA-recruited operatives and anti-Castro Cubans directly against Castro undermined the CIA's credibility. The reputation of the agency and its director declined drastically after the
Bay of Pigs Invasion fiasco of 1961. President Kennedy reportedly said he wanted to "splinter the CIA into a thousand pieces and scatter it into the winds." The next day, November 29, the White House released a resignation letter signed by Dulles. He was replaced by
John McCone. Dulles referred to the Bay of Pigs failure as "the worst day of my life" and developed a strong dislike of Kennedy, later telling journalist
Willie Morris "that little Kennedy, he thought he was a god". Dulles found life outside the CIA difficult, with his friend
James Angleton recalling "He had a very difficult time to decompress". ==Later life==