Although
DS9s ratings remained solid, it was never as successful as the syndicated
Star Trek: The Next Generation. One factor was the minimal promotion for
DS9, as Paramount focused its efforts on its flagship network series
Star Trek: Voyager.
Critical reception DS9 was well received by critics, with
TV Guide describing it as "the best acted, written, produced, and altogether finest"
Star Trek series. Though debuting in the shadow of
The Next Generation,
DS9 achieved a considerable level of success in its own right. According to a press release through
Newswire on April 7, 1999, it was the #1 syndicated show in the United States for adults 18–49 and 25–54. The characters of
DS9 were featured on the cover of
TV Guide ten times during its run, including several "special issue" editions in which a set of four versions with different covers was printed. The series was bestowed with a number of award nominations and awards.
DS9 earned 31
Emmy Award nominations during its run, including for makeup,
cinematography, art direction, special effects, hairstyling, music (direction and composition), and costumes. Of these, it won two for makeup (for "
Captive Pursuit" and "
Distant Voices"), one for
special visual effects (for "Emissary"), and one for its main title theme music (by composer Dennis McCarthy).
DS9 was also nominated for two
Hugo Awards in the category of Best Dramatic Presentation for "
The Visitor" and "
Trials and Tribble-ations".
Deep Space Nine drew praise from African-American, Latino, and other minority viewers for its handling of the minority characters, particularly the Sisko family members. In addition, actor Alexander Siddig (who portrayed Dr. Bashir) expressed his enthusiasm for the fact that he, with his English accent, unusual screen name at the time of casting (Siddig El Fadil), and North African heritage, was a main character on a prominent television series, despite not being as easily racially identifiable to audiences as many other TV actors and characters were at the time.
Andrew J. Robinson commented on
DS9 not being as popular as its predecessors: "It's not the most popular because it's the most morally ambiguous... Whenever you have characters who are gray rather than black and white... Although they are more interesting, they are more difficult for people to get a handle on. I loved
DS9 because they were gray because the characters were not easily definable, but that's not for everybody". Author Terry J. Erdmann commented: "
DS9 was never as popular as its two predecessors, although it arguably was a more critically acclaimed series". In 2018,
IndieWire ranked
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine as the third-best science-fiction show set in outer space, while placing
Star Trek (1966–1969) in eighth place and
Star Trek: The Next Generation (1987–1994) in 12th place among other shows in this genre, including 18 overall. In 2016,
The Washington Post called the Dominion war arc possibly the "richest narrative" of the
Star Trek universe, though the arc's only standout episode is "In the Pale Moonlight", which it ranked the fourth-best episode of all
Star Trek for highlighting the moral confusion and compromises that can occur during war. In 2017,
Vulture ranked it the best live-action
Star Trek television show. In 2019,
Popular Mechanics ranked it the 16th-best science-fiction television show ever. In 2021,
Variety ranked it ninth among
Star Trek film and television series. In 2021,
Empire ranked it the 46th-greatest television show ever, saying its seasons-long character and story arcs make it good for
binge-watching.
Former cast members and staff In a 2007 interview with
If Magazine,
George Takei, who had played the character
Hikaru Sulu in
The Original Series, criticized
DS9 for being the polar opposite of Gene Roddenberry's philosophy and vision of the future. Writer
D. C. Fontana thought that as a World War II veteran Roddenberry would have appreciated the show and its dark themes.
Bjo Trimble, one of the major forces behind the letter-writing campaign that helped renew
The Original Series for its third season, commented that she thought Roddenberry would have "come to like
DS9, had he lived to see it", and that "the only reason there were not full battles in early
Star Trek is lack of funds to pull it off, and lack of technology to show it. Otherwise, GR would certainly have added it; he knew what audiences liked". Roddenberry is quoted in
The Making of Star Trek DS9 as having doubts that a non-exploration show could work, and being displeased with early concepts presented to him in 1991. However, Rick Berman stated in the
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Companion that Roddenberry had given him his blessing for developing it close to his death. At the Shore Leave 14 convention in July 1992, Majel Barrett commented on Roddenberry's involvement: "He knew about it, but he was not about to become involved. He had done what he wanted to do and that was it. He just wished them Godspeed and go ahead. And as long as the name
Star Trek is on it, yes, the estate will have a part of the action."
Ronald D. Moore, one of the series' main writers (who previously wrote for
Star Trek: The Next Generation and went on to create the
re-imagined Battlestar Galactica), praised the show as the "ultimate achievement for the [
Star Trek] franchise" in 2002: I think
Deep Space [Nine] was the show that really took
Star Trek as far as you could take it. You have
The Original Series which is a sort of a landmark, it changes everything about the way science fiction is presented on television, at least space-based science fiction. Then you have
Next Generation, which for all of its legitimate achievements, is still a riff on the original. It's still sort of like, ok, it's another star ship and it's another captain – it's different, but it's still a riff on the original. Here comes
Deep Space [Nine] and it just runs the table in a different way. It just says ok, you think you know what
Star Trek is, let's put it on a space station, and let's make it darker. Let's make it a continuing story, and let's continually challenge your assumptions about what this American icon means. And I think it was the ultimate achievement for the franchise. Personally, I think it's the best of all of them; I think it's an amazing piece of work.
Scholarly reception J. Emmett Winn, in his discussion of the portrayal of Ferengi, criticized the show for "perpetuat[ing]
racial stereotypes and promot[ing] mainstream
cultural assimilation as a noble, desirable quest and as the correct way for the racialized 'other' to exist". Since the end of the series, many other scholars have addressed a variety of aspects of the show, including Victor Grech's analysis of the Cardassians as representing Nazis; Douglas Cowan's chapter looking at religion in science fiction "Heeding the Prophet's Call:
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine"; and Roger A. Sneed's
The Dreamer and The Dream: Afrofuturism and Black Religious Thought and Lisa Doris Alexander's article "Far Beyond the Stars: The Framing of Blackness in
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine", both of which address the way
Deep Space Nine broke new ground in depicting race in science fiction. ==
Babylon 5 controversy ==