In March 1646, Parliament announced Royalists who '
compounded' would be pardoned and have their property restored in return for an agreed fine and promise not to take up arms again. Lisle received a pass into London in January 1647, where he remained as Parliament struggled with economic distress, unpaid soldiers and the terms of a political settlement with Charles. When the
Second English Civil War began in April 1648, he joined Royalists in
Kent, led by the
Earl of Norwich and Charles Lucas. After this rising was
suppressed by the
New Model Army, the remnants headed for
Colchester, where Lucas assumed command. He refused several offers to surrender, since he faced death in any case for breaking his oath not to fight against Parliament; after an eleven-week
siege, the town was close to starvation and capitulated on 28 August. The latter stages of the first war were marked by atrocities on both sides, such as the
Storming of Bolton and
Liverpool by Prince Rupert's men in 1644, or the Parliamentarian "
Ordinance of no quarter to the Irish" and killing of prisoners at
Shelford Priory in November 1645. This bitterness continued into the second, especially against those like Lucas who had promised not to take up arms against Parliament again. Lisle himself was damaged by association with Prince Rupert, widely blamed for many atrocities, and his presence at Leicester, an event which shocked many in Parliament and formed one of the charges at the
Trial of Charles I. Other prisoners included Lords Norwich and
Capell, who were sent to London for trial. Capell was beheaded in March 1649, while Lucas, Lisle and Sir
Bernard Gascoigne were sentenced to immediate execution; Lucas died first, followed by Lisle, who reportedly invited the firing squad to come closer to ensure they did not miss. Gascoigne was reprieved and most of the garrison exiled. Despite the legal justifications provided by Sir
Thomas Fairfax, historian Trevor Royle views the executions as driven by frustration at having to resume the war, and anger at needlessly prolonging the siege long after it could impact the result of the war. Contrary to Royalist propaganda, Lisle and Lucas were not close friends but linked by their deaths and adoption as martyrs; after the
Stuart Restoration in 1661, they were reburied in St Giles Church
Colchester, where their memorial can still be seen. In the
amnesty and general act of forgetting that followed, Lisle and Lucas faded into obscurity until their case was resurrected during the 'Cavalier' resurgence of the
Victorian era. A monument was erected to their memory in
Colchester Castle and a number of scholarly papers published debating the legal merits of their execution. ==References==