The spread of English around the world is often discussed in terms of three distinct groups of users, where English is used respectively as: • a
native language (ENL); the
primary language of the majority population of a country, such as in the United States, the United Kingdom and Australia. • a
second language (ESL); an additional language for
intranational as well as
international communication in communities that are
multilingual, such as in
India,
Pakistan,
Nigeria, and
Singapore. Most of these Englishes developed as a result of imperial expansion that brought the language to various parts of the world. • a foreign language (EFL); used almost exclusively for international communication, such as in Japan.
Kachru's Three Circles of English The most influential model of the spread of English is
Braj Kachru's model of World Englishes. In this model the diffusion of English is captured in terms of three concentric circles of the language: the Inner Circle, the Outer Circle, and the Expanding Circle. The
Inner Circle refers to English as it originally took shape and was spread across the world in the first
diaspora. In this transplantation of English, speakers from England carried the language to Australia, New Zealand, and North America. The Inner Circle thus represents the traditional historical and sociolinguistic bases of English in regions where it is now used as a primary language: the United Kingdom, the United States, Australia, New Zealand, Ireland, and anglophone Canada. English is the
native language or
mother tongue of most people in these countries. The total number of English speakers in the inner circle is as high as 380 million, of whom some 120 million are outside the United States. The
Outer Circle of English was produced by the second
diaspora of English, which spread the language through imperial expansion by
Great Britain in
Asia and
Africa. In these regions, English is not the native tongue but serves as a useful
lingua franca between
ethnic and language groups. Higher education, the
legislature and
judiciary, national commerce and so on may all be carried out predominantly in English. This circle includes
India,
Nigeria,
Bangladesh,
Pakistan,
Malaysia,
Tanzania,
Kenya,
South Africa, the
Philippines (colonized by the US) and others. The total number of English speakers in the outer circle is estimated to range from 150 million to 300 million.
Singapore, while in the Outer Circle, may be drifting into the Inner Circle as English becomes more often used as a home language (see
Languages of Singapore), much as Ireland did earlier. The Outer Circle also includes countries where most people speak an
English-based creole, yet retain standard English for official purposes, such as
Jamaica,
Trinidad and Tobago,
Barbados,
Guyana,
Belize and
Papua New Guinea. Finally, the
Expanding Circle encompasses countries where English plays no historical or governmental role, but where is nevertheless widely used as a medium of international communication. This includes much of the rest of the world's population not categorized above, including territories such as China, Russia, Japan,
South Korea, non-Anglophone
Europe (especially
Central Europe and
Nordic countries), and the Middle East. The total in this expanding circle is the most difficult to estimate, especially because English may be employed for specific, limited purposes, usually in a business context. The estimates of these users range from 100 million to one billion. The inner circle is 'norm-providing'; that means that the English language
norms is developed in these countries. The outer circle (mainly
New Commonwealth countries) is 'norm-developing'. The expanding circle (which includes much of the rest of the world) is 'norm-dependent' because it relies on the standards set by
native speakers in the inner circle.
Schneider's dynamic model of postcolonial Englishes Edgar Werner Schneider tries to avoid a purely geographical and historical approach evident in the 'circles' models and incorporates
sociolinguistic concepts pertaining to acts of
identity. His model suggests that, despite all differences in geography and history, there is a fundamentally uniform process underlying all instances of the emergence of new World Englishes, motivated by the changing social relationship between a region's indigenous population and settlers who came to that region. The relationship between historical and social conditions and linguistic developments is viewed as a unilateral implicational relationship among four components. The political history of a country, typically from colony to independent nationhood, is reflected in the identity rewritings of the groups involved (indigenous population and settlers). These determine sociolinguistic conditions of language contact (such as the acquisition of the other party's language), linguistic usage (such as the amount and kind of mutual interaction), and language attitudes. Linguistic developments, and structural changes in the varieties concerned, follow. The model outlines five characteristic stages in the spread of English:
Phase 1 – Foundation: This is the initial stage of the introduction of English to a new territory over an extended period of time. Two linguistic processes are operative at this stage: (a)
language contact between English and
indigenous languages; (b) contact between different
dialects of English of the settlers which eventually results in a new stable
dialect (see
koiné). At this stage,
bilingualism is marginal. A few members of the local populace may play an important role as interpreters, translators, and guides. Borrowings are limited to lexical items; with local place names and terms for local fauna and flora being adopted by the English.
Phase 2 – Exonormative stabilization: At this stage, the settler communities tend to stabilize politically under British rule. English increases in prominence and though the
colloquial English is a colonial
koiné, the speakers look to England for their formal norms. Local vocabulary continues to be adopted. Bilingualism increases amongst the
indigenous population through education and increased contacts with English settlers. Knowledge of English becomes an asset, and a new indigenous
elite develops.
Phase 5 – Differentiation: At this stage, there is a change in the dynamics of
identity as the young nation sees itself as less defined by its differences from the
former colonial power and more as a composite of subgroups defined on regional, social and ethnic lines. Coupled with the simple effects of time in effecting
language change (with the aid of
social differentiation) the new English
koiné starts to show greater differentiation.
McArthur's Circle of World English McArthur's "wheel model" has an idealized central variety called "World Standard English," which is best represented by "written international English." The next circle is made of regional standards or standards that are emerging. Finally, the outer layer consists of localized varieties which may have similarities with the regional standards or emerging standards. Although the model is neat, it raises several problems. Firstly, the three different types of English — ENL,
ESL and
EFL, are conflated in the second circle. Secondly, the multitude of Englishes in Europe is also missing in this layer. Finally, the outside layer includes
pidgins,
creoles and
L2 Englishes. Most scholars would argue that
English pidgins and
creoles do not belong to one family: rather they have overlapping multiple memberships.
Görlach's circle model of English Manfred Görlach's and McArthur's models are reasonably similar. Both exclude English varieties in Europe. As Görlach does not include
EFLs at all, his model is more consistent, though less comprehensive. Outside the circle are mixed varieties (
pidgins,
creoles, and
mixed languages involving English), which are better categorized as having partial membership.
Modiano's model of English In Modiano's model of English, the center consists of users of English as an International Language, with a core set of features that are comprehensible to the majority of native and competent non-native speakers of English. The second circle consists of features that may become internationally common or may fall into obscurity. Finally, the outer area consists of five groups (
American English,
British English, other major varieties, local varieties, and foreign varieties) each with features particular to their own speech community and which are unlikely to be understood by most members of the other four groups. ==Variations and varieties==