According to Shatner, early
Star Trek reviewers described his performance as "wooden", with most of the show's acting praise and media interest going to Nimoy. and Shatner won a
Saturn Award for Best Actor in 1982 for
The Wrath of Khan.
Star Trek II director
Nicholas Meyer said Shatner "gives the best performance of his life" in
The Wrath of Khan.
The Guardian called Pine's performance of Kirk an "unqualified success", and
The Boston Globe said Pine is "a fine, brash boy Kirk".
Slate, which called Pine "a jewel", described his performance as "channel[ing]" Shatner without being an impersonation.
The Myth of the American Superhero refers to Kirk as a "superhuman redeemer" who "like a true
superhero ... regularly escapes after risking battle with monsters or enemy spaceships". Although some episodes question Kirk's position as a hero,
Star Trek "never left the viewer in doubt for long". Others have commented that Kirk's exaggerated "strength, intelligence, charm, and adventurousness" make him unrealistic. Kirk is described as able to find ways "through unanticipated problems to reach [his] goals" and his leadership style is most "appropriate in a tight, geographically identical team with a culture of strong leadership." Although Roddenberry conceived the character as being "in a very real sense ... 'married' " to the
Enterprise, Kirk has been noted for "his sexual exploits with gorgeous females of every size, shape and type"; and labeled a "
womanizer".
The Last Lecture author
Randy Pausch believed he became a better teacher, colleague, and husband because he watched Kirk run the
Enterprise; Pausch wrote that "for ambitious boys with a scientific bent, there could be no greater role model than James T. Kirk".
David A. Goodman commented that Kirk "has as much reality as possible for a fictional character." In 2012,
IGN ranked the character Captain Kirk, as depicted in the original series, films, and the new Kirk in 2009 film
Star Trek, as the number one top character of the
Star Trek universe. In 2016, Kirk was ranked as the #1 most important character of
Starfleet within the
Star Trek science fiction universe by
Wired magazine, out of 100 characters of the franchise. In 2018,
CBR ranked Kirk the best
Starfleet character of
Star Trek, including later television series. In July 2019,
Screen Rant ranked Kirk the 8th smartest character of
Star Trek.
Cultural impact , self-proclaimed as Captain Kirk's "future birthplace" In 1985,
Riverside, Iowa petitioned Roddenberry and
Paramount Pictures for permission to "adopt" Kirk as their town's "Future Son". Shatner and Roddenberry approved the proposal. Paramount wanted $40,000 for a license to reproduce a
bust of Kirk, but the city instead set a plaque and built a replica of the
Enterprise (named the "USS
Riverside"), and the Riverside Area Community Club holds an annual "Trek Fest" in anticipation of Kirk's birthday. Kirk has been the subject of a wide range of television spoofs that aired in many countries, including
The Carol Burnett Show and
KI.KA's
Bernd das Brot.
John Belushi's impression of Kirk for
Saturday Night Live, which he described as his favorite role, was "dead-on".
Jim Carrey has been praised for his satire of the character in a 1992 episode of
In Living Color. Comedian
Kevin Pollak is well known for his impressions of Shatner as Kirk. Kirk's memorable scream of "Khan!" in the 1982 movie
Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan has become a pop culture icon in its own right, spawning internet memes and is widely parodied and paid tribute to. Kirk has been referenced in the lyrics of many
pop songs. Early examples include the 1979 song "
Where's Captain Kirk?" by
Spizzenergi, the 1982 rap song "
Tough" by
Kurtis Blow, and 1983's "
99 Luftballons" by
Nena (both German and English versions). More recently, in the 2003 remix of 1998’s "
That Don't Impress Me Much",
Shania Twain puts forth Captain Kirk as one of the unattainable ideals to whom her unappealingly haughty suitor apparently thinks himself equal. Kirk has been merchandised in a variety of ways, including collectible busts,
action figures,
mugs,
t-shirts, A Kirk Halloween mask was altered and used as the mask worn by the character
Michael Myers in the
Halloween film franchise. In 2002, Kirk's captain's chair from the original
Star Trek was auctioned for $304,000. In a 2010
Space Foundation survey, Kirk tied with cosmonaut
Yuri Gagarin as the No. 6 most popular space hero. Captain Kirk has also been portrayed in feline form. First, anthropomorphically, in two episodes of the 1975
Filmation Saturday morning animated children’s series
The Secret Lives of Waldo Kitty. The cartoon is based around the title character’s fantasies about being various heroic felines based on popular culture icons. Later came scientific illustrator
Jenny Parks' 2017 book
Star Trek Cats, in which Kirk is depicted as an orange
tabby cat. The
Kirk crater on
Pluto's moon,
Charon, is named after the character.
Fan productions In addition to television, feature films, books, and parodies, Kirk has also been portrayed in
non-canon fan fiction.
Star Trek: New Voyages The
Star Trek: New Voyages fan production, known from 2008 until 2015 as
Star Trek: Phase II, portrays the further voyages of the original
Enterprise crew. The series' creators feel that "Kirk, Spock, McCoy and the rest should be treated as 'classic' characters like
Willy Loman from
Death of a Salesman,
Gandalf from
The Lord of the Rings or even
Hamlet,
Othello or
Romeo. Many actors have and can play the roles, each offering a different interpretation of said character."
James Cawley played Kirk in most of the ten episode
Phase II series from its beginning in 2004 before replacing himself with actor Brian Gross.
Wired observes that while Cawley's depiction "lacks Shatner's vulnerability", the actor has enough swagger "to be passable in the role".
Star Trek Continues portrayed Kirk in
Star Trek Continues First produced in 2013, the 11 episode series
Star Trek Continues also looked to chronicle the "lost seasons" of
Star Trek: The Original Series. The series developer and producer is anime voice actor
Vic Mignogna, who also plays the role of Kirk. Rounding out the core cast is fellow voice actor
Todd Haberkorn as Spock,
Chris Doohan (son of the original Scotty actor
James Doohan) as Scotty, and as McCoy first author-producer
Larry Nemecek, followed by voice actor
Chuck Huber. It also co-starred
Grant Imahara (
MythBusters) as Sulu. The first episode, "
Pilgrim of Eternity" (with
Michael Forest reprising his role as Apollo from the original series episode "
Who Mourns for Adonais?") was released in 2013. The second episode, "
Lolani" (featuring guest star
Lou Ferrigno), was released in February 2014, and a third episode, "
Fairest of Them All" was released in June 2014 and won a
Burbank International Film Festival award for "Best New Media – Drama".
Star Trek Continues also won a Geekie Award for "Best Web Series". On June 19, 2015, Episode 4 of the series was posted and titled "White Iris". All eleven full episodes have been released as of December, 2017. ==Legacy==