Poetry First Dream First Dream, a long philosophical and descriptive
silva (a poetic form combining verses of 7 and 11 syllables), deals with the shadow of night beneath which a person falls asleep in the midst of quietness and silence. There night and day animals participate, either dozing or sleeping, all urged to silence and rest by Harpocrates. The person's body ceases its ordinary operations, which are described in physiological and symbolical terms, ending with the activity of the imagination as an image-reflecting apparatus: the
Pharos. From this moment, her soul, in a dream, sees itself free at the summit of her own intellect; in other words, at the apex of a pyramid-like mount, which aims at God and is luminous. There, perched like an eagle, she contemplates the whole creation, but fails to comprehend such a sight in a single concept. Dazzled, the soul's intellect faces its own shipwreck, caused mainly by trying to understand the overwhelming abundance of the universe, until reason undertakes that enterprise, beginning with each individual creation, and processing them one by one, helped by the
ten categories of Aristotle. The soul cannot get beyond questioning herself about the traits and causes of a fountain and a flower, intimating perhaps that his method constitutes a useless effort, since it must take into account all the details, accidents, and mysteries of each being. By that time, the body has consumed all its nourishment, and it starts to move and wake up, soul and body are reunited. The poem ends with the Sun overcoming Night in battle between luminous and dark armies, and with the poet's awakening. Many of her poems dealt with the subject of love and sensuality. Colombian-American translator
Jaime Manrique described her poetry thus: "her love poems are expressions of a complex and ambivalent modern psyche, and because they are so passionate and ferocious that when we read them we feel consumed by the naked intensity she achieves." One of Sor Juana's sonnets:
"You Foolish Men (Philosophical Satire)" )Sor Juana's
Hombres Necios (Foolish men), written in the 1680s, is among the first
proto-feminist literary works in the Americas to explore the
double standards of men while also accusing men of trying to diminish a woman's honor. Society in seventeenth-century Mexico was heavily patriarchal, but Sor Juana nevertheless managed to publish this work, which only added to the backlash she would eventually face from the Church. The names of
Thais and
Lucretia are cited along with the concept of prostitution to stress how men use women and leave them helpless, facing only blame and hatred. Sor Juana's writing, in the
Baroque literary style prevalent in her time, can be readily understood today. In the 1990s,
Guillermo Schmidhuber found a release of the comedy that contained a different ending. He proposed that those one thousand words were written by Sor Juana. Some
literary critics, such as
Octavio Paz, Georgina Sabat-Rivers, and
Luis Leal) have accepted Sor Juana as the co-author, but others, such as
Antonio Alatorre and José Pascual Buxó, have questioned the attribution.
Comedies of
St Jerome in
Mexico City.Scholars have debated the meaning of Juana's comedies. Julie Greer Johnson describes how Juana protested against the rigorously defined relationship between genders through her full-length comedies and humor. She argues that Juana recognized the negative view of women in comedy which was designed to uphold male superiority at the expense of women. By recognizing the power of laughter, Juana appropriated the purpose of humor, and used it as a socially acceptable medium with which to question notions of men and women.
Pawns of a House The work was first performed on
October 4, 1683, during the celebration of the Viceroy Count of Paredes' first son's birth. Some critics maintain that it could have been set up for the Archbishop
Francisco de Aguiar y Seijas' entrance to the capital, but this theory is not considered reliable. The protagonist of the story, Dona Leonor, fits the
archetype perfectly. The plot takes on the well-known theme in
Greek mythology of
Theseus: a hero from
Crete Island. He fights against the
Minotaur and awakens the love of
Ariadne and
Phaedra. Sor Juana conceived Theseus as the archetype of the baroque hero, a model also used by her fellow countryman
Juan Ruiz de Alarcón. Theseus's triumph over the Minotaur does not make Theseus proud, but instead allows him to be humble. Propiedad es de natura que entre Dios y el hombre media, y del cielo el be cuadrado junto al be bemol de la tierra. (Villancico 220) Second, Professor Sarah Finley argues that the visual is related with patriarchal themes, while the sonorous offers an alternative to the feminine space in the work of Sor Juana. As an example of this, Finley points out that Narciso falls in love with a voice, and not with a reflection.
Other notable works One musical work attributed to Sor Juana survives from the archive of
Guatemala Cathedral. This is a 4-part villancico,
Madre, la de los primores. Other works include
Hombres Necios (Foolish Men), and
The Divine Narcissus. Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz wrote a letter to her Confessor, Antonio Núñez de Miranda, titled
Autodefensa Espiritual (Spiritual Self-Defense) in 1690
, ten years before she severs ties after sending the
Respuesta a Sor Filotea. However, unlike the Respuesta, the
Autodefensa has much more biting and frank language used. In the
Autodefensa, Sor Juana defends her intellectual pursuits and criticizes the restrictions placed on women's education and opportunities to pursue knowledge. She argues that women have the same rational souls as men and should be able to study and engage in intellectual pursuits. In the
Autodefensa letter, Sor Juana uses this more forceful and confrontational language to reprimand and dismiss her Confessor. This has led scholars to suggest that the Autodefensa was a rehearsal for the arguments she would later make in the Respuesta. In both letters, Sor Juana defends her right to pursue knowledge and critiques the restrictions placed on women's intellectual development
. Many of these themes were feminist in nature with one of the most notable being the right of women to be able to study intellectual pursuits. This theme is prevalent in the lines, "But who has prohibited women private and individual studies? Do they not have a rational soul like men? Why should it then not enjoy within them the privilege of enlightenment in an education? Is it not as capable of earning God's glory and grace as yours? Why should it not be capable of such news and science, a trifle? What divine revelation, what determination of the Church, what dictate of reason made for us such a severe law?" (translated from Tapia Mendez 1993). Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz's Autodefensa Espiritual and Respuesta a Sor Filotea are considered some of the most significant feminist writings of the 17th century. Her advocacy for women's intellectual rights was particularly groundbreaking, as women in her time were often restricted from pursuing academic and intellectual pursuits. Sor Juana's writings challenged patriarchal structures and called for greater gender equality and opportunities for women to pursue their passions. Sor Juana's writings were not only feminist but also expressed her thoughts on politics and religion. She was known for her strong defense of her beliefs and refusal to be silenced, which resulted in her being criticized by the Church and other powerful figures of her time. Despite facing backlash and opposition, Sor Juana continued to write and publish her works. Her work continues to inspire feminists and scholars today, and she is celebrated as a feminist icon and a leading voice in Latin American literature and intellectual thought. Sor Juana's writing also had a significant impact on the development of Mexican literature and culture, and she is considered a national treasure in Mexico. == Translations and interpretations ==