The original sales for
Lemmings on the Amiga topped 55,000 copies on the first day of sales; in comparison,
Menace sold 20,000 copies and
Blood Money sold 40,000 copies cumulatively. With all ports included, Mike Dailly estimated that 15 million copies of
Lemmings were sold between 1991 and 2006. In 2011, Luke Plunkett from
Kotaku placed the figure at over 20 million, a figure which has been quoted as far back as 1997. At the time of its first release,
Lemmings received several high scores from gaming magazines, with only the level of graphics and sound receiving some small amount of criticism. David Sears of
Compute!, in his review of
Lemmings for the PC, stated that "perhaps Psygnosis has tapped into the human instinct for survival in formulating this perfect blend of puzzle, strategy, and action."
Amiga Computing stated that "
Lemmings is absolutely brilliant. Psygnosis have managed to produce a game that is not only totally original, but also features the kind of addictive gameplay that will keep you coming back for more time and time again." A review from the
Australian Commodore and Amiga Review (
ACAR) stated that "above all, the concept is simple, and the game is a lot of fun."
Computer Gaming World stated that "Not since
Tetris has this reviewer been so addicted to, or completely fascinated with, a series of challenging puzzles ... follow the crowd and get
Lemmings". In 1992 the magazine named it its Action Game of the Year. The game was reviewed in 1991 in
Dragon by Hartley, Patricia, and Kirk Lesser in "The Role of Computers" column. The reviewers gave the game 5 out of 5 stars. In 1994,
Electronic Gaming Monthly complimented the Lynx version's large number of options and password feature, and remarked, "
Lemmings has always been a good strategy game, and the Lynx version continues the tradition." The following year they reviewed the CD-i version, criticising that it has nothing but the obligatory
full-motion video intro to set it apart from the numerous ports of the game that had already been released over the past four years.
GamePro made the same criticisms, commenting that "this former 16-bit puzzler isn't going anywhere new on the CD-i."
Next Generations review of the 3DO version assessed that "If you've played any version, you've played this one, too, but if you haven't tried it, this is one of the better ones, and it's still one game that's addictive as hell." and that same year,
Next Generation declared it the 8th-greatest game of all time, and "second only to
Tetris" in the puzzle genre. In 1991,
PC Format named
Lemmings one of the 50 best computer games ever. The editors wrote, "Yes, we know it sounds stupid, but you will like it – everyone else has." In 1994,
PC Gamer US named
Lemmings the 30th-best computer game ever. The editors called it "one of the biggest puzzlers ever released for PC" and "cleaner and less complicated" than its sequel. That same year,
PC Gamer UK named it the 25th-best computer game of all time, calling it "a seminal title." In 1998,
PC Gamer declared it the 21st-best computer game ever released, and the editors called it "as fresh and addictive today as it was when it was first released". In 2018,
Complex listed the game 70th on its "The Best Super Nintendo Games of All Time". In 1995,
Total! ranked the game 81st on their Top 100 SNES Games summarizing: "The game that spawned a dozen imitators is still one of the best platform puzzlers available." ==Legacy==