(red) or
democratising (blue) substantially and significantly (2010–2020) according to the
V-Dem Institute; the remainder are substantially unchanged.
Democratic backsliding refers to a political process in which a democratic system increasingly deteriorates into an autocratic regime. This transition is characterised by the erosion of democratic norms, the suppression of mechanisms that constrain the exercise of political power, and the centralisation of authority. Since Modi came to power in 2014, various studies conducted by
non-governmental organisations, have confirmed the persistent decline in democracy indexes in that now India is widely considered to be gradually moving towards an "electoral autocracy". This is credibly supported by the Swedish organisation
International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance categorising India as an "electoral autocracy" in March 2021. This democratic backsliding has been driven primarily by Modi and the
Hindu nationalist BJP. Akhilesh Pillalamarri of
the Diplomat has argued that the "cultural and social trends [in India today] are not necessarily evidence of democratic backsliding, but are rather evidence of social norms in India that are illiberal toward speech, individual expression, and criticism." In 2023, the Modi administration issued a notification constituting a high-level committee on
One Nation, One Election, a proposal aimed to synchronise all elections in the country either on a single day or within a specific time frame. In September 2024, the bill for One Nation, One Election was approved by the Modi Cabinet. The government also passed the
One Hundred and Sixth Amendment of the Constitution of India, which sought to allocate 33 percent of the seats in the directly elected Lok Sabha, state legislative assemblies and Delhi legislative assembly for women. However, in April 2026, an amendment did not pass due to concerns from opposition parties about the timing of its implementation and the proposed delimitation process.
Statistics In the past decade, India has seen a decline in many
global freedom indices. In 2020, India reported drop in the rankings in the Human Freedom Index, Global Economic Freedom Index, Internet Freedom Index,
Human Development Report. India also saw a
decline in press freedom, falling from 133 out of 180 countries in 2016 to 161 in 2023, in the
Press Freedom Index published by
Reporters Without Borders. India ranked 46th out of 165 independent countries and two territories in the Democracy Index published by the
Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) for 2021. In 2021,
V-Dem Institute downgraded India from a 'flawed democracy' to an 'electoral autocracy'.
Factors contributing to democratic backsliding According to international think-tank
Chatham house amongst many factors, such as its control of the media, corruption, and abuse of power, the BJP seems to be on the path to becoming an illiberal pseudo-democracy similar to Turkey or Russia. Their attempt at developing the country, has now been increasingly polarised, eroding the citizens' trust in the states' institutions and basic democratic foundations like the rule of law.
Defiance, defamation, and counterterrorism to silence critics If a public source was to criticise the rule of Modi or the BJP, they would be punished through harassment, prosecution, raided by tax income officers, or put under surveillance. This was to restrict the denunciation of the leader, however this would then deny the public of the free flow of information that essentially enables them to assess the work of the government and make political choices. Therefore, the public would not be able to hold the government accountable for their actions. Cases of sedition (conduct or speech inciting people to rebel against the authority of a state) had risen by 28% between 2010 and 2021; Of these cases filed against citizens for criticising the government, 96% were filed after Modi came to power in 2014. Not only were opposing press silenced, but media coverage on the television was highly influenced by Modi, with a study of RepublicTV from 2017 to 2020 finding that coverage would be "consistently biased in favour of the Modi government and its policies.". Moreover, Mukesh Ambani, a businessman with close ties to Modi, directly controls media outlets followed by at least 800 million Indians. This heavily dictates the media shown to the population, often being able to convey propaganda benefitting the BJP. As well as subduing the media, Modi has been able to manipulate the Supreme Court, despite a tradition of an independent judiciary which would maintain effective checks and balances. The government has been able to abuse their executive power which is supposedly overtly embedded into the constitutional order and institutional structure. The Constitution establishes a political system designed to advancing executive power and supports coercive legislation at their disposal, if there are cases of absent fundamental plumbing, it can be created through amendments. The investigative agencies provide inputs about the opposition's vulnerabilities with the Modi government, and intimidate them with raids. On one occasion, IT officers came from a car with BJP sticker. The government has put opposition politicians under house arrest and jailed them in order to prevent them from canvassing or participating in protest movements such as in the cases of TDP politician
Nara Lokesh and former finance minister
P. Chidambaram. were dropped against
Himanta Biswa Sarma when he joined the BJP. Similar cases of corruption against
Ajit Pawar,
Mukul Roy,
Y.S. Chowdary were also dropped when they defected to the BJP. The timing of raids on the opposition leaders is often made to coincide with elections or other political consequences. According to the data shared by the Union government in the parliament in July 2022, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) has registered 5,422 cases under the
Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, but only 23 persons have been convicted – less than 0.5% out of which 5,310 cases were under the premiership of Narendra Modi – a 27 times rise . The government data on convictions by the
Income Tax Department is also abysmal. In 6 months between 2018 and 2019, the Income Tax Department had raided the offices of 16 politicians of which 15 belonged to opposition parties. Among the politicians booked, arrested, raided or questioned by the
Central Bureau of Investigation under the first eight years of Modi's government, 95% were from the opposition. BJP leaders have boasted about the impunity they get from the investigative agencies and threatening rebels in their party with raids, adds further to the allegations of misuse of investigative agencies under the premiership of Modi.
Crackdown on media The investigative agencies have also targeted independent and media houses with raids. Offices of
Dainik Bhaskar were raided by IT department months after the media house exposed the handling of the
COVID-19 pandemic by the government.
BBC India offices were raided by income tax officers a month after they released a
documentary on Modi's role in the
2002 Gujarat riots. Other media houses that were targeted include Bennett Coleman and Company Limited,
India Today Group,
Kashmir Times,
The Quint,
The News Minute, Theo Connect (parent of HW News Network),
Newslaundry,
Bharat Samachar, NewsClick,
Greater Kashmir, Kashmir Walla. Journalist
Sidheeq Kappan was put in jail for 850 days under the stringent UAPA by UP police and money laundering case by the ED on his way to
Hathras gang rape and murder case. Journalist Manash Baruah from Guwahati was summoned by the NIA asking him to discontinue phone calls with activist
Akhil Gogoi. At the time of
farmers' protests, NIA summoned Gurpatwant Singh Pannun because of his reporting on farmer protests was different from
mainstream media. The move to allow extension of tenures to up to five years by the government was seen by the critics as an attack on independence of agencies. On 8 May 2023, The Supreme Court's
amicus curiae K.V. Viswanathan told the court that the extensions granted to Mishra were "invalid" and the changes brought by the government in the law "should be scrapped in the interest of democracy", when the court was hearing petitions challenging the third extension of Mishra.
Suppression of data Modi's government delayed the release of data on unemployment in 2019. Two members of
National Statistical Commission resigned in protest as the release was approved in December 2018 by the commission. The government released the data in May 2019 after the
general elections. The government delayed farmer suicide data from 2016 by three years. Before the 2019 general elections, the government did not release data on consumer expenditure, GDP growth, deaths due to lynching, and caste census from 2011. The government withheld
National Crime Records Bureau data for 2017, discontinued Labour Bureau's quarterly enterprises survey and the Employment-Unemployment Survey, and instead plan to rely on provident fund data for calculation of unemployment, which is widely criticised. == Health and sanitation policies ==