2004: Red Sox win World Series and in the 2004 ALCS with the Red Sox. In an effort to build up their lineup, the Red Sox set up a potential deal that would send
Texas Rangers SS and reigning AL MVP
Alex Rodriguez to Boston and
Manny Ramírez and other players to Texas. The deal eventually fell through after Rodriguez indicated he would not go against the
MLBPA, which opposed a proposed renegotiation that would have potentially reduced Rodríguez's earnings in the later years of his contract. A freak off-season basketball injury to Aaron Boone, just months removed from his historic home run, had Yankees management looking at possible options to replace him. Despite being courted by Boston for nearly three months, Rodriguez was traded to New York. That year, the Red Sox won an eventful season series against the Yankees, 11–8. A 13-inning comeback win for the Yankees on July 1 was punctuated by a catch from Jeter, who ran and dove into the stands at full speed and came out with facial lacerations when
Trot Nixon hit a pop up in an area deep behind third base. On July 24,
Jason Varitek shoved his glove into the face of Rodriguez after Rodriguez was hit by a pitch from
Bronson Arroyo, causing a bench-clearing brawl. Though he was ejected (along with Rodriguez) from the game following the incident, the moment sparked Boston to an 11–10 come-from-behind victory. After a 6–4 loss on September 24 in which he gave up 5 runs,
Pedro Martínez told media "I just tip my hat and call the Yankees my daddy". This would lead Yankees fans to taunt Pedro with "who's your Daddy" chants for the remainder of his career. The Red Sox finished second to the Yankees in the AL East for the seventh straight season. Both teams would advance to the
ALCS for the second straight year.
2004 ALCS: The curse is broken After the melodrama of the 2003 ALCS, a rematch in 2004 was hotly anticipated. Yankees GM
Brian Cashman said "I think Boston...really are...a mirror image of us in terms of...aggressiveness and desire to win". Yankees pitcher
Mike Mussina summarized the buildup: "This is what everyone was hoping for...it's a rematch of last year, with the best two teams in the American League". The Yankees won the first three games of the series, including a 19–8 rout in Game 3. No team in the history of baseball had ever won a best-of-seven series after being down 3–0. Entering the bottom of the ninth inning of Game 4 at Fenway Park, Yankees reliever
Mariano Rivera was attempting to close out a 4–3 lead. But after a lead-off walk to
Kevin Millar, pinch-runner
Dave Roberts stole second and came around to score on an RBI single by
Bill Mueller. is playing GOLF today" and "THIS IS BETTER!".|Manny Ramírez at the Red Sox victory parade in 2004, with a sign that one of the spectators handed him. The Red Sox would go on to win their first World Series championship in 86 years, completing a four-game sweep of the
St. Louis Cardinals in the
2004 World Series.
2005–2009: Yankees, Red Sox win titles At Yankee Stadium on April 3, 2005, the teams' first meeting since the 2004 ALCS, Yankees fans started new taunts, saying "The Curse of 1918 is finally over (86 years). Let the new curse 2090 begin." They also projected the next Red Sox championship with signs saying "1918-2004-2090." A week later, the Red Sox received their
World Series rings at Fenway Park before they played the Yankees. All of the Yankees went to the top step of the dugout to applaud their rivals' accomplishment. During the announcement of the lineups, Red Sox fans reciprocated by giving Yankees closer Mariano Rivera, who had struggled against the Red Sox in the previous year's ALCS, a loud
standing ovation, despite their booing of
Alex Rodriguez. The Red Sox won the game 8–1. The Yankees would follow with their own off-season acquisition of former Red Sox outfielder
Johnny Damon, a fan-favorite during his four years in Boston. Damon returned to Fenway Park the following May to a mix of cheers and boos as he tipped his helmet to the fans. The Yankees completed a five-game sweep of the Red Sox at Fenway Park, evoking memories of 1978's "Boston Massacre". The Yankees pushed their division lead from games up to games over the second place Sox.
Boston Globe columnist Dan Shaughnessy dubbed it the "Son of Massacre." The second game of the series, which the Yankees won 14–11, took four hours and 45 minutes to complete, making it the longest nine-inning game in MLB history. Months after the Yankees loss in the
2006 ALDS and Torre's decision to drop a struggling Alex Rodriguez to 8th in the lineup, Rodriguez in an interview with
Sports Illustrated, claimed that he had preferred to go to the Red Sox before being traded to the Yankees. The incident would be one of contention between Torre and Rodriguez as noted in Torre's book,
The Yankee Years. , shown here with the Red Sox, pitched a complete game shutout against the Yankees to win the
2003 World Series for the Marlins. During the third inning of a 2007 game at Fenway Park, Ramírez,
J. D. Drew,
Mike Lowell, and
Jason Varitek hit four consecutive home runs off Yankees pitcher
Chase Wright, powering a comeback from a three-run deficit and completing a three-game sweep of the Yankees at Fenway Park for the first time since 1990. By May, after long speculation about what team he would play for after retirement, Roger Clemens chose to return to the Yankees as opposed to the Red Sox (where he started his career) or the
Houston Astros (his hometown and last team he played for). Clemens helped the Yankees overcome a -game deficit in the standings in late May to roar back to reach the playoffs again, however, this was not enough to win the division. On September 28, Boston won the AL East after a win against the
Minnesota Twins and a loss by the Yankees against the
Baltimore Orioles. This was the first AL East Championship for the Red Sox since 1995, ending the Yankees' nine-year reign in the division. The Red Sox went on to sweep the
Colorado Rockies in the
World Series. Series MVP Mike Lowell remarks, upon receiving his trophy, that "the Red Sox are expected to win." Controversy erupted during the eighth inning of the final game when Alex Rodriguez's agent
Scott Boras announced that Rodriguez had decided to opt out of his contract, in what was seen by many as an attempt by Boras to overshadow the series. The 2007–08 off-season showed a war of words between management of both teams. Boston GM
Theo Epstein called Yankees pitcher
Mike Mussina a "bad apple" for complaining about the Yankees' 2004 trip to Japan as the Red Sox were gearing up for their own trip there. Epstein claimed that Mussina had used it as a crutch during the season. Mussina retorted back saying "Yea, we used it as a crutch to win the division!" Later that month,
Hank Steinbrenner, who had taken a bigger role with the Yankees operation from his father George, responded in a feisty manner to the popularity of
Red Sox Nation in
The New York Times supplemental
Play Magazine: Red Sox Nation?' What a bunch of (expletive) that is. That was a creation of the Red Sox and
ESPN, which is filled with Red Sox fans. Go anywhere in America and you won't see Red Sox hats and jackets, you'll see Yankee hats and jackets. This is a Yankee country. We're going to put the Yankees back on top and restore the universe to order." In response, Red Sox principal owner
John W. Henry inducted Hank Steinbrenner into Red Sox Nation. Steinbrenner went on to praise Henry's handling of the Red Sox and said they would always be competitive under him. In the 2008–09 off-season, first baseman
Mark Teixeira signed an eight year, $180 million contract with the Yankees. Tony Massarotti of
The Boston Globe summed up his feelings by calling it a "kick in the pants". In August 2009, the Yankees defeated the Red Sox, 20–11, in which the total runs scored (31) was the most combined runs scored in a game in the history of the rivalry. Both teams made the playoffs in 2009. During the
ALDS, the Yankees defeated the Minnesota Twins to face the Los Angeles Angels who had knocked out the Red Sox. The Yankees beat the Angels and went on defeat the
Philadelphia Phillies in the
2009 World Series, 4–2, to win their 27th World Series title in their first year in the new Yankee Stadium. Former Red Sox pitcher Pedro Martínez was the losing pitcher for the Phillies in the deciding Game 6.
2010–2012: Yankees fall short, Red Sox collapse In the final series of the 2010 season at Fenway Park, the Red Sox, struggling to get out of third place for much of the season, played the role of spoiler, knocking the Yankees out of first place in the American League East, relegating them to the wild-card for 2010. In 2011, the Red Sox went 12–6 against the Yankees, including beating Yankees ace
CC Sabathia four times during the season and sweeping two three-game series at
Yankee Stadium, the first two series of three games of more where the Yankees have been swept at home since it opened in 2009. Critics and writers forecasted overwhelmingly that the Red Sox would win the
2011 World Series. The Red Sox spent a great deal to build the team in the off-season, and were about to sell at least two Red Sox as
Most Valuable Player candidates by mid season. Following a disastrous first month, the Red Sox climbed in the standings. The Yankees claimed the AL East crown after the Red Sox's September struggles left them battling for the wild-card with the Rays, with whom they went into the season's final game tied. On September 28, the Tampa Bay Rays staged a dramatic comeback from 7–0 to win 8–7 over the Yankees in the 12th inning. Only three minutes earlier, Red Sox closer
Jonathan Papelbon blew a 3–2 lead over the Orioles in the bottom of the 9th inning, handing a 4–3 walk-off victory to the Orioles. The Rays claimed the AL Wild Card and eliminated the Red Sox from the postseason. Dan Shaughnessy of
The Boston Globe said that "the greatest choke in baseball history...feels like revenge for and ." The Red Sox hired outspoken manager
Bobby Valentine, who had previously lost to the Yankees in the
2000 World Series during his tenure with the
New York Mets, to take Francona's place. After his signing, Valentine immediately inserted himself into the rivalry when he said he hated the Yankees. On the series of April 20–22, 2012, the Red Sox celebrated the 100th anniversary of Fenway Park against the Yankees, who they played to open up the park. Both teams wore their 1912 uniforms on April 20, which the Yankees won 6–2. The Yankees came back from down, 9–0, to win, 15–9, the next day, the largest deficit they have ever overcome. They won the season series 13–5, their best record against the Red Sox since 2001, when they also went 13–5 against them, and swept the final three-game series of the season at Yankee Stadium to clinch the AL East while the Red Sox finished last in the division for the first time since 1992 with their worst record since 1965. Valentine was fired soon after. Later in 2012, the Yankees acquired 2004 ALCS Game 7 winner
Derek Lowe. He was the latest member of the 2004 team to later play for the Yankees. After the 2012 season,
Kevin Youkilis, who the Red Sox traded to the
Chicago White Sox earlier in the season, signed with the Yankees as a free agent. He had previously clashed with
Joba Chamberlain when he was with Boston.
2013–2016: Red Sox champions again On April 16, 2013, the Yankees showed support to the victims of the
Boston Marathon bombing, which occurred the day before, by holding a moment of silence prior to their game against the
Arizona Diamondbacks. Following the third inning, the team further paid tribute by playing "
Sweet Caroline", which is known as Fenway Park's traditional song, over the Yankee Stadium's loudspeakers. At the end of the year, the Red Sox took the regular season series over the Yankees 13–6. The Red Sox finished the season with the best record in the American League and went on to defeat the St. Louis Cardinals in the
2013 World Series to win their eighth World Series title, while the Yankees failed to make the playoffs. In 2014 the Yankees acquired
Stephen Drew in exchange for
Kelly Johnson in the first trade between the two teams since 1997. Both teams missed the playoffs in 2014, which was the first time in the wild card era. To start the edition of the rivalry, the first game at Yankee Stadium on April 10 went into extra innings ended up being one of the longest games ever played – at 6 hours and 49 minutes – going 19 innings, with the Yankees tying the game three times in the bottom of the 9th, 14th, and 16th. The Red Sox won the game, 6–5. The Yankees won the 2015 season series 11–8, including going 7–2 at Fenway Park. Towards the end of the season in September, the Yankees headed to Fenway Park trailing the first place Red Sox by only four games. The Yankees ended up getting swept and blew late-inning leads in three of the four games, including giving up five runs in the ninth inning of the first game. The sweep has been dubbed "Boston Massacre II" in reference to the 1978 four-game sweep of the Red Sox by the Yankees at Fenway. On September 28, Yankees first baseman and former Red Sox draft pick
Mark Teixeira hit the final home run of his career, which was a walk-off grand slam off Boston Red Sox pitcher
Joe Kelly. It was the first game-ending home run Teixeira had ever hit in a regular-season game. It was also the firstand as of 2018, the onlywalk-off grand slam hit by any player at the new
Yankee Stadium. ==2017–present: Rebirth of the rivalry==