After the publication of his book on
Luigi Pirandello, Starkie became a director of the
Abbey Theatre in 1927 at the invitation of
W. B. Yeats. Recent productions had been fraught with controversy, and one of his roles was to act as arbiter among the factions. In 1928, while Starkie was away in Italy, Yeats, along with
Lady Gregory and
Lennox Robinson, the other two board members, rejected
Seán O'Casey's fourth play,
The Silver Tassie, his lament of the First World War. When he returned to Dublin he voiced his disagreement with the other board members saying that, "This play was written with the purpose of showing the useless brutality of war and the public should be allowed to judge it for themselves. O'Casey is groping for a new kind of drama and the Abbey should produce the play". In light of his previous successes at the Abbey Theatre the rejection caused much controversy and O'Casey severed his relations with the theatre and took the play to London where it premiered on 11 October 1929 at the
Apollo Theatre with
Charles Laughton and
Barry Fitzgerald under the direction of
Raymond Massey. To many observers the loss of O'Casey marked the beginning of a decline in the fortunes of the Abbey. The following year (1928) the board rejected
Denis Johnston's modernist play
Shadowdance, and Starkie was charged with giving Johnston the bad news. In his spindly handwriting he wrote on the draft title-page the five words (referring to Lady Gregory), "The Old Lady Says NO", which Johnston used to retitle the play before putting on at Dublin's
Gate Theatre the following year to considerable critical acclaim. At the start of World War II, Britain chose to send Catholics to Spain as their representatives, and so the Irish-Catholic, fiddle-playing Starkie was sent to Madrid as the
British Council representative, which took him away from the theatre and nightlife of Dublin, and into
World War II Spain. He resigned from the Abbey Theatre on 17 September 1942 and on the same day he accepted the invitation of
Hilton Edwards and
Micheál MacLiammóir to be on the board of directors at the Gate Theatre. He was one of the founders of the
Centre International des Études Fascistes (CINEF). Its only publication,
A Survey of Fascism (1928), had an article by him, "Whither is Ireland Heading – Is It Fascism? Thoughts on the Irish Free State." During the 1930s, he was an apologist for
Benito Mussolini, whom he had interviewed in 1927. In general terms he was influenced by the Irish poet and mystic
George William Russell (AE) in his writing on
co-operatives. He travelled to
Abyssinia in 1935 and later wrote in favour of the Italian campaign there, opposing
Éamon de Valera's call for
sanctions, fearing they would further isolate Italy and drive
Benito Mussolini into an alliance with
Adolf Hitler. However soon after his appointment in
Madrid his wife dropped her first name "Italia" to avoid being branded an agent of Mussolini. In the mid-1930s, he was involved in a pro-Nazi international network, the Internationale Arbeitsgemeinschaft der Nationalisten, where he chaired the Akademie für die Rechte der Völker. ==British Institute, Madrid==