Background The origins of the Beiyang government lie in the aftermath of the
First Sino-Japanese War of 1895, after which the defeated armies of the Qing dynasty instituted a series of military reforms known as the
New Army reforms, headed by general
Li Hongzhang. Among the regional armies that emerged from these reforms was the
Beiyang Army, named such due to being primarily based in the
Beiyang region. Commanded by general
Yuan Shikai, the Beiyang Army grew to become the largest and most modernized of China's New Armies, and Yuan began to become a highly influential figure in the Qing government. In 1907, Yuan was appointed to the high positions of
Grand Councillor and
Secretary of Foreign Affairs, which he held until being relieved of both positions by Imperial Regent
Prince Chun in 1909. In October 1911, the
Tongmenghui incited troops to revolt in the
Wuchang Uprising. The Qing recalled Yuan Shikai from retirement; Yuan was to lead the imperial military - his personal relationship with Beiyang Army officers was seen as a stabilizing factor - but he refused the appointment. In November, with New Army units joining the revolt, the Qing capitulated to rebel demands and agreed to reform the empire into a
constitutional monarchy. The Qing national assembly drafted a constitution on November 3 and elected Yuan as Premier on November 8; the Qing confirmed the appointment on November 11. Qing attempts to suppress the uprising were inconclusive. At the end of 1911,
Sun Yat-sen returned to China from
France. On January 1, 1912, the Tongmenghui made Sun the president of the
Provisional Government of the Republic of China in
Nanjing. Sun privately offered the presidency to Yuan, who had greater military resources. At the end of January 1912, the Beiyang Army pressured the Qing to replace the empire with a republic. The empire ended with Emperor
Puyi abdication on February 12, 1912. An imperial edict authorized Yuan to form a provisional republican government and work with the rebels to unify the country.
Yuan Shikai and attempted imperial revival (1912–1916) in Chinese), first issued in 1914, became a dominant coin type of the Republic of China. On February 13, 1912, the Republic of China's National Council elected Yuan as provisional president; Sun's support made the vote unanimous. Yuan refused to move the Nanjing, claiming that the unstable military situation in the north required his attention. The National Council created a new provisional constitution in early March and in April agreed to move to Beijing, replacing the Qing national assembly. New
political parties formed for the
1912 Republic of China National Assembly elections. The KMT was created from the Tongmenghui and led by
Song Jiaoren. The
Progressive Party was led by
Liang Qichao. There was also the nationalistic Republican party, the Unification party, and over 300 smaller parties. Song was an outspoken critic of Yuan's domination of the cabinet and desire for extensive presidential powers. The election campaign did not address local government reform; after the Qing Empire dissolved, local gentry assumed power from imperial magistrates in positions meant to increase central government influence over local affairs. In January 1913, the KMT emerged as the dominant party from the elections. The relationship between Yuan and the KMT deteriorated. Song was assassinated in
Shanghai in March 1913; Yuan was suspected to be responsible but was not officially implicated. The state lacked revenue; the KMT was critical of Yuan's failure to reform tax collection and relying on foreign loans. Yuan dismissed pro-KMT military governors in May. The KMT's uprising, the
Second Revolution was suppressed; Nanjing was captured by Beiyang forces led by General
Zhang Xun in September. In October, Yuan forced the Parliament to elect him as president for a five-year term. KMT members were expelled from parliament and the party was banned. Sun went back into exile at the end of November. Yuan worked to dismantle the republic's democratic institutions. Parliament was dissolved in January 1914; it had been adjourned in November 1913 after the expulsion of KMT members left both houses without
quorums. Provincial assemblies and local government organizations were dissolved in February 1914. In May 1914, a "constitutional compact" was developed to replace the provisional constitution; the compact gave the president unlimited power over the state. Media censorship regulations were introduced in 1914.
World War I reduced foreign pressure, but Japan's
Twenty-One Demands of 1915 were accepted in modified form. Yuan and his advisors, including
Frank Johnson Goodnow, believed that China wanted an imperial restoration. Elements of the Qing state religion were revived; a
Confucian state religion was formed and Yuan became a chief participant in ceremonies at the
Temple of Heaven. In late-1915, Yuan spread rumors of popular support for his ascension to
Emperor of China. A special Representative Assembly conferred the title on Yuan in November; Yuan accepted on December 12, 1915 and declared a
new empire on January 1, 1916. Yuan's attempt to revive the empire failed. There was apathy or strong disapproval from the general population, Yuan's close allies, and other countries. Multiple provinces declared independence, and continued to do so even after Yuan abolished the monarchy in March 1916. Yuan died from
uremia on June 6, 1916.
The Warlord Era (1916–1920) Vice President
Li Yuanhong succeeded Yuan as president. Li reinstated the 1912 provisional constitution and reconvened the December 1912 parliament; legally, it was unclear whether Yuan's 1914 constitutional compact had priority or if the parliamentary members' three-year terms had expired.
Duan Qirui, acting premier since 1913 and who opposed Yuan's imperial restoration, became premier and brought the support of old Beiyang army officers. In June 1917, Zhang Xun launched a military
coup d'état; his forces occupied Beijing and announced the restoration of the Qing Empire with Puyi as emperor. The restoration ended when rival generals captured the city in July. The coup demonstrated the primacy of the warlords over the central government. Duan and Liang Qichao was in favor of entering the war on the
Allied side. President Li and Sun Yat-sen were opposed. Duan managed to strongarm parliament into breaking ties with the
German Empire. Li fired Duan when his
secret loans from Japan were revealed. Duan denounced his removal as illegal and set up base in
Tianjin. Most of the Beiyang generals sided with Duan and demanded the dissolution of parliament. In June 1917, General
Zhang Xun offered to mediate and went to Beijing with his soldiers. Backed with German funds and arms, he occupied the capital and forced Li to dissolve parliament. On July 1, he shocked the country by restoring
Puyi as
emperor. After escaping to the Japanese legation, Li reappointed Duan Qirui as premier and charged him with protecting the republic. Duan led an army that quickly defeated the
Manchu Restoration. Li resigned as president and was succeeded by Feng Guozhang. Duan refused to restore parliament due to his unpleasant experiences with it in the past. He argued that his victory over the Manchu Restoration counted as a second Xinhai Revolution and set out to craft a new provisional senate which would draft the election rules for a new parliament; this senate cut the number of seats in the future parliament by nearly half. His opponents, including President Feng, disagreed, claiming that, under Duan's argument, he should resign, as the position of premier could not exist independently from parliament. Sun Yat-sen and his followers moved to
Guangzhou to set up a rival government under the
Constitutional Protection Movement with the backing of the Yunnan clique and the
Old Guangxi clique. A rump of the old parliament held an extraordinary session. The Beiyang government
declared war on the
Central Powers in August 1917 and began sending
labor battalions to
France and a
token force to Siberia. Duan took out
large loans from Japan, claiming that he planned to build an army of a million men to send to Europe but his rivals knew this army would never leave the country: its true purpose was to crush internal dissent, since it existed outside the jurisdiction of the army ministry. Meanwhile, the war between the northern and southern governments led to a stalemate as neither side could defeat the other. Duan's favoritism in promoting relatives, friends and proteges to high positions in the military and government caused strong divisions within the Beiyang army. His followers became known as the
Anhui clique. His detractors rallied around President Feng and formed the
Zhili clique. The Zhili clique favored peaceful negotiations with the south while Duan wanted to conquer it. Duan resigned as premier due to the president's interference but his underlings pressured Feng to restore him. The
1918 elections for the new parliament were rigged to favor Duan's
Anfu Club which took three-fourths of the seats. The rest went to
Liang Shiyi's
Communications Clique,
Liang Qichao's
Research Clique, or to independents. Because President Feng was simply finishing the five-year term Yuan began in 1913, he was obliged to resign in October. Duan replaced his archrival with
Xu Shichang as president, the closest to a normal transfer of power in this government's history. Duan promised Feng's ally,
Cao Kun, the vice presidency but the Communications Clique and the Research Clique opposed it after newspapers reported that Cao lavished enormous amounts of money on a prostitute. They also preferred to give it to a figure in the renegade South as a token of reconciliation. However, no southerner took up the offer and this left the vice presidency vacant. This set up an enmity between Cao Kun and Duan. When Feng relinquished the presidency, Duan resigned his premiership. Duan, however, remained the country's most powerful man through his network in the government and military. Convening on August 12, the new parliament spent much of its time trying to draft a new constitution to replace the 1912 provisional one and engaged in polemics against the rump old parliament in the south. In the
1919 Paris Peace Conference, Duan's ally,
Cao Rulin, promised Japan all of Germany's concessions in
Shandong. This sparked the
May Fourth Movement which seriously weakened the Anhui clique's hold in government. Though the First World War had ended, the army Duan had created to send to the trenches was not disbanded. Instead, it was given to his deputy
Xu Shuzheng to
invade Outer Mongolia. This soured relations with
Zhang Zuolin of
Manchuria's
Fengtian clique who considered such a large army bordering his territory as a threat. The Zhili clique demanded more influence in the government but in December Feng Guozhang died leaving the group momentarily leaderless. Cao Kun and
Wu Peifu emerged as the leaders of the Zhili clique and they issued circular telegrams denouncing the Anhui clique. Cao and Zhang pressured the president to dismiss Xu Shuzheng. The president was already leaning against Duan for sabotaging his Shanghai peace talks with the South in 1919. Both Xu and Duan denounced the dismissal and promptly declared war on July 6, 1920. On July 14, the two sides clashed in the
Zhili–Anhui War. Within a few days, the Anhui clique was defeated and Duan retired from the military. The new parliament was dissolved on August 30.
Ascendancy of the Zhili clique (1920–1924) Although
Zhang Zuolin's
Fengtian clique played a minor role assisting the Zhili clique in the war, they were allowed to share power in Beijing.
Jin Yunpeng, who had ties to both sides, was chosen as premier. President Xu called for parliamentary elections in the summer of 1921 but because only 11 provinces took part the elections became invalid and no assembly was convened. Zhang became worried over Wu Peifu's growing military strength and anti-Japanese stance which threatened his backers in Japan. Using a financial crisis as a pretext, he removed Jin and replaced him with
Liang Shiyi in December 1921. Wu forced Liang to resign after a month accusing him of being pro-Japanese. He exposed Liang's telegram ordering diplomats to back Japan on the
Shandong Problem during the
Washington Naval Conference. Zhang then formed an alliance with Duan Qirui and Sun Yat-sen. Both sides sent circular telegrams to rally their officers and denounce their enemies. On April 28, the
First Zhili–Fengtian War began with Wu clashed with Zhang's army in
Shanhaiguan and won a major victory forcing Zhang to retreat to
Manchuria. Next, the Zhili clique started a national campaign to restore Li Yuanhong as president. Despite having co-existed with Xu Shichang for two years after the fall of Duan, they declared his presidency illegal as he was elected by an illegal parliament. They demanded Xu and Sun Yat-sen resign their rival presidencies in favor of a unified government. Wu convinced
Chen Jiongming to oust Sun from Guangzhou in return for recognition of his control over
Guangdong. Enough members of the old parliament moved to Beijing to constitute a quorum which superficially gave the government an appearance that it operated as it did before the Manchu Restoration in 1917. Li's new administration was even more powerless than his first. His cabinet appointments had to be approved by Wu Peifu. Wu's growing power and prestige outshone his mentor and superior officer, Cao Kun, which strained relations between the two. Cao wanted to become president himself but Wu tried to restrain his ambitions. President Li tried to create an "Able Men Cabinet" consisting of experts but he ruined it by arresting Finance Minister
Luo Wengan on spurious rumours supplied by the speakers of parliament. The cabinet resigned en-masse and Wu was no longer able to shield Li. Cao Kun's followers controlled the new cabinet and bribed parliament to impeach Li. Next, Cao orchestrated strikes by unpaid police and had the utilities for the presidential manor cut. Li tried to take the presidential seal with him but was intercepted. Cao Kun spent the next few months promoting his presidency by openly offering five thousand dollars to any member of parliament willing to elect him. This created universal condemnation but he was nevertheless elected and was inaugurated on
Double Ten Day, 1923 with a new constitution, the only formal constitution promulgated until 1947. He neglected his presidential duties and would rather meet with his officers than the cabinet. The vice presidency was again left vacant to entice Zhang Zuolin, Duan Qirui, or
Lu Yongxiang but none wanted to associate with Cao's infamy. In September 1924, the Zhili clique general and
Jiangsu governor
Qi Xieyuan demanded control of
Shanghai, which belongs in his province, from Lu Yongxiang's
Zhejiang the last province controlled by the Anhui clique. Fighting broke out between the two provinces with Qi quickly gaining ground. Sun Yatsen and Zhang Zuolin pledged to protect Zhejiang, sparking the
Second Zhili–Fengtian War. Zhejiang fell and for the next two months Wu was gradually winning against Zhang. In the early morning hours of October 23, General
Feng Yuxiang betrayed the Zhili clique by pulling off the
Beijing Coup. He put President Cao under house arrest. Wu reacted furiously at this betrayal by pulling his army from the front to rescue Cao. Zhang pursued and attacked Wu's rear, defeating him at Tianjin. Wu escaped to the Central Plains where
Sun Chuanfang held the line against Zhang.
Provisional Executive Government (1924–1926) ceased being official timepieces after the
coup. On November 2, 1924,
Huang Fu was made acting president after Feng Yuxiang's request. He declared Cao Kun's presidency illegal as it was obtained by bribery. Any member of parliament who voted for him was subject to arrest. The 1923 constitution was invalidated and replaced with "Regulations for the Provisional Government".
Puyi was expelled from the
Forbidden City and several other reforms were made. Zhang, a monarchist, objected to the expulsion and Huang's government. Feng and Zhang agreed to make Duan Qirui the head of the provisional government and permanently dissolve the old parliament. The Provisional Chief Executive had the combined powers of the president and premier, the ability to pick his cabinet freely, and could rule without a legislature. While theoretically very powerful, in reality, Duan was at the mercy of Feng and Zhang. Feng, Zhang, and Duan invited Sun Yat-sen north to discuss national reunification. Sun travelled to Beijing but his liver cancer progressed. Duan created a 160-member Reconstruction Conference on February 1. Sun was skeptical of Duan and Zhang who toyed with the idea of restoring Puyi. Sun died in March, leaving his southern followers divided. Duan created a provisional legislature on July 30, the Beiyang government's last assembly. A constitutional drafting commission was also held from August to December but its draft was never accepted as warfare broke out after Fengtian clique general
Guo Songling defected to Feng Yuxiang's
Guominjun in November, sparking the
Anti-Fengtian War. Wu Peifu made an alliance with Zhang against Feng in revenge for the coup. Guo was killed on December 24 and fighting went so badly against the Guominjun, Feng resigned and moved to the Soviet Union but was recalled by his officers in a few months. When the tide turned against the Guominjun, Duan restored the office of premier to shift responsibilities away from himself. The
March 18 Massacre of protesters in Beijing led to Duan's downfall. Under heavy pressure, Duan held a special session of the provisional legislature that passed a resolution condemning the massacre. It did not stop Guominjun soldiers from disarming Duan's guards and forcing the Chief Executive to flee to a diplomatic legation the next month. When Zhang's troops retook the capital weeks later, he refused to restore Duan whom he saw as a treacherous double-dealing opportunist. The capital suffered heavily during the initial occupation as Zhang and Wu's troops raped and pillaged the city's inhabitants. Zhang and Wu disagreed on who should succeed Duan. Wu wanted to restore Cao Kun as president but Zhang was vehemently opposed. What followed was a series of weak interim governments. The civil service collapsed due to the pillaging and lack of pay and the ministries existed in name only. There were mass resignations with remaining cabinet ministers pressured by the military to stay on. The only functioning parts of the bureaucracy were the postal service, customs revenue service, and the salt administration which was staffed by foreign employees. No legislature was created as it would have been too expensive and difficult to assemble.
Northern Expedition and military government (1926–1927) and
the new national flag crested on a building in
Harbin, Manchuria In July 1926, the
Kuomintang launched their
Northern Expedition to reunify China and defeat the warlords. They rapidly defeated the armies of Beiyang-affiliated warlords Wu Peifu and Sun Chuanfang, sparking Zhang Zuolin to establish the
National Pacification Army (NPA; also known as the
Anguojun/
Ankuochun) anti-Kuomintang warlord coalition in November 1926. Following a series of
internal struggles within the KMT,
Chiang Kai-shek purged the
Communists from his
National Revolutionary Army in April 1927, and the expedition was halted. During this period, a conference of the warlord leaders of the NPA was held in June 1927. They resolved that all civil and military power would be concentrated in the person of Zhang Zuolin. Zhang was declared "
Generalissimo", and consequently formed a new military government. This was the only time in the history of the Beiyang regime that it was explicitly a military government.
Pan Fu was made Prime Minister and Minister of Communications, Liu Changqing was made Minister of Agriculture and Labor, Yan Zebo was made Minister of Finance, Wang Yingtai was made Minister of Foreign Affairs, Liu Zhe was made Minister of Education,
He Fenglin was made Minister of Military Affairs (including the navy), Shen Ruilin was made Minister of the Interior,
Zhang Jinghui was made Minister of Industry, Yao Zhen was made Minister of Justice, and Xia Renhu was made Chief Cabinet Secretary. Zhang published a manifesto for the new government, declaring that he would free China from Bolshevism (the "Reds") and chaos, and that he would reverse the unequal treaties through negotiation. Soon after, Zhang's Foreign Office sent a request to the Japanese Legation in China to request the withdrawal of Japanese troops from Shandong. The civil service began to improve and start functioning again. The navy and army ministries were merged to create the Ministry of Military Affairs. In early 1927, the NPA Political Commission, in an effort to make Zhang Zuolin seem more legitimate and popular, declared that a new policy would be taken by Zhang: "Development of the democratic spirit and opposition to oppression by force. Restoration of the national sovereignty and abolition of the "unequal treaties." Improvement of economic conditions and co-operation between capital and labor. Encouragement of popular education. Enforcement of a system of local self government. Reclamation of the frontiers and colonization of undeveloped areas. Preservation of the national sovereignty and characteristics. Readjustment of official morality and development of the morality of the people." Immediately following the defeat of Wu Peifu, the Fengtian clique and the KMT had to decide what to do with the political situation in Manchuria. In August 1926,
Jiang Zuobin, a KMT general in Hubei, was sent from Guangzhou to Mukden to discuss a possible alliance. Towards Winter 1926–1927, foreign observers were predicting the possibility of a Fengtian–KMT settlement. On January 14,
Reuters reported that Yang Yuting was working with
Liang Shiyi to draw up a compromise between the two governments. During the early 1927 Fengtian–KMT negotiations, the KMT promised to "end the Northern Expedition (at Hubei, where they had already reached)", and allow the Fengtian clique to expand towards the south. According to the KMT, Zhang Zuolin would be made the Chair of the Central Executive Committee of the government according to the KMT, while Zhang himself wanted either himself or another Fengtian representative to be made President, with KMT representatives in the positions of Vice President and Premier. Zhang asked the KMT to stay to the provinces of Hunan, Hubei, Zhejiang, Sichuan, Yunnan, Guizhou, Guangdong and Guangxi, as well as ridding themselves of any foreign influence. The military government was seen by some as something that could be redeemed from warlordism. There was a push for reform and reconstruction, as well as adopting a new modernity in politics. Beijing was renamed Beiping until the end of the
Chinese Civil War in 1949. Zhang's son,
Zhang Xueliang, took over the National Pacification Army and retained a
government in exile led by Premier
Pan Fu. However, many civil servants, including former ministers and presidents, had already switched over to the
Nationalist government. The United States became the first major power to switch recognition to the Nationalist government in Nanjing on October 1. Japan was the last major power to switch because they detested the anti-Japanese attitude of the KMT. Zhang negotiated with Chiang Kai-shek to end this pretense leading to the dissolution of the Beiyang government, the NPA, and the
unification of China under the Nationalist flag on December 29, 1928. The
Japanese had poor relations with the new KMT
one-party state in Nanjing. When the Japanese created the separatist
Manchukuo in 1932, the new country used Beiyang symbolism. These were followed by
Mengjiang, the
Provisional Government, and the
Reformed Government; which all used Beiyang symbols. When the high ranking Nationalist
Wang Jingwei defected to the Japanese, he was placed in charge of the
Reorganized Government in 1940. Wang insisted upon adopting Nationalist symbols to create a parallel rival government against the
KMT government in
Chongqing instead of reviving the Beiyang government. Both Wang's government and Chongqing's
Nationalist government used near-identical symbols and claimed their continuity from Sun Yat-sen's rather than Yuan Shikai's regime. == Political system ==