The development of her body of work from a creative perspective and her footprints within different performing arts were commented on by different sociologists and commentators, Speaking about the critical interest she aroused, author Jason Hanley commented in 2015 that her performances made critics and scholars "stand up" and take note of her sound, style and message. Rather than a musician, Madonna was considered a
performer. The same year, Samuel R. Murrian from
Parade considered her the "modern master of
performance art". In 2018, Kyra Belán, an art historian and professor from
Broward College, stated she achieved major success as an artist within several
art forms, further labeling her as a female achievement. In
Women in Russian Theatre (2013), however, Catherine Schule explained that various "
avant-garde critics regard her performances as trendy schlock rather than legitimate art".
Stage shows '' and theatrical shows. During best part of her career, she attracted significant praise for her stage shows; they were regarded as "organized sequences of events, scripts, known texts and movements". Described as
tableaux vivants, senior lecturer Ian Inglis said in 2013 that her live performances have been celebrated as "theatrical events", while others deem them "immaculate performances". Writing for
Slant Magazine in 2015, Sal Cinquemani considered her "the greatest performer of our time", saying she is a "
showgirl" with theatrical shows of "narrative storytelling". Madonna has been credited with helping propel artistic concepts for stage shows and tours in her generation, mainly for mainstream pop music shows. Some pointed out, how she divided into "thematic categories" her concerts in unusual forms. In
William Baker's words, the splitting of sections derived that pretty much everyone copies or everyone is inspired by, Lester Brathwaite from
Logo TV, said she "transformed the concept of a rock concert from a mere live show into true performance art". Scholars and journalists, including
Berrin Yanıkkaya and
Matt Cain, detailed how she "paved the way" of extravaganza in concerts as a theatrical spectacle and having the female figure at center stage. If a specific title is mentioned, it is generally the
Blond Ambition World Tour, for which Jacob Bernstein of
The New York Times recognized other contemporary musicians, but with Madonna, he says, she set the tone. Speaking about her perceived influence, in
The Twisted Tale of Glam Rock (2010), Stuart Lenig wrote: "Over the decades, Madonna's carefully choreographed and performed shows became a gold standard of pop theatre, inspiring others to re-embrace the stage".
Videos " on her 2023–24
The Celebration Tour. Briefly
the most expensive music video in history, it shows references of numerous
surrealists.
Madonna's videos have received considerable critical attention since the
MTV generation of the 1980s. Reviews of her music videos have played a major role in her academic scrutiny, and a scholar has argued that she became "the most analyzed" figure among female music video stars. On the point,
Martha Bayles said in the mid-1990s, "pundits, professors and preachers" tried to interpret Madonna "taking her far more seriously than others", further explaining that it was "more important one's relation to the visual arts instead one's musical statement". Her videos were considered not merely commercial productions, but
visual performances. Her influence in the videos as an
art form, was commented on by critic
Armond White in 2015, who said "she elevated this into a memorable expressive art form" and perceived her "art-consciousness" influence in artists such as
Björk or
Lady Gaga. Scholar
Norman Fairclough made the suggestion that "the evolution of the music video could indeed be studied through Madonna". White even credited Madonna for helping "popularize" the music video format. Her impact in the format was compared to that of Michael Jackson by Sarah Frink from
Consequence, while she further credited her for set "the standard". Similar connotations were discussed by editors from
VH1, and
Slant Magazine. Retrospectively, she has been critically appreciated by mentions or rankings by music-targeted publications such as
MTV,
Billboard and
Nerdist who have listed her among the most significant music video artists. Her contemporary reception is also attested by publications such as
The Vindicator and
Montreal Gazette in the early 1990s.
Dancing . The same year,
Rolling Stone staffers commented she is "entirely synonymous with dancing". Various scholars and
dance critics have reviewed her in the artistic discipline; American sociologist
Cindy Patton was one of the first in articulate the "cultural" and "proto-political" effects of dance culture with her. In 2015, a
The Guardian dance critic, noted her forays within several dance forms from "serious art" to club trends. However, as a dancer, Madonna met mixed responses. In
Popular Music and the Politics of Hope (2019) authors observed that she is "routinely dismissed by scholars, critics, and fellow artists alike as someone who 'can't sing and can't dance'". In late twentieth century, critic
Lucy Sante called her "a graceless dancer". Others, including
Interview magazine staffers in 2011, referred to her as "the best dancer/performer since Michael Jackson". Included among
Rolling Stones poll of the "10 Favorite Dancing Musicians" in 2011, she was credited by the magazine to help bringing many underground dancing or its elements into the mainstream culture. Publishing company,
DK noted her influence in dance styles such as
voguing and
krumping saying she helped made them "globally popular". O'Brien noted her influence in
rave culture in the 1990s, and
Public Culture in
gay ball dance form. The
Smithsonian Institution said Madonna helped transform pop concerts into dance spectacles, further crediting her with popularizing the use of
headset microphones to allow greater movement and used choreography. The institution also deemed Madonna as the first performer to use her tours as reenactments of her music videos.
Acting Madonna's
acting career was also analyzed from
film studies, with British cultural theorist
Angela McRobbie, adding she was analyzed from perspectives of
feminist film theory. Madonna was considered by journalists of publications like
Portland Mercury and
Vanity Fair as an "unusual case", while authors
Lou Harry and Eric Furman concurred saying in 2005, that "there are few actors or actresses in the movies who have bombed in as many genres as Madonna has". Her industry reception, however, at best was "mixed" according to a
The Daily Telegraph contributor.
Los Angeles Times echoed criticisms and counter-criticisms, with editors of ''Encyclopedia of Women in Today's World
(2011), noting how some have seen her films or acting as "notable". Publications and authors, including Australian writer Clint Morris and website Queerty have elaborated listicles of her best movies or acting roles, while others have included her among best acting performances by musicians in movies, including Far Out
, Collider and Billboard''. For commentators like Kellner and Fresán, Madonna was better received as an actress in her music videos. Her films such as
Madonna: Truth or Dare, and
Desperately Seeking Susan, garnered
cult status in some audiences. Madonna also collected various number-one songs from motion pictures, with
Billboards
Fred Bronson saying in 1995, that only Bryan Adams, Phil Collins, Prince and Madonna belongs to the very small club of artists who have had four soundtrack singles hit the top.
Depictions and accolades According to English writer
Andrew Morton in 2001, various of
her films have been exhibited in museums around the world as "modern works of art", including the
Pompidou Center in Paris. In 2016,
MoMA PS1 screened
Madonna: Truth or Dare celebrating its 25th anniversary and impact. Her film career have been part of some tributes, including a comedic tribute in 2009 named
Almost Human: Madonna on Film, hosted by
David Schmader at Central Cinema, while
Metrograph devoted the
Body of Word: A Madonna Retrospective in 2016, a five-days retrospective celebrating her film career. A month-thematic Madonna film series was announced to be held at The Roxy Cinema in New York starting on July 27 and running through August 2023. Some of her videos were part of art exhibitions, notoriously, "
Bedtime Story" on display permanently at the
Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) and then in
Museum of the Moving Image of London. Other entities like the
School of Visual Arts screened the video as well. The 2000 article
Madonna and Hypertext, published by the
National Art Education Association in their
Studies in Art Education, explored two Madonna's videos. She has inspired some dance visuals performances. For instance, Singaporean composer, painter and poet,
Mark Chan displayed the "Dreaming of Kuanyin, Meeting Madonna" (2007) at the
Singapore International Festival of Arts, a dance and visual poem that combined dance moves, inspired by
Kuanyin,
Virgin Mary and Madonna. In 2018, Madonna was awarded by the High School of Performing Arts in Malaga (in Spanish: Escuela Superior de Artes Escénicas de Málaga, ESAEM). They rendered a performance tribute called
Madonna Revolution. In 2015, she received a tribute in the Canadian's
L'International des Feux Loto-Québec. ==Artistic reception==