Critical reception 's performance as
Seth Cohen was held in high regard by fans and critics.
Season one of
The O.C. received generally positive reviews from critics and is frequently regarded as the best season. Upon the show's premiere, Gael Fashingbauer Cooper of
MSNBC described Ryan and Seth's friendship as "the most promising plot".
The New York Times noted that "Mr. Schwartz pulled it off, sneaking a truly smart show past the gatekeepers in the guise of something commercial and trashy and fun." The reviewer also praised how the show "steered clear of both Aaron Spelling-style camp and the soggy earnestness that often characterises teen drama" and praised the integration of the adult cast into the plotlines.
IGN called it "far more engaging and interesting" than its predecessors in the teen genre. The reviewer pointed to the show's sense of humor and respect for its audience, praising the series as "very funny" and "well-acted", while referring to
Mischa Barton as the weak link.
Time Magazine critic James Poniewozik was fond of the premiere episode, saying that the show "looks to have enough heart, talent and wit to generate a few seasons' worth of luxurious suds. As Ryan would say, in the teen-soap business, being 100% original doesn't make you smart. Delivering a formula with so much style and believability that it feels new again—that does." Despite much positive reception, the first season was not without some criticism.
San Jose Mercury News criticized the plot and the casting, saying that "the storylines usually involve the obligatory three-episode-arc drug problems or lost virginity with dialogue designed to keep a dog up to speed," and that "Whoever at FOX thought Benjamin McKenzie could pass for anything younger than 25 should be fired." but still received generally positive reception. IGN noted that the second season contains some of the best moments of the series, and praised the bisexual romance between Alex and Marissa. It was said to have "managed to surpass its ratings ploy outer trappings to actually work as one of the better Marissa plotlines, at least initially, by doing a solid job of portraying her "I've never done this before..." confusion and excitement." Another review praised episodes "The Chrismukkah That Almost Wasn't" and "The Rainy Day Woman" as standout quality hours of the series, and praised the storyline that focused on Sandy and Kirsten's marriage. 's performance as
Taylor Townsend was frequently singled out as a highlight of the third and fourth seasons. In contrast to the first two,
Season 3 of the series was met with mostly negative reception. After the eventual cancellation of the show, Schwartz admitted that "the whole first half of the third season was a total mess."
IGN faulted a season which, in their opinion, had "far too much time and too many episodes spent with the less than beloved character Johnny." IGN also noted that "Kirsten and Sandy both suffered from unsatisfying stories," and that the departure of character Caleb Nichol had been a mistake "as he had been a great character to bounce off both of the elder Cohens." While looking back on the series in an interview for the complete series box-set, Schwartz explained that "somewhere around Season 3, for reasons too numerous to discuss, I lost focus. The network wasn't really supporting the show." Schwartz went on to say that the third season was probably "the most important season, because it's where I learned the most. About television, about myself as a writer, about discipline and trying to hold onto your focus even if you're hearing a lot of opinions or being forced to add things creatively that you don't agree with. And I don't think Season 4 would have been as fun or as adventurous or as weird and zany and ultimately emotional if it weren't for that experience."
The final season is generally regarded by fans and critics as a return to form for the series.
Varietys Josef Adalian said that "[the show] is once again in great creative shape." He added that "the scripts are snappy, the plots make sense, the acting's solid, [and] the music is appropriately indie" but criticized Fox for "throwing away" the show by giving it the Thursday 9:00 p.m. timeslot. Buddytv.com praised the season premiere, saying "this episode is the best OC episode since the show's first season. The absence of
Mischa Barton character of
Marissa Cooper is the best thing that's happened to The OC in a long time. The cast is now exceptional from top to bottom and the show is, at least in the first episode, much darker in tone than the first three seasons. This is a good sign." Later in the season, Buddytv.com lamented that "The OC is winding down, in all likelihood, and it's a shame. The show is hitting its creative stride just now, in its fourth season, and no one cares." Critic
Alan Sepinwall said of the premiere, "Damn. That was... not bad. No, better than that. That was good. Confident, in character, funny on occasion (any scene with Che), genuinely touching at others (the comic book store intervention), really the most like itself the show has felt in a long time, maybe even going back to season one." In a review of a later episode, Sepinwall related that the fourth season was a "resurgent season" and that "every "O.C." episode review just turns into a list of things I liked." Belinda Acosta of
The Austin Chronicle agreed, praising the show's "new energy" and its ability to successfully cover "the transition between high school and college that other series have stumbled over."
Entertainment Weeklys Ken Tucker commented that the fourth season was "a succession of terrific subplots" and praised new main cast member Taylor "as a fine, funny love interest for Ryan." Greg Elwell of
DVD Talk described Bullit as "the breakout character of the season" but commented that the season's "dark opening (...) didn't do much to keep viewers around."
IGN's Eric Goldman was also critical, saying that "as amusing as Che was, his inclusion into some later episodes gets a bit tired." Goldman also commented that "the second half of Season 4 wasn't quite as solid as the first [half]"; however, he added that while the fourth season had to prove itself again as an enjoyable watch "Josh Schwartz rose to this challenge (...) once again creating a show that was witty and self-aware."
U.S. television ratings The
pilot episode attracted 7.46 million viewers in the United States, came second in its time slot behind the season finale of
Last Comic Standing, and was the highest rated show of the night in the 12–17-year-old demographic. The most watched
O.C. episode was "
The Rivals", the seventeenth episode of season one. It attracted 12.72 million viewers, and was the lead-out to
American Idol, which attracted 29.43 million viewers that week.
The O.C. was the highest-rated new drama of the 2003–2004 season among adults aged 18 to 34, averaging a total of 9.7 million viewers. timeslot against the likes of
Survivor,
Joey and
Will & Grace. This is often cited as a cause of
The O.C.s decline in popularity. The move improved Fox's performance at the new time slot, but lost the show viewers, as average viewing figures decreased thirty percent from the previous season to 7million. For the third season, average viewing figures decreased a further twenty percent from the previous season to 5.6 million. The Thursday 9.00 pm timeslot placed the show against two other popular shows,
CSI and ''
Grey's Anatomy''. The fourth season premiered in November 2006 with very little promotion or advertisements from FOX, and was once again in the Thursday timeslot. The premiere episode attracted 3.4 million viewers, which was a series low. For the series finale, 6.7 million viewers tuned in. This was 76 percent more than the season average of 4.6 million viewers.
Awards and honors For the debut episode, "
Premiere", Schwartz received a
Writers Guild of America Award nomination for
Best Screenplay in an Episodic Drama, and casting directors Rush and Silverberg nominated in the Dramatic Pilot category of the
Artios Awards. Luke's declaration in the premiere episode of "Welcome to the O.C., bitch" was placed 83rd by
TV Land in its
100 Greatest TV Quotes and Catchphrases in 2006. The first season picked up four
Teen Choice Awards, and was nominated for another two. Additionally it was nominated for the Outstanding New Program
TCA Award, and in Australia it won a
Logie Award for Most Popular Overseas Program in
2005. For the second season the show was nominated for five
Teen Choice Awards, and won four of them, including best drama. It was nominated for the Favorite Television Drama
People's Choice Award, and
Kelly Rowan won a
PRISM Award for Performance in a Drama Series Episode, with
Peter Gallagher getting a nomination. The second-season finale was nominated for a PRISM TV Drama Series Episode award. The third season was nominated for five
Teen Choice Awards and won four of them, including "Choice Drama/Action Adventure Show" and "Choice Actor: Drama/Action Adventure," which Adam Brody won for the third consecutive year.
Legacy Schwartz said in 2023 that Marissa died in the third season because many online fans by then disliked her storyline, and the network wanted to kill a main character to increase ratings:
The O.C. popularized its setting, Orange County, and led to copycats like
MTV's reality show
Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County and the
Bravo documentary series
The Real Housewives of Orange County, and its success as a prime-time soap opera helped
Marc Cherry get
Desperate Housewives on the air. The show generated a dedicated and thriving international fan community. DVD Verdict said, "
The O.C. has become one of those rare shows whose influence has begun to extend far beyond the television screen, and has actually started to take an active role in shaping American teenage pop culture." Fans of the show, sometimes dubbed
OC Groupies, have been active in developing a large number of fan websites and forums dedicated to the program. Famous fans of the show include the Bush twins,
Jenna and
Barbara, and
Princess Beatrice. Additionally, actual UC Berkeley students created in 2004 the Sandy Cohen Public Defender Fellowship in honor of Peter Gallagher's character Sandy Cohen. The fellowship is awarded to students who plan to work as public defenders and has been presented by Gallagher. Comedy group
the Lonely Island created a parody of
The O.C. called The 'Bu. At
Boston College, students created and produced a parody titled "The BC" that received nationwide acclaim and was featured in
The New York Times and
CBS Evening News. On April 14, 2007,
Saturday Night Live aired a Digital Short titled "Dear Sister" that satirized the final scene of
The O.C.s
second-season finale. The short became popular enough to beget a wave of re-enactments and parodies using "
Hide and Seek" with the music set to slow-motion scenes of violence from various films and television series. In 2020, the
Netflix show
Outer Banks was compared to
The O.C. by publications such as
Glamour.
Marvel described
Runaways (created for television by Schwartz and Savage) as
The O.C. of the Marvel Universe, even before they hired Schwartz and Savage to run the series. Independent
Washington University in St. Louis newspaper
Student Life said that, "
The O.C.s" legacy will live on through its viewers. Whether you wear a 'Save Marissa' shirt, a leather wristcuff or hoodie in honor of Ryan or listen to Death Cab for Cutie, as Seth did, know that "
The O.C." was a cultural phenomenon that will not be forgotten." ==Complementary media==