Reactions towards Madonna among religious press and community, as well from general public for her religious display, vary with different degrees and perspectives.
Religious community The Christian community has been described as the religious sector most offended by Madonna. Outside Christian religious community, in 2005,
Reuters also informed: She "[...] has drawn frequent censure from
ultra-Orthodox Jews who say her embrace of Kabbalah debases their religion". Some of them deemed Madonna as a "depraved cultural icon". Madonna's persona and work were both analyzed and commented in some religious-targeted publications. Colombian newspaper
El Tiempo remarked in 1997, a dedicated article to Madonna and her film
Evita by Italian's Catholic newspaper
Famiglia Cristiana. She topped 2013's rank by
Religion News Service of the "10 'blasphemous' pop songs and music videos". In the book
What about Christian Rock? (1986), authors compared how the religious press called Christian singer
Sheila Walsh "sexy", while labeling "porn queen Madonna '
born again'". They also reported about the nickname given to
Amy Grant, as the "
Madonna of Christian Rock", explaining that some publications picked it up, but when it appeared in the religious press, it offended many Christian readers. Susan also compared Saint
Hildegard of Bingen's reputation, saying her fan base "continue to grow eight centuries after her death". In 2006, during her
Confessions Tour,
Christine Whelan dedicated an article to Madonna in
Paulist Fathers'
Busted Halo, receiving commentaries by website's community. Broadly, American religion historian
Randall J. Stephens wrote in ''The Devil's Music: How Christians Inspired, Condemned, and Embraced Rock ’n’ Roll'' (2016), that some Christians might find the songs of performers such as
the Beatles,
Led Zeppelin or Madonna "degraded and artless". Madonna appeared with other entertainers in
Focus on the Family's
Chart Watch book of 1998, where some albums were reviewed, remarking their "pro-social content" and "objectionable" content, as well an "advisory" to readers. Various Madonna's concerts were condemned by religious adherents, including
radical Orthodox believers. She angered many Polish religious adherents in various of her stops when she toured. According to
Evangelical Times during her Dutch stop of the
Confessions Tour, police arrested a 63-year-old priest who admitted to making a
hoax call in an attempt to disrupt the event. A
bomb threat was also reported. In January 2023, Madonna sparked again outrage among Christian community after doing an all-female
Last Supper photoshoot, and also for channeling Virgin Mary as
Our Lady of Sorrows, on the first
Vanity Fairs European "Icon issue".
The European Conservative headlined, that her photoshoots "Reveals Deep Occult Roots of the Entertainment Industry". Moderate views have been also reported. Jock McGregor, a contributor to the
evangelical organization
L'Abri commented that "not all Christians have been hostile" toward Madonna. McGregor, himself, considered dedicating a few words to Madonna because she is "a significant and representative child of her times".
Anglican British writer,
Karl Dallas commented at some point that "so far she has done little more than to use the talents God gave her, and challenged a few sensibilities with them".
Theological, secular and other views Madonna has also been criticized from reviewers of non-religious targeted press, although throughout years, others have interpreted her religious display differently as well, with some favoring
free speech. In
Stealing My Religion: Not Just Any Cultural Appropriation (2022), her usage of Catholic aesthetics is understood as an
appropriation "to promote her brand". Academic Anne-Marie Korte, similarly states she uses Christian symbols and misuses them to attract attention while showing disrespect for Christian and for religion in general. Media scholar
John Fiske once felt and stated that her uses of religious iconography are neither religious nor sacrilegious. {{multiple image|perrow =3|total_width= 410 During the release of her video of "Like a Prayer", it was reported that
religious liberals supported her as a
martyr to free speech. According to authors of
Doing Gender in Media, Art and Culture (2009), some theologians have supported Madonna, including her 2006 stage crucifixion, been called as a "contribution to
feminist theology and
liberation theology". In 2008, Gail Walker from
Belfast Telegraph brought the
scandals that Catholic Church have rocked, and also commented that her "musings on the simple icons of her culture seem more a positive recognition of the emotional power of Christianity than ridicule of it". Outside Christian world, some Hindu scholars backed Madonna's display of their religious traditions, including
Vagish Shastri after the criticism she faced by religious organizations like
World Vaisnava Association with her performance at MTV in
1998. Her conduit was also addressed. In
Profiles of Female Genius (1994), editor compared that "if nothing else, she is honest" with her reflection, describing that despite she is offensive and appear sacrilegious to most people, he believes she is "more honest than many women see walking the streets of the world with crucifixes". Journalists
Andrew Breitbart and
Mark Ebner called Madonna, the "Mother Superior of perpetual self-
indulgence". In the late-twentieth century, American journalist
Pete Hamill even considered her "a good Christian".
Some Madonna's responses and others interpretations Some of Madonna's statements as responses to controversies were documented. During the
Blond Ambition World Tour, she invited the clergy of Vatican to attend the concert and "judge for themselves", while stated that her show was a "theatrical presentation of my music, and like theater, it ask questions, provokes thought [...]" and that the moral also include "believe in freedom and in God". As one of her most controversial performances, she claimed about her stage crucifixion in the
Confessions Tour, that her performance was "neither anti-Christian, sacrilegious or blasphemous" and "it is not different than a persona wearing a cross". In 2018, Justin Ravitz from entertainment website
Refinery29, labeled her as maybe one of the most famous Catholics in the world, and remarked her relationship and response to Catholicism, as a "confrontational and provocative" from the jump. Feminist scholar
Camille Paglia described Madonna in 1991, as "the latest atavistic discoverer of the
pagan heart of Catholicism". According to
Premier Christian in 2015, her shows of the Rebel Heart Tour were accused of "Catholic-bashing" and for which Catholic League's
Bill Donohue, said that her "anti-Catholic performances" are for her, and her fans, "a one thing that never gets old". For others, according to National World's Molly Paul, both her actions and religious themes may have crossed the line one "too many times". After her usage of
Revelation 2:9's term of
Synagogue of Satan, in the remix "Justify my Love" ("The Beast Within"), whom rabbi
Abraham Cooper labeled as
antisemitism, or
"Jew as Devil", Madonna responded through her publicist according to the
Associated Press. == Madonna and metaphors ==