• 1890 (WPC) -
Allegheny Athletic Association (3-2-1) • 1891 (WPC) -
Pittsburgh Athletic Club (7-0-0) • 1892 (WPC) - Allegheny Athletic Association 4, Pittsburgh Athletic Club 0 • 1894 (WPC) - Allegheny Athletic Association 30, Pittsburgh Athletic Club 0 • 1895 (WPC) -
Duquesne Country and Athletic Club 10, Pittsburgh Athletic Club 6 • 1896 (WPC) - Allegheny Athletic Association 18, Pittsburgh Athletic Club 0 • 1897 (WPC) -
Greensburg Athletic Association 6,
Latrobe Athletic Association 0 • 1898 (WPC) - Duquesne Country and Athletic Club 16,
Western Pennsylvania All-Stars 0 • 1900 (WPC) -
Homestead AC 30, East End Athletic Association (Pittsburgh) 0 • 1901 (WPC) -
Homestead AC 18,
Philadelphia Athletics 0 • 1902 (NFL1902) –
Pittsburgh Stars 11,
Philadelphia Athletics 0 ::: (WSF) –
All-Syracuse 36,
Orange AC 0 ::: (OIC) –
Akron East Ends • 1903 (OIC) –
Massillon Tigers (8-1-0) 11, Akron East Ends 0 ::: (WPC) -
Latrobe Athletic Association 6, Pennsylvania Railroad YMCA 0 ::: (WSF) –
Franklin Athletic Club 12,
Watertown Red & Black 0 • 1904 (OIC) –
Massillon Tigers (7-0-0) 6, Akron East Ends 5 ::: (WPC) -
Latrobe Athletic Association 5, Steelton Athletic Club 0 • 1905 (OIC) –
Massillon Tigers (10-0-0) 10,
Canton Bulldogs 0 • 1906 (OIC) –
Massillon Tigers (10-1-0) 13, Canton Bulldogs 6 • 1907 (OIC) –
All-Massillons (7-0-1, won by a common-opponent tiebreaker over the
Shelby Blues) • 1908 (OIC) –
Akron Indians 8-0-1 • 1909 (OIC) –
Akron Indians (9-0-0) 12, Shelby Blues 9 • 1910 (OIC) –
Shelby Blues/
Shelby Tigers (14-0-1) 8, Akron Indians 5 • 1911 (OIC) –
Shelby Blues (10-0-0) 1, Canton Bulldogs 0 (forfeit) • 1912 (OIC) –
Elyria Athletics (8-0-0) • 1913 (OIC) –
Akron Indians (8-1-2) 20, Shelby Blues 0 • 1914 (OIC) –
Akron Indians (8-2-1) 21, Canton Bulldogs 0 • 1915 (OIC) –
Youngstown Patricians (8-0-1) 13,
Washington Vigilants 7 • 1916 (OIC) –
Canton Bulldogs (9-0-1) 24, Massillon Tigers 0 • 1917 (OIC) –
Canton Bulldogs (9-1-0) 7,
Detroit Heralds 0 ::: (NYPFL) –
All-Tonawanda 9,
Rochester Jeffersons 7 • 1918 (OIC) –
Dayton Triangles (8-0-0) 62, Miamis 0 ::: (Buffalo Semi-Pro FL) –
Buffalo Niagaras 5-0-0, did not play outside Buffalo due to
1918 flu pandemic • 1919 (OIC) –
Canton Bulldogs 9-0-1 ::: (NYPFL) –
Buffalo Prospects 20,
Rochester Jeffersons 0 ::: (Self proclaim) -
Rock Island Independents == 1920-1932 ==