In 2004, three Liberal organizers, former Liberal candidate
Alfred Apps, Ian Davey (son of Senator
Keith Davey) and lawyer Daniel Brock, travelled to
Cambridge, Massachusetts, to convince Ignatieff to move back to Canada and run for the
House of Commons of Canada, and to consider a possible bid for the Liberal leadership should Paul Martin retire.
Rocco Rossi, who was at that time a key Liberal Party organizer, had previously mentioned to Davey that Davey's father had said that Ignatieff had "the makings of a prime minister". In January 2005, as a result of the efforts of Apps, Brock and Davey, press speculation that Ignatieff could be a
star candidate for the Liberals in the next election, and possibly a candidate to eventually succeed Prime Minister
Paul Martin, the leader of the governing
Liberal Party of Canada. After months of rumours and several denials, Ignatieff confirmed in November 2005 that he would run for a seat in the House of Commons in the
winter 2006 election. It was announced that Ignatieff would seek the Liberal nomination in the Toronto riding of Etobicoke—Lakeshore. Some
Ukrainian-Canadian members of the
riding association objected to the nomination, citing a perceived anti-Ukrainian sentiment in
Blood and Belonging, where Ignatieff said: "I have reasons to take the Ukraine seriously indeed. But, to be honest, I'm having trouble. Ukrainian independence conjures up images of peasants in embroidered shirts, the nasal whine of ethnic instruments, phony Cossacks in cloaks and boots..." Critics also questioned his commitment to Canada, pointing out that Ignatieff had lived outside of Canada for more than 30 years and had referred to himself as an American many times. When asked about it by
Peter Newman in a ''
Maclean's'' interview published on April 6, 2006, Ignatieff said: "Sometimes you want to increase your influence over your audience by appropriating their voice, but it was a mistake. Every single one of the students from 85 countries who took my courses at Harvard knew one thing about me: I was that funny Canadian." Two other candidates filed for the nomination but were disqualified (one, because he was not a member of the party and the second because he had failed to resign from his position on the
riding association executive). Ignatieff went on to defeat the Conservative candidate by a margin of roughly 5,000 votes to win the
seat.
2006 leadership bid After the Liberal government was defeated in the January 2006 federal election,
Paul Martin resigned the party leadership in March that same year. On April 7, 2006, Ignatieff announced his candidacy in the upcoming
Liberal leadership race, joining several others who had already declared their candidacy. Ignatieff received
several high-profile endorsements of his candidacy. His campaign was headed by
Senator David Smith, who had been a
Chrétien organizer, along with
Ian Davey,
Daniel Brock,
Alfred Apps and Paul Lalonde, a Toronto lawyer and son of
Marc Lalonde. An impressive team of policy advisors was assembled, led by Toronto lawyer Brad Davis, and including Brock, fellow lawyers
Mark Sakamoto, Sachin Aggarwal, Jason Rosychuck, Jon Penney, Nigel Marshman, Alex Mazer,
Will Amos, and Alix Dostal, former Ignatieff student Jeff Anders, banker Clint Davis, economists Blair Stransky, Leslie Church and Ellis Westwood, and Liberal operatives Alexis Levine, Marc Gendron, Mike Pal,
Julie Dzerowicz, Patrice Ryan, Taylor Owen and Jamie Macdonald. Following the selection of delegates in the party's "Super Weekend" exercise on the last weekend of September, Ignatieff gained more support from delegates than other candidates, with 30% voting for him. In August 2006, Ignatieff said he was "not losing any sleep" over dozens of civilian deaths caused by Israel's attack on
Qana during its military actions in
Lebanon. Ignatieff recanted those words the following week. Then, on October 11, 2006, Ignatieff described the Qana attack as a war crime (committed by Israel).
Susan Kadis, who had been Ignatieff's campaign co-chair, withdrew her support following the comment. Other Liberal leadership candidates have also criticized Ignatieff's comments. Ariela Cotler, a Jewish community leader and the wife of prominent Liberal MP
Irwin Cotler, left the party following Ignatieff's comments. Ignatieff later qualified his statement, saying "Whether war crimes were committed in the attack on Qana is for international bodies to determine. That doesn't change the fact that Qana was a terrible tragedy." On October 14, Ignatieff announced that he would visit Israel to meet with Israeli and
Palestinian leaders and "learn first-hand their view of the situation". He noted that
Amnesty International,
Human Rights Watch and Israel's own
B'Tselem have stated that war crimes were committed in Qana, describing the suggestion as "a serious matter precisely because Israel has a record of compliance, concern and respect for the laws of war and human rights". Ignatieff added that he would not meet with Palestinian leaders who did not recognize Israel. However, the Jewish organization sponsoring the trip subsequently cancelled it, because of too much media attention.
Convention At the leadership convention in
Montreal, taking place at
Palais des Congrès, Ignatieff entered as the apparent front-runner, having won more delegates to the convention than any other contender. However, polls consistently showed he had weak second-ballot support, and those delegates not already tied to him would be unlikely to support him later. On December 1, 2006, Ignatieff led the leadership candidates on the first ballot, garnering 29% support. The subsequent ballots were cast the following day, and Ignatieff managed a small increase, to 31% on the second ballot, good enough to maintain his lead over
Bob Rae, who had attracted 24% support, and
Stéphane Dion, who garnered 20%. However, due to massive movement towards Dion by delegates who supported
Gerard Kennedy, Ignatieff dropped to second on the third ballot. Shortly before voting for the third ballot was completed, with the realization that there was a Dion–Kennedy pact, Ignatieff campaign co-chair
Denis Coderre made an appeal to Rae to join forces and prevent Dion from winning the Liberal Party leadership (on the basis that Stephane Dion's ardent federalism would alienate Quebecers), but Rae turned down the offer and opted to release his delegates. With the help of the Kennedy delegates, Dion jumped up to 37% support on the third ballot, in contrast to Ignatieff's 34% and Rae's 29%. Rae was eliminated and the bulk of his delegates opted to vote for Dion rather than Ignatieff. In the fourth and final round of voting, Ignatieff took 2084 votes and lost the contest to Dion, who won with 2,521 votes. Ignatieff confirmed that he would run as the Liberal MP for Etobicoke—Lakeshore in the next federal election.
Deputy Leader of the Liberal Party On December 18, 2006, new Liberal leader
Stéphane Dion named Ignatieff his deputy leader, in line with Dion's plan to give high-ranking positions to each of his former leadership rivals. During three by-elections held on September 18, 2007, the
Halifax Chronicle-Herald reported that unidentified Dion supporters were accusing Ignatieff's supporters of undermining by-election efforts, with the goal of showing that Dion could not hold on to the party's Quebec base. Susan Delacourt of the
Toronto Star described this as a recurring issue in the party with the leadership runner-up.
The National Post referred to the affair as, "Discreet signs of a mutiny." Although Ignatieff called Dion to deny the allegations,
The Globe and Mail cited the NDP's widening lead after the article's release, suggested that the report had a negative impact on the Liberals' morale. The Liberals were defeated in their former stronghold of
Outremont by future NDP leader
Thomas Mulcair. Since then, Ignatieff urged the Liberals to put aside their differences, saying "united we win, divided we lose".
Interim Leader in Ottawa on February 19, 2009 Dion announced that he would schedule his departure as Liberal leader for the next party convention, after the Liberals lost seats and support in the
2008 federal election. Ignatieff held a news conference on November 13, 2008, to once again announce his candidacy for the leadership of the Liberal Party of Canada. When the
Liberals reached an accord with the other opposition parties to form a coalition and defeat the government, Ignatieff reluctantly endorsed it. He was reportedly uncomfortable with a coalition with the NDP and support from the Bloc Québécois, and has been described as one of the last Liberals to sign on. After the announcement to
prorogue Parliament, delaying the non-confidence motion until January 2009, Dion announced his intention to stay on as leader until the party selected a new one. On December 10, he was formally declared the interim leader in a caucus meeting, and his position was ratified at the May 2009 convention. The vote was mostly a formality as the other candidates had stepped down. On August 31, 2009, Ignatieff announced that the Liberal Party would withdraw support for the government of Prime Minister
Stephen Harper. However, the NDP under
Jack Layton abstained and the Conservatives survived the confidence motion. Ignatieff's attempt to force a September 2009 election was reported as a miscalculation, as polls showed that most Canadians did not want another election. Ignatieff's popularity as well as that of the Liberals dropped off considerably immediately afterwards.
2011 election On March 25, 2011, Ignatieff introduced a motion of
non-confidence against the Harper government to attempt to force a
May 2011 federal election after the government was found to be in
contempt of Parliament, the first such occurrence in
Commonwealth history. The House of Commons passed the motion by 156–145. The Liberals had considerable momentum when the writ was dropped. Ignatieff successfully squeezed NDP leader
Jack Layton out of media attention by issuing challenges to Harper for one-on-one debates. In the first couple of weeks of the campaign, Ignatieff kept his party in second place in the polls, and his personal ratings exceeded that of Layton for the first time. However, opponents frequently criticized Ignatieff's perceived political opportunism, particularly during the
leaders debates, during which Layton criticized Ignatieff for having a poor attendance record for Commons votes, commenting "You know, most Canadians, if they don't show up for work, they don't get a promotion". Ignatieff failed to defend himself against these charges, and the debates were said to be a turning point for his party's campaign. Ignatieff was also subject to scathing attack ads by the Conservative Party, slamming him as "Just visiting" Canada and "
He Didn't Come Back For You" for the sake of political advancement. Near the end of the campaign, a late surge in support for Layton and the NDP relegated Ignatieff and the Liberals to third in the polls. On
May 2, 2011, Ignatieff's Liberals lost 43 seats only winning 34 and thus slipped to third party status behind the NDP and the Conservatives, who gained a majority in Parliament. It was the worst result in the history of the Liberal Party, the worst result in Canadian history for an incumbent Official Opposition party, and the first time since Confederation the Liberals failed to finish first or second. Ignatieff was defeated by Conservative challenger
Bernard Trottier, becoming the first incumbent Leader of the Official Opposition to lose his own seat since
Charles Tupper's defeat in Cape Breton in 1900, as well as the first sitting Liberal leader since
Mackenzie King lost his riding in the 1945 election. Reports suggested that Ignatieff had initially promised to move into a home inside his riding, but instead he resided in the downtown Toronto neighbourhood of Yorkville, which rankled Etobicoke–Lakeshore residents and reinforced perceptions of Ignatieff's political opportunism. On May 3, 2011, Ignatieff announced that he would be resigning as leader of the party pending the appointment of an
interim leader; his resignation went into effect on May 25 when Bob Rae was appointed as Ignatieff's interim replacement. ==Post-political career==