Reactions and destruction of evidence , discovered in a room at the Watergate Hotel, June 18, 1972 On the morning of June 18, Liddy visited the CRP, destroyed Gemstone files, and reported the arrests to Magruder. Nixon was informed shortly thereafter. Later that day, federal prosecutors
Earl Silbert and
Chuck Work searched the burglars' hotel rooms: they found spying gear, $100 bills, papers mentioning Hunt, Barker's address books (listing "WH"), and Martínez's telephone directory (listing "W. House"). Investigators learned that the burglars had given pseudonyms, that McCord worked for the CRP, and that the White House had conducted a background check on Hunt. The burglars did not cooperate with the FBI or in court. Visited by FBI agents, Hunt admitted that a check found at Watergate was his but refused further comment. On June 19, CIA agent Lee Pennington Jr. destroyed incriminating material at McCord's home. The CRP conducted a "massive housecleaning": Magruder burned Gemstone files at his home, and Colson destroyed pages in the White House phone directory listing Hunt. Nixon made his first public statement on Watergate on June 22, denying White House involvement. Following Ehrlichman's orders, Dean had Hunt's White House safe drilled open; Ehrlichman told Dean to "
deep six" incriminating files in the
Potomac River. As a Secret Service agent and two aides had seen the files' removal, Dean feared perjuring himself in future testimony. On June 27, he instead gave nonsensitive files to the FBI and sensitive files—on the Fielding burglary and other Plumber activities—directly to acting FBI director
L. Patrick Gray. Dean personally destroyed two Hunt notebooks and an address book, and Gray burned the surrendered files around Christmas 1972.
Early press investigations and
Carl Bernstein, 2024 Shortly after the break-in, DNC counsel
Joseph Califano Jr. notified
The Washington Post: editor
Barry Sussman assigned veteran journalist
Alfred Lewis and the novices
Bob Woodward and
Carl Bernstein to the story. The team found that four of the burglars were Cuban exiles; Woodward attended the burglars' preliminary hearing, where McCord admitted to being former CIA.
The Washington Posts next issue contained three stories on Watergate, but the scandal received negligible coverage from papers like
The New York Times. Based on the address book and letters found in the burglar's suite, Woodward and Bernstein contacted the White House
switchboard and asked for Hunt. They were connected to "Mr. Colson's office" and then referred to Hunt's office at the Mullen Company PR Firm. They were able to reach Hunt, who hung up. Contacting acquaintances, they learned that Hunt was "with the CIA" and that McCord had created a presidential list of "domestic radicals" and a censorship plan in case of a national emergency. Based on Sussman's research on Colson, the trio published a headline implicating the White House: "White House Consultant Linked to Bugging Suspects". Press attention on the "Watergate caper" grew from other outlets.
The New York Times Latin-American specialist
Tad Szulc connected the Cuban burglars to past CIA plots and Hunt to the Bay of Pigs.
Kidnapping of Martha Mitchell was kidnapped and sedated.
Martha Mitchell, the wife of CRP head John Mitchell, was a vocal Nixon supporter and, according to Graff, "perhaps the first national
conservative celebrity pundit". After the arrests, John Mitchell distanced the CRP from McCord—who had previously been assigned to guard Martha—claiming he was just an outside security contractor. Through aides, he unsuccessfully tried to prevent Martha from seeing news about McCord. Furious at the deception, Martha had a
nervous episode. If her husband would not leave politics, she threatened to permanently leave D.C. and contact
UPI reporter
Helen Thomas. In a locked bedroom of a
Newport Beach villa, Martha's call to Thomas was interrupted when bodyguard
Steve King broke down the door, destroyed the phone, and restrained her. A thwarted morning escape attempt from King resulted in Martha slicing her hand on a broken glass door. A doctor visited the house and forcibly sedated Martha, who was restrained and had her pants removed by FBI and Secret Service agents. Other escape attempts also failed. Her concerned husband had her flown to the
Westchester Country Club in New York, where she called Thomas, stating that "I'm black and blue. I'm a political prisoner". She was then interviewed by the
New York Daily News. John and his team denied Martha's account and blocked the FBI from interviewing her. On June 30, less than two weeks after the break-in, John Mitchell resigned to tend to his wife and because he had become a liability for Nixon.
"Smoking Gun" conversation The FBI traced $4,500 from the burglars' suite to Barker's account, which had received $89,000 in four Mexican checks and a $25,000 check from the CRP's
Midwest finance chairman
Kenneth Dahlberg, closing in on the "money trail" source: CRP contributions. The FBI's progress—including a hypothesis by the Washington field office head that Watergate was "in furtherance of the White House efforts to locate and identify 'leaks'"—alarmed the White House. As Gray was considering CIA involvement, Dean, Haldeman, and Mitchell plotted to have the CIA pressure the FBI to drop its probe under the pretense of national security. On June 23, Nixon approved the plan and instructed Haldeman in a recorded conversation known as the
"Smoking Gun" tape: "... When you get in (inaudible) people, say 'Look, the problem is that this will open the whole, the whole Bay of Pigs thing, and the President just feels that ah, without going into the details — don't, don't lie to them to the extent to say no involvement, but just say this is a comedy of errors, without getting into it, the President believes that it is going to open the whole Bay of Pigs thing up again. And, ah, because these people are plugging for (inaudible) and that they should call the FBI in and (inaudible) don't go any further into this case period!'" Haldeman and Ehrlichman relayed this message to CIA director
Richard Helms and deputy director
Vernon Walters in a White House meeting: Helms agreed to pressure the FBI to end their investigation by claiming that it might reveal CIA
money laundering. Although he threatened to resign, Walters reluctantly repeated this message to Gray; he refused to halt the investigation unless the CIA put the request in writing, which it rebuffed. The meaning of "the whole Bay of Pigs thing" has drawn much attention. Helms deemed it "incoherent"; investigators for the
Senate Select Committee on Intelligence suspected it referred to the
then-secret CIA assassination attempts on Cuban leader Castro but did not raise the subject with Nixon during 1975 testimony. Haldeman's memoir said it was Nixon's "way of reminding Helms, not so gently, of the cover-up of the CIA assassination attempts on the hero of the Bay of Pigs, Fidel Castro, a CIA operation that
may have triggered the Kennedy tragedy and which Helms desperately wanted to hide." Journalist
Jefferson Morley cites another tape in which Nixon mentions "
the 'Who shot John?' angle" to support Haldeman's interpretation.
Deep Throat , revealed to be "
Deep Throat" in 2005, was labeled by
The New York Times as "the most famous anonymous source in American history". In 1971, Hoover made
Mark Felt deputy associate director and his apparent successor. Felt was spurned after Hoover's 1972 death when Nixon selected L. Patrick Gray as acting director (avoiding a pre-election
Senate confirmation). Gray named Felt as acting associate director. Hoping to become director, Felt sought to undermine Gray through leaks. Woodward first met Felt in 1970, and he became a key anonymous source. No one else at the
Post knew his identity; editor
Howard Simons dubbed him "Deep Throat", referencing both his
deep background status and the 1972 pornographic film
Deep Throat. Woodward and Bernstein also relied on the anonymous "Z": a female grand juror. Felt gave Woodward many early Watergate leads but soon avoided the telephone. According to Woodward, Felt created a covert protocol to schedule 2 a.m. rendezvous in an underground garage in
Rosslyn, Virginia. The system involved Woodward placing a flag on his sixth floor apartment's balcony and Felt intercepting and notating Woodward's daily
The New York Times. Felt also leaked to
The Washington Daily News and
Times Sandy Smith; other FBI agents, like the Washington field office head, were also likely leakers. Woodward and Bernstein's role in Watergate is often exaggerated, and some, including
Post managing editor
Ben Bradlee and biographer
Adrian Havill, have criticized their account as overly cinematic and have identified inaccuracies.
Edward Jay Epstein wrote that their reporting was derivative or the mere presentation of leaks. Woodward has said that "the mythologizing of our role in Watergate has gone to the point of absurdity, where journalists write... that I, single-handedly, brought down Richard Nixon. Totally absurd."
Obstruction and bribery 's wife Dorothy on
United Air Lines Flight 553, Bay of Pigs invasion leader
Manuel Artime (seen far left with President Kennedy in 1962) dispersed the hush money. By July, Baldwin was granted immunity by the FBI and provided their first major insight into Watergate. The administration grew concerned over $250,000 in CRP funds authorized for Liddy's operations, of which $199,000 was used. That month, Magruder pressed CRP treasurer
Hugh Sloan to fabricate a narrative of CRP payments to Liddy, suggesting perjury. Sloan, conflicted, confided to two lawyers, fled to California, and then returned to D.C. a week later to resign from the CRP. He confessed to the U.S. attorney's office and gave truthful grand jury testimony. Alarmed, Mitchell convened with Magruder, Dean, and Nixon advisor
Fred LaRue to concoct a cover. They decided to inflate funding for Liddy's less illicit activities, such as campus surveillance of radicals, and convinced aide
Herbert Porter to perjure himself. Their motto became "
The buck stops with Liddy", who was fired from the CRP to create distance. Other efforts including delaying FBI interviews on "national security" grounds, coaching witnesses, and having Dean and assistant
Fred Fielding sit in on FBI interviews of White House staff. They also disrupted the grand jury by making staffers testify privately at the DOJ, rather than before jurors that could assess their credibility. Throughout the grand jury investigation, prosecutors Silbert and especially
Henry Petersen were overly deferent to Nixon. Before the burglary, an unknown official had assured Liddy that the Plumbers would be "taken care of" financially if caught. Liddy reminded Mitchell of this, leading Dean to unsuccessfully ask CIA deputy director Walters to front
hush money. Dean then convinced Nixon's former deputy campaign finance manager
Herbert Kalmbach to provide the bribes. Ulasewicz delivered $180,000 in cash to the Plumbers, dispersed by Hunt's wife and, after her death on
United Air Lines Flight 553, by Bay of Pigs invasion leader
Manuel Artime.
Patman probe and indictment of the Plumbers in the largest landslide in American history. In August 1972, the
Government Accountability Office released an audit of Nixon's re-election campaign, referring $350,000 in questionable transactions to the DOJ for prosecution. The DOJ did not pursue these, and Nixon declined to appoint a special prosecutor.
Wright Patman, the Democrat
House Banking Committee chair, initiated his own probe. Like the FBI, his committee was stonewalled by the White House. In September, O'Brien's legal team—all of whom also worked for the
Post—interviewed Baldwin, yielding a front-page story for Woodward and Bernstein. Felt used the story to shift leaking suspicion to other FBI staffers, and Silbert made the FBI search his office and the grand jury room for bugs: none were found. Another wiretap of unclear origin was found in Oliver's DNC office. On September 13, the Patman probe released a confidential report on the Mexican transactions: the findings were leaked to the
Post. Fearing more revelations, Nixon used
House Republican leader Gerald Ford to stop the probe from gaining
subpoena power. On September 15, Hunt, Liddy, and the five burglars were indicted on eight counts, none relating to the misuse of campaign funds. The limited indictment, sparing Nixon officials, was a White House victory, and Eisenhower appointee
John Sirica assigned himself as judge. Baldwin then gave his complete account of Watergate to the
Los Angeles Times Jack Nelson and
Ronald Ostrow. Although Hunt's lawyers and Silbert convinced Sirica to issue a gag order and advise the
Times against publication, the paper printed the story—the first directly linking the break-in to the White House—on October 5. The cover-up proved effective, and Democrats could not make Watergate a campaign issue. Although most Americans knew of the break-in, few associated it with Nixon, and in November he won re-election in the largest landslide in American history, winning 49 of 50 states.
Trial thrice met with
James McCord alongside the
George Washington Parkway to dissuade him from cooperating with prosecutors. On January 6, 1973, Dean promised Liddy $30,000 annually, legal fees, and a 1975 pardon if he stayed silent; as early as January 8, Nixon discussed "Goddamn hush money" with Colson. Two days later, the trial began, the Silbert-led prosecution arguing that McCord and Liddy were rogue agents and that Hunt and the other burglars acted on Liddy's payments. Hunt and the Cubans unexpectedly pleaded guilty. Using Sturgis as a source,
The New York Times Seymour Hersh—who had exposed the
My Lai massacre—revealed that the burglars were receiving hush money and were pressured to plead guilty. Questioned by Sirica, the Cubans refused to say who sent the payments. The White House learned that McCord, who had expressed concerns that he or the CIA might be scapegoated, was considering cooperating with prosecutors. Through Ulasewicz, Dean promised McCord an eventual government job and his family's financial security. To calm McCord, Caulfield thrice met with him alongside the
George Washington Parkway. McCord proposed that the trial could be dismissed if prosecutors introduced telephone conversations regarding Watergate that he had made to the
Israeli and
Chilean embassies—both of which were illegally wiretapped. Dean rejected this approach. In the trial's only interruption, Oliver's lawyer
Charles Morgan convinced Sirica and Silbert to suspend the trial to stop Baldwin from describing the conversations from Oliver's wiretap: an appeals court sealed the transcripts. As of 2022, these remain secret and are, according to Graff, "the last and potentially only chance to [know] whether... the burglary and wiretapping plot included a sexual motive". In resumed testimony, administration officials denied involvement in the break-in. Dissatisfied with Silbert's examination, Sirica made the unusual move to interrogate the officials privately. On January 30, the jury found the last two defendants—Liddy and McCord—guilty on all counts, and Sirica scheduled sentencing for March 23. After setting bail at $100,000 each on February 2, he declared that he was "still not satisfied that all pertinent facts that might be available... have been produced before an American jury".
Ervin Committee and the "Dean Report" In addition to the trial's perceived failure, a multi-month, secret inquiry by Senator Ted Kennedy raised Congress' suspicions about Watergate. On February 7, 1973, the Senate voted 77–0 to establish a
select committee to investigate Watergate, naming Senator
Sam Ervin of
North Carolina as chairman. Ervin in turn selected
Samuel Dash as chief counsel. The Ervin Committee took over files created by both Ted Kennedy and the Patman probe. Due to his loyalty, Nixon nominated Gray as FBI director. During his confirmation proceedings, Gray admitted that he had given the bureau's investigative Watergate reports to John Dean, alarming both his own agents and the senators. In a bid to save his nomination, Gray offered the reports to Congress, which was vetoed by an infuriated Nixon. In late February, Nixon devised two ways to stop the committee:
executive privilege—a then-vague doctrine that the
Constitution's
separation of powers prevented presidential disclosure to Congress—and the release of an exonerative "Dean Report". The report was, according to Graff, "mythic" as Dean had never conducted a real investigation of Watergate and was himself involved. On March 21, Dean told Nixon that "I have the impression that you don't know everything I know" and gave a full account of Watergate—which he called "a cancer within"—particularly blaming Liddy and Magruder. Although Nixon seemed largely ignorant and asked over 150 questions, Dean was sometimes surprised by Nixon's knowledge of the plot, including the hush money and Fielding break-in. At another confirmation hearing the following day, Gray testified that Dean had lied about his ignorance of the opening of Hunt's safe, damaging Dean's credibility and leading Gray to withdraw his nomination.
McCord, Dean, and Magruder cooperate (pictured) and
John Dean were cooperating with prosecutors. At the March 23 sentencing, Judge Sirica read a confession from McCord that the Plumbers were told to plead guilty; perjury occurred; others were involved; and the Cubans were misled to think that Watergate was a CIA operation. Sirica tabled McCord's sentencing and gave maximum sentences to Liddy, Hunt, and the Cubans. McCord identified false testimony to the Ervin Committee, implicating Magruder and Dean, and leaked his account—mostly
hearsay through Liddy—to the
Los Angeles Times. Press attention on Watergate exploded, and the Ervin Committee uncovered Gemstone, the destruction of evidence, and the Liddy payments. In April, Dean and Magruder began cooperating with prosecutors, exposing the Fielding break-in and the cover-up complicity of Magruder, Mitchell, Haldeman, and Ehrlichman—but not Nixon. Liddy refused to testify before the grand jury and was held in contempt. By the end of April, Nixon—to save face—made Ehrlichman, Haldeman, Magruder, and Attorney General
Richard Kleindienst resign; Dean was fired on April 30. Watergate scrutiny spawned probes into other abuses, including a "dirty tricks" campaign by
Donald Segretti; Kissinger-ordered wiretaps that led to Felt's resignation; B-52 bombings in Cambodia; illegal CRP donations from firms like
American Airlines; and an off-record $200,000 from investor
Robert Vesco that led to the May 10 indictment of Mitchell and CRP finance chairman
Maurice Stans. Later that month, Congressman
William Mills committed suicide after it emerged that he had taken an unreported $25,000 from a CRP slush fund. In July, Nixon was hospitalized with
pneumonia, possibly caused by the stress of Watergate; acting White House Counsel
Leonard Garment wrote that "The organizing objective of these investigations was to bleed Nixon to death".
Ervin hearings and Special Prosecutor Cox The Ervin Committee's public hearings began on May 17. Testimony from McCord, Caulfield, Ulasewicz, and others suggested White House involvement in the break-in and cover-up, which Nixon vehemently denied. The hearings—which also included testimony from Dean, Magruder, and Mitchell—drew immense publicity: three in four American households watched live testimony, an average of 30 hours per home. In concurrent Senate proceedings, Attorney General nominee
Elliot Richardson agreed to appoint a
special prosecutor on Watergate. After rejecting Nixon's suggestions, Richardson chose
Archibald Cox—President Kennedy's
solicitor general. They negotiated that Cox could only be fired by Richardson and only due to "extraordinary improprieties". Cox built a legal team he called the Watergate Special Prosecution Force. As early as July 4, Nixon expressed a desire to fire Cox after the Force considered investigating the financial impropriety of his California estate,
La Casa Pacifica. In August, the Force empaneled a second grand jury to pursue crimes beyond the break-in, such as campaign finance irregularities.
Struggle for the tapes in 1973 On July 13, Haldeman assistant
Alexander Butterfield revealed the existence of the Oval Office tapes to the Ervin Committee. In urgent meetings, White House counsel
J. Fred Buzhardt and Vice President
Spiro Agnew suggested the tapes be destroyed. Nixon did not destroy the tapes for unclear reasons, possibly to preserve his legacy, protect himself against perjury or Kissinger's aggrandizement, or because he did not believe he would ever have to surrender them. Following Butterfield's revelation, Cox and the Ervin Committee formally subpoenaed tapes corresponding to meetings suspected to involve Watergate. Nixon rejected both subpoenas, leading to objections in court. Due to stronger
standing under the separation of powers, Sirica prioritized the executive branch Cox over the legislative Ervin committee. Nixon's legal team—led by
Charles Alan Wright—invoked executive privilege and argued that releasing the tapes would create a precedent allowing judicial access to all sensitive presidential material. Cox asserted that executive privilege did not apply when criminality was suspected, and also cited
United States v. Burr, in which Chief Justice
John Marshall ruled that President
Thomas Jefferson could be subpoenaed. In a decision that upset both parties, Sirica ordered the tapes be submitted to him to determine if any were protected by executive privilege. This was appealed, and on October 12 the appeals court ruled 5–2 to force Nixon to surrender the tapes to Sirica, or to make a deal with Cox.
Saturday Night Massacre (right)—seen with Senator
John Stennis (left)—resigned when ordered by Nixon to fire Special Prosecutor Cox. During October, Cox and the Force made progress on Watergate-related investigations, including securing a grand jury indictment of Krogh for
false declarations on the Fielding break-in, and guilty pleas from American Airlines,
Goodyear, and the
3M Company for illegal contributions to the CRP. Cox also began investigating Nixon's closest friend
Bebe Rebozo for mediating an illicit $100,000 campaign contribution from Howard Hughes. After weighing the appellate decision, Nixon proposed giving Sirica the tapes and then firing Cox to negate the appeals court case; Attorney General Richardson rejected the scheme. Negotiations with Cox to drop the subpoena and have Senator
John Stennis review the tapes also collapsed. On October 19—citing the need for stability in the
Middle East amid the
Yom Kippur War—Nixon unexpectedly announced that Stennis would review the tapes: a deal not approved by Stennis, the Ervin Committee, Cox, or Richardson. On October 20, in what became known as the
Saturday Night Massacre, Nixon ordered Richardson to fire Cox. He refused and resigned in protest. Nixon then ordered Deputy Attorney General
William Ruckelshaus to fire Cox, but Ruckelshaus declined and was fired after offering his resignation. The next acting attorney general, Solicitor General
Robert Bork, agreed to fire Cox. FBI agents sealed the Force's office and blocked the entry of Cox's staff. Though Bork believed Nixon's order was legal and justified, he considered resigning to avoid being "perceived as a man who did the President's bidding to save my job". ==Impeachment process and resignation ==