Scholars have not always agreed on questions such as • why humans believe in an afterlife; • whether descriptions of paradise and hell, Resurrection and Judgment Day in the Quran and other Islamic literature are literal, are allegorical, or perhaps are beyond human understanding; • whether there is a third state in the afterlife between heaven and hell; • whether the creation of paradise and hell will wait until Judgement Day, and whether all parts of the two abodes are eternal; • whether all actions that humans will be punished or rewarded for in the afterlife are preordained by God; • who might go to heaven or hell and why; • whether those consigned to hell will be there for eternity.
Basis of belief "Fear, hope, and finally ... faith", have been given (by Jane I. Smith, Yvonne Y. Haddad) as motivations offered by the Quran for the belief of Muslims in an afterlife, although some (
Abū Aʿla al-Mawdūdī) have asserted it is simply a matter of reason: The fact is that whatever Muhammad (peace be upon him) has told us about life after death is clearly borne out by reason. Although our belief in that Day is based upon our implicit trust in the Messenger of God, rational reflection not only confirms this belief but it also reveals that Muhammad's (peace be upon him) teachings in this respect are much more reasonable and understandable than all other view-points about life after death.
Literal or allegorical Descriptions of the physical pleasures of paradise have been interpreted as
allegories, symbolic of the state of joy believers will experience in the afterlife. For some theologians, even being able to see God is not a question of sight, but of awareness of God's presence. Although early
Sufis, such as
Hallaj, took the descriptions of paradise literally, later Sufi traditions usually stressed an allegorical meaning. On the issue of Judgement Day, early Muslims debated whether scripture should be interpreted literally or figuratively, with a literal interpretation of the
Ashʿarī school of thought eventually prevailing. It affirmed that things connected with Judgement day such as "the individual records of deeds (including the paper, pen, and ink with which they are inscribed), the bridge, the balance, and the pond" were all to be understood "in a concrete and literal sense." In the contemporary era, according to scholars Jane I. Smith, Yvonne Y. Haddad, "the vast majority" of believers, understand verses of the Quran on
Jannah (and hellfire) "to be real and specific, anticipating them" with joy or terror.
Modernist and postmodernist thought Earlier
Islamic Modernists did not accept literal interpretation. The beliefs of Pakistani modernist
Muhammad Iqbal (died 1938), were similar to the Sufi "spiritual and internalized interpretations of hell" of
ibn ʿArabī, and
Rumi, seeing paradise and hell "primarily as metaphors for inner psychic" developments. Thus "hellfire is actually a state of realization of one's failures as a human being", and not a supernatural subterranean realm. Egyptian modernist
Muhammad ʿAbduh, thought it was sufficient to believe in the existence of an afterlife with rewards and punishment to be a true believer, even if you ignored "clear" (
ẓāhir) hadith about hell. According to Smith and Haddad, "the great majority of contemporary Muslim writers, ... choose not to discuss the afterlife at all". Consequently, most of "modern Muslim Theologians" either "silence the issue" or reaffirm "the traditional position" that the afterlife is real and should not be denied but that "its exact nature remains unfathomable". In opposition to this, Amina Wadud notes that the Qur'an does not mention any specific gender when talking about hell. Verse Q., for example, states that "the guilty are immortal in hell's torment". When discussing paradise, the Quran includes women, Q., for example, states that "Beautiful of mankind is love of the joys (that come) from women and offspring..."
"Limbo" or al-aʿrāf in Islam In terms of classical Islam, "the only options" afforded by the Qur'an for the resurrected are an eternity of horrible punishments of The Fire (hell) or the delightful rewards of The Garden (paradise). Islamic tradition has raised the question of whether or not consignment to The Fire is eternal, or eternal for all, but "has found no reason to amend" the limit of two options in the afterlife. However, one verse in the Quran has "led to a great deal of speculation concerning the possibility of a third place". As for who the inhabitants of
al-aʿrāf are, the "majority of exegetes" support the theory that they are those whose actions in dunya were balanced – whose good deeds keep them from the Fire and whose evil deeds keep them from the Garden. After everyone else has been let into the Garden, and if the mercy of their Lord permits it, they will be allowed in.
Predestination Orthodox Islam teaches the doctrine of
Qadar (, aka
Predestination, or
divine destiny in
Islam), whereby everything that has happened and will happen in the universe—including sinful human behavior—is commanded by God. At the same time, we human beings are responsible for our actions and rewarded or punished for them in the
Afterlife.
Qadar/predestination/divine destiny, is one of Sunni Islam's
six articles of faith and is mentioned in the Quran in verses such as: • "Nothing will ever befall us except what Allah has destined for us" (Q.). Of course, the fate of human beings in the afterlife is especially crucial. It is reflected in Quranic verses such as • Had We willed, We could have easily imposed guidance on every soul. But My Word will come to pass: I will surely fill up Hell with jinn and humans all together. (Q.). Opponents of predestination in early Islam, (
al-Qadariyah,
Muʿtazila) argued that if everything that will ever happen has already determined, God's human creation cannot really be free to make decisions to do good or evil, or be in control of whether they suffer eternal torment in
Jahannam—which is something that (the opponents believe) a just God would never allow to happen. and according to the creed of
Al-Tahawi, "the principle of providence" is such a secret that God did not let even angels, prophets and messengers in on the mystery.
Creation of heaven and hell Whether heaven and hell have already been created Islam, like
Christianity, conceptualizes the relationship between
Dunyā (temporal world) and
Ākhirah (hereafter) in a diachronic timeline. arguing that God creates only with a purpose, and since all except God will be destroyed by the
trumpet before the Day of Resurrection, paradise and hell would have no function until Judgement Day, after the annihilation of the world, and so must be created afterwards. Furthermore Islamic literature is filled with interactions between the world and the hereafter and the world is closely intertwined with both paradise and hell.
Māturīdi scholar Abu al-Layth al-Samarqandi (944–983) explains that the otherworldly abodes coexist in order to inspire hope and cause fear. The overlap of the earthly and otherworldly domain is anchored in the
Quran itself. However, some practitioners in the early Muslim community held that the other abode of the hereafter (hell/jahannam), or at least part of that abode, might not be eternal. This possibility that God may yet commute a sentence to hell, interprets (parts of) hell as serving a function similar to
purgatory in Christianity, (with the exception to this comparison being that hell in this context is for the punishment of the sinner's complete body, as opposed to only the soul being punished in purgatory). Evidence against the concept of hell being in part temporary, is the Quran verse stating that hell will endure as long as Heaven will, which has been established as eternal.
Who will enter heaven or hell Scholars do not all agree on who will end up in jannah and who in jahannam, and the criteria for deciding. Issues include whether all Muslims, even those who've committed major sins, will end up in jannah; whether any non-Muslims will be saved or all will go to jahannam. According to the Quran, the basic criterion for
salvation in the afterlife is the belief in the
oneness of God (Tawhid|),
angels,
revealed books,
messengers, as well as
repentance to God, and doing good deeds (
amal salih). This is qualified by the doctrine that ultimately salvation can only be attained through God's judgement.
Muslims, jinn, angels, devils Muslim scholars mostly agree that ultimately all Muslims will be saved (though many may need to be purified by a spell in hellfire), but disagree about the possibility for salvation of non-Muslims. The idea that
jinn as well as humans could find salvation was widely accepted. Like humans, their destiny in the hereafter depends on whether they accept God's guidance. The surah Al-Jinn says: Angels, who are not subject to desire and do not commit sin, are found in paradise. The devils cannot return to paradise, because Islamic scripture states that their father, the fallen angel Iblis, was banished, but never suggests that he or his offspring were forgiven or promised to return.
Early Muslim thought on damnation One of the primary beliefs pertaining to Islamic eschatology during the early Muslim period was that all humans could receive God's mercy and were worthy of salvation. These early depictions even show how small, insignificant deeds were enough to warrant mercy. Most early depictions of the end of days describe only those who reject
Tawhid, (
monotheism), as being subject to eternal punishment. However, everybody is held responsible for their actions. Concepts of reward and punishment were seen as beyond this world, a view that is also held today. Although the Quran acknowledges the Bible as gospel, rejecting Muhammad and his message is seen as a rejection of salvation by them. Based on these categories, four "well-known and particularly influential Muslim thinkers" can be sorted as: • al-Ghazālī – "optimistic" or "liberal inclusivist"; •
Ibn Hazm – "proclaimed that even the most upright and flawless moral-ethical monotheist is damned to hell if he knows anything about a person named Muḥammad or a religion called Islam and does not join, while even the most brutal and immoral person who converts sincerely to Islam the moment before he dies, is saved". Furthermore, "any Muslim who does not agree is not a Muslim himself." • People who heard of Islam because they lived in neighboring lands and/or mixed with Muslims. Only this group has no hope of salvation, and will be punished. that everyone with normal intellectual capacities is responsible for believing in a
creator even if they haven't heard about Muhammad or any other prophetic mission, While some (like
Rifat Atay) regard Māturīdism to be exclusivistic, only allowing people who are Muslims to enter paradise,
Muʿtazila The theology of
Muʿtazila emphasized God's justice, and the
free will and responsibility of each human being for their actions. They have been called the "best known exponents" of
Qadariyah, the idea that human beings must have free will otherwise it would be unjust to punish or reward them for their actions. Compared to Maturidi and Ashʿarī, Muʿtazila had the least amount of "salvific optimism", as they stressing individual accountability, rejecting
intercession (''Shafa'a'') on behalf of sinners by Muhammad. (At least one
Twelver Shia scholar 'Allama al-Hilli, insists that not only will non-Muslims be damned but suggests Sunni Muslim will be as well, as it is not possible for any Muslim to be ignorant of "the imamate and of the Return", and thus "whoever is ignorant of any of them is outside the circle of believers and worthy of eternal punishment." This statement is not indicative of all Shia eschatological thought.) Also like mainstream schools, and unlike Muʿtazila, Twelver Shia hold that Jannah and hellfire "exist at present ... according to the Qur`an and ahadith". However, they will not "become fully apparent and represented" until Judgement Day. As for three other issues in Islamic eschatology: • the differences between Adam and Eve's
Garden of Eden, • "the heaven or hell of one's actions which envelopes a person"; and • the
Barzakh state of "purgatory" in Islam after death and before Resurrection; in Shia Islam, these three "types" of jannah (or Jahannam) are "all simply manifestations of the ultimate, eternal heaven and hell". The
Fate of the unlearned is also a matter of dispute within Islamic theology. Like many
modern scholars advocated, including
Mawlana Ali,
Ismail Hakki Izmirli, and
Yusuf al-Qaradawi, Muhammad Abduh and Rashid Rida asserted the doctrine of a finite hell
fanāʾ al-nār ("demise of hell").
Neo-Salafi commonly reject inclusive salvation theories. For example, Salafi scholar
Umar Sulaiman Al-Ashqar, like proto-Salafi
ibn Qayyim, rejects the doctrine of
fanāʾ al-nār. He interprets the hadith that will be 73 Islamic sects from which only one will be saved in accordance with his belief that only those who stick close to the Quran and the Sunnah go to paradise, while those he considers deviant, such as
Muʿtazila and Kharijites go to hell temporarily, while "extreme" groups such as
Isma'ilis,
Alevites, and
Druze, go to hell forever. Al-Ashqar elaborates on a hadith that "most inhabitants of hell are women" that women are more likely to go to hell due to intellectual deficiencies, but adds that despite their flaws, there are also many good and pious women. ==Contemporary popular interest in Islamic eschatology==