Distress at CBS, then recovery CBS's position entering the
1994–95 television season was particularly dire. The loss of the NFC and multiple tenured affiliates, combined with a long-held strategy of pursuing older, less-desirable audiences in prime time, resulted in the network crashing to last place among the "Big Three". Upon moving to CBS from NBC in August 1993,
David Letterman's
Late Show enjoyed a lead over
The Tonight Show with Jay Leno in the late-night ratings. With CBS having to move from established affiliates to lesser-known UHF outlets, that lead began to shrink. "You can do a great show, but if it's on Channel 93 in
West Tipton, Indiana, it's not going to be easy to find it," Letterman commented on the switches. Finally, a
Jay Leno interview with actor
Hugh Grant in July 1995 following the actor's infamous arrest for lewd conduct resulted in
Tonight taking the top spot and remaining there until
Leno stepped down in 2009. Laurence Tisch began exploring a sale of CBS amid the turmoil, with Westinghouse announcing a $5.4 billion purchase of the network on August 1, 1995. Westinghouse CEO
Michael H. Jordan credited a growing relationship with Tisch thanks to their joint venture that made the deal possible. On October 2, 1996, network flagship WCBS-TV fired much of its on-air talent including longtime anchor
Michele Marsh, a move meant to address the station's low ratings. CBS attempted to fill the void left by the NFL on Sunday afternoons in 1994 with
made-for-TV movie reruns aimed at a female audience. By December 1994, the network announced a contract renewal with the
NCAA, particularly for the
Division I men's basketball tournament, a franchise CBS had held since 1982. CBS Sports also presented a higher emphasis on
NASCAR programming including the
Winston Cup,
Busch Series and
Craftsman Truck series, along with the
PGA Tour and
US Open. In late 1995, CBS was approached by the
CFL about a television contract for
the league's American teams.
Sean McManus was appointed as president of CBS Sports in November 1996, which was interpreted as the network intending to bid aggressively for the NFL for the next rights deal, as McManus had a reputation for being the "kingpin of big TV negotiations". CBS successfully outbid NBC for the AFC contract on January 13, 1998, signing an eight-year contract worth $4 billion; NBC Sports president
Dick Ebersol was told by
General Electric officials not to do anything "reckless" and saw the package as third-tier behind the NFC and MNF. The return of football was especially seen as a comeback vehicle for
Jim Nantz, one of the few high-profile sports announcers that remained with CBS throughout.
New World stations struggle to adapt The New World Fox stations struggled to reconcile their new network programming, which targeted a younger audience, with their older-skewing newscasts. In Phoenix, KSAZ-TV's existing 5, 6, and 10 p.m. newscasts lost half their ratings in the first year of the switch. In dumping the popular syndicated shows
Jeopardy! and
Wheel of Fortune because they attracted older viewers, the station lost a valuable lead-in and lead-out around its newscasts. The two shows were then picked up by KTVK, which showed unexpected aggression in buying syndicated programs. KTVK also launched the market's first longform morning newscast, which emerged a winner as KSAZ-TV's effort struggled. It was not until 1997 that the station began to turn around its news ratings by dropping its sputtering 9 p.m.
Arizona Prime in favor of
Fox 10 News at 9, which featured an emphasis on breaking news and entertainment stories designed to be more compatible with Fox prime time shows. In Cleveland, WJW-TV's issues were fairly pronounced. WJW's switch came with three months notice and altered more than 20 hours of programming per day, or 87 percent of the schedule. Ratings declined in all time slots but especially fell by half for the late-evening news after moving from 11 p.m.—a time slot WJW had won in since 1981—to 10 p.m., but still topped WUAB's newscast. WJW's morning show also failed to retain the audience of its lead-in 6 a.m. news. Virgil Dominic retired in May 1995 and was replaced by KNXV general manager Bob Rowe; under Rowe, the station rebranded to "Fox is Ei8ht" / "Ei8ht is News" in November 1995, a slogan derided among viewers for its continuous on-air repetition. The morning newscasts were retooled into a three-hour program and had its audience double year-over-year during the first month, while WJW saw ratings increases in several dayparts. Fox's purchase of New World resulted in WJW rebranding as "Fox 8" in August 1996. By 1998, WJW was beating WUAB at 10 p.m. by a 2–1 margin and in 2000 was ranked first sign-on to sign-off in multiple key demographics, besting WEWS. In Milwaukee, WITI had been the market's second-rated outlet generally in May 1994. However, its ratings sank after the affiliation switch, with the 10 p.m. news, which was retained, dropping by roughly half. Initially resisting changes to their CBS-era presentation, WITI rebranded as "Fox is Six" / "Six is News" in November 1995, parallel to WJW's "Ei8ht" rebranding, but kept its long-running "Friend You Can Count On" slogan. By 1997, WITI was rebounding in local ratings, but it still fell short of their pre-switch levels and remained in third place by 2000. Atlanta's WAGA was the number two station leading into the affiliation switches. Its new 10 p.m. newscast held most of the viewers of its prior 11 p.m. broadcast, which
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution TV critic Phil Kloer attributed to the station's strength and news anchors. The station remained in second place by 2000, though it was a distant second to longtime Atlanta ratings powerhouse
WSB-TV, an unchanged ABC affiliate. WBRC in Birmingham weathered the switches well and by 2000 was the highest-rated Fox-owned station in morning, evening, and late news, as well as prime time. Uniquely, the station initially produced separate half-hour newscasts at 9 and 10 p.m. because it lacked the resources to produce 90 minutes of late news. However, its 5 and 10 p.m. newscasts placed a close second to the new WBMA. WBMA also benefitted from the immediate acquisition of meteorologist
James Spann, who sued to be released from his WBRC contract objecting to Fox programs on moral and religious grounds. WBRC anchor Brenda Ladun also filed suit against the station seeking a contract release and followed Spann to WBMA. WGHP remained the number-two station in the North Carolina Piedmont in its early evening and morning newscasts, though its 10 p.m. news initially fared poorly in comparison to the 11 p.m. news it aired as an ABC affiliate. By 2000, the WGHP 10 p.m. newscast had doubled its audience share from 9 percent in November 1995 to 17 percent, with a higher rating than the 11 p.m. newscasts on market leader WFMY-TV and WXII-TV. In Tampa, WTVT lost its first-place position among the market's local television newscasts to NBC affiliate
WFLA-TV, the only station in the market not affected by the switches, whose newscasts had placed second. It was the first time since 1989 that WFLA-TV had swept the ratings. WFLA also became the market's number-one station in total viewing in every sweeps period until November 1998, when WTVT surpassed it. WJBK in Detroit was a third-rated station before the switch, attracting just over half of the audience as primary competitors
WDIV-TV and
WXYZ-TV. While its 10 p.m. news surpassed incumbent
WKBD-TV, the 6 p.m. newscast was beaten by entertainment programming on that station. WJBK returned to the 11 p.m. news race in May 1995 with
Bonds Tonight, hosted by former WXYZ anchor
Bill Bonds, but was moved to 6:30 p.m. in September and canceled by mid-November due to low ratings. WJBK's overall poor ratings performance following the switch also saw its 4 p.m. news eliminated and multiple staffers laid off. In Austin, KTBC's news ratings slumped significantly in the years after the Fox affiliation switch, while third-place
KXAN-TV there began a climb to the top; KEYE-TV even outdrew KTBC in assorted dayparts. KDFW was the third-rated news outlet in Dallas–Fort Worth prior to the switches. It saw immediate year-over-year declines in the viewership for its 6 and 10 p.m. newscasts; KDFW, which retained its 10 p.m. news in addition to a 9 p.m. news hour, saw notable late news declines because the prior newscast was a poorer lead-in than CBS entertainment programming. By 2000, KTVT had pulled into a dead heat with KDFW for third place. WDAF-TV, a third-rated station in local news in its last years as an NBC affiliate, remained in third but saw significant declines in news viewing in the aftermath of its switch and doubling of weekday news output. Its 10 p.m. news went from attracting 23 percent of TV viewers at that hour to 13 percent, and the station's new morning news attracted just over half the audience share of
The Today Show, which it replaced. In prime time, however, WDAF largely outperformed the national average for Fox affiliates. WDAF maintained their NBC-era "Newschannel 4" branding until being renamed "Fox 4" in 1997 after Fox assumed ownership. It was still in third place at the end of the decade. KTVI also remained a third-rated news outlet in St. Louis. It did not introduce a 9 p.m. newscast until August 1997 and remained third in its market by 2000. van parked next to a van for WMC-TV. WHBQ's competitiveness improved with Fox's investments, but the station could not surpass market leaders WMC-TV or WREG-TV. Though not owned by New World, WHBQ-TV in Memphis was in a similar position. Prior to the switch, it was only producing half-hour newscasts at 6 and 10 p.m. Coinciding with the switch, its weekday news output quadrupled with the introduction of a two-hour morning newscast,
Mornings on Fox, and the reinstatement of a noon newscast after nearly three years; the early evening news was moved to 5 p.m. and the late news to 9 p.m., both an hour in length. However, WHBQ-TV continued to rank third in Memphis behind
WMC-TV and
WREG-TV, the traditional first- and second-place news outlets in Memphis. A
cultural conflict largely existed between the New World stations and Fox. Stations like KSAZ, WJW, WDAF and WITI continued news presentations similar to their "Big Three" affiliations, which analysts saw as unsustainable with younger-skewing Fox shows like
Party of Five as lead-ins. Fox Entertainment president
John Matoian told
The Plain Dealer in July 1995 that the network was planning to expand beyond their original target 18–34 demographic, which was partly based on stations like WJW refusing to identify with the network. By the time Fox purchased New World, the stations were seen as underperformers, largely attributed to station managers unwilling to embrace their new affiliations. WITI news director Jill Geisler was known for stressing a "fair, concerned, balanced position" at the station, while Virgil Dominic was seen as "avuncular" in his stewardship of WJW. One financial analyst suggested incoming Fox management would drastically overhaul the stations and "obviously make 'em full-blown Fox monsters". Fox chairman Chase Carey said, "Without question, the [New World] stations could be performing better than they are today."
The local news production boom . A former "Big Three" affiliate that switched to Fox in 1996, KHON invested heavily into a news-intensive operation.|315x315pxThe New World stations all committed to increased local news production when they switched to Fox. This was partly out of necessity, as Fox only programmed a two-hour prime time program block, but also because the stations stood to generate more revenue selling local advertising. While with CBS, WJW could only sell two minutes of local ads during the 10 p.m. hour, which increased to 16 minutes after their late news moved to that hour. Industry analysts cited WSVN's success with a news-intensive format: having more control over programming and advertising, WSVN generated more revenue than it ever had with NBC. Precedent also existed: when a dispute over revenue compensation emerged between CBS and the affiliate body in 1992, WAGA and WJBK dropped
CBS This Morning in favor of local morning shows. When CBS debuted the
Late Show in 1993, WJW delayed it to midnight in favor of
Murphy Brown reruns and later the New World-produced
Valley of the Dolls—shows during which they could sell additional local advertising—to the network's chagrin; CBS president of affiliate relations Tony Malara later said, "The fact of the matter is, it ain't exactly chopped liver we're offering." By June 1994, Fox was still in the planning stages for a network news service, but Rupert Murdoch dismissed the idea of a nightly evening newscast similar to the "Big Three" networks airing over Fox, saying, "I don't think people watch them very much. People prefer watching a newscast edited and customized for them in their communities." The New World stations gained access to a news sharing service among Fox owned-stations and affiliates while also retaining existing
CNN Newsource affiliations, simulcasting CNN in the event of
breaking news. WDAF, WJBK, KTBC and KHON launched nightly half-hour newscasts with emphasis on national and international coverage, but produced locally. Most of the New World stations moved their late-evening newscasts by an hour and extended them to 60 minutes in length (due to Fox only programming for two hours), or in the cases of WDAF and WITI, created a 90-minute long newscast. WBRC initially had separate half-hour newscasts at 9 and 10. KTVI and KTBC were exceptions: KTVI moved their late-evening news from 10 to 9 p.m. in 1997, while KTBC did the same in 2002; for the latter, the newscasts replaced sitcom reruns in the 9 p.m. hour. KHON maintained a late-evening newscast at 10 p.m. until September 2014, when a 9 p.m. newscast was launched. An unprecedented level of hiring took place among both the New World stations and the replacement "Big Three" affiliates to account for the overall increase in local news, with as many as 1,500 to 2,000 jobs being created during this period. In Cleveland, WJW boasted a news staff of over 120 people, while WOIO used WUAB's news department as the foundation for their own, moving both stations to new facilities at
Reserve Square. Kansas City saw KSHB add 54 people to create a workforce of 72, while WDAF doubled their news staff for a total of 110. WNCN hired 68 full-time staffers in 1995 as they prepared to take the NBC affiliation, WGNX increased their headcount to 50 after linking with CBS, and WHBQ bolstered their staffing from 28 to 55 under Fox ownership. Technical advancements were also made with the increased manpower. WBMA boasted all-digital equipment when their news room launched, with Allbritton executive John Hillis saying, "We had the luxury of a clean sheet on paper." Spurned by ABC, KTVK invested heavily into syndicated programming and newsroom staffing and broke ground on new studios to house their expanded operations. Among unchanged Fox affiliates, Sacramento's
KTXL began hiring staff and extended their late-evening news to an hour, and KOKH-TV in Oklahoma City began assembling a news staff for a 1996 launch. KOKH's entry was a complete reversal from June 1994, when general manager Harlan Reams publicly expressed no desire to do local news, saying, "From a business standpoint, if you want to watch news, hey, watch
4,
5 and
9, watch CNN, read the newspaper. But I'm here to entertain." "Big Three" affiliates in unchanged markets like
KVBC in
Las Vegas and
KIVI-TV in
Boise, Idaho, also saw their news output increased with additional staffing.
Ball State University professor Bob Papper estimated in 1996 that several thousand more jobs could be created if other older Fox affiliates started local news, or expanded their output to match up with the New World stations.
Ratings headwinds for new news operations Many of the new "Big Three" affiliates, which had been either former Fox affiliates or independents on the UHF dial with no news presence, found difficulty garnering ratings traction against their traditional VHF competitors. While most of these replacement affiliates have maintained local news production, with some even experiencing gradual ratings growth, some stations eventually cancelled or outsourced operations outright. Among CBS's replacement affiliates, WGPR-TV (renamed
WWJ-TV) proved to be the network's biggest challenge. A $1 million promotional blitz saw the network's star talent make fun of the station's embarrassingly high channel number, but ratings for network programming in Detroit fell 46 percent year-over-year following the switch. CBS announced plans to establish a news department in Detroit in late 1995, only to withdraw them entirely after several months. Two attempts at local news in 2001 and 2009 failed before the station launched its third and ongoing news operation in January 2023. Unlike WWJ-TV, WOIO, WGNX and WDJT-TV were all successful in debuting local news after linking with CBS, but still struggled against established competition. Until relaunching with a
tabloid format in 2002, WOIO was beset by continued talent instability and dismal ratings. This distinction was shared by WGNX despite a 1998 sale to Meredith, a renaming to WGCL-TV in 2000, multiple rebrands, and continual executive upheaval. When succeeding owner
Gray Television relaunched WGCL as
WANF in 2022, for
Atlanta News First, management conceded the station had no brand at all. WDJT-TV's fortunes have been mixed: the station has thrived in prime time since picking up
Jeopardy! and
Wheel of Fortune as a lead-in, but its news operation continues to trail the competition. Replacement ABC affiliates KDNL-TV and WXLV-TV experienced severe difficulty establishing a news presence and had their efforts shut down by owner Sinclair Broadcast Group. KDNL's newscasts, which debuted prior to the switch, struggled to gain viewership amid repeated changes in management, on-air talent and news sets, with ABC network programming equally underperforming. Barry Baker, chief executive of former owner River City Broadcasting, held an
option to sell their St. Louis holdings and sold it to Emmis Communications in June 1999, sparking a year-long lawsuit between Sinclair and Emmis. The lawsuit forced KDNL onto an
austerity budget cancelling the 5 p.m. news, while a failing transmitter repeatedly forced the station
off-air. The 5 p.m. news was restored in October 2000 but failed to register any measurable audience, while the 10 p.m. news drew half the ratings as
Friends reruns on KPLR, resulting in the news department's disbanding on October 12, 2001. WXLV-TV, which frequently failed to make progress in area ratings against the more established
WFMY-TV, WGHP and WXII-TV, had its morning and weekend newscasts cancelled in late 2000 and ultimately shuttered outright on January 11, 2002. Utilizing Sinclair's hybrid
News Central format, an 11 p.m. newscast ran from 2004 to 2005, when it was again scrapped due to poor ratings. In February 2012,
Spectrum News 1 North Carolina (then known as News 14 Carolina) began producing daily newscasts for WXLV as part of a
retransmission consent dispute settlement between
Time Warner Cable and Sinclair. Spectrum News newscasts continued to air on WXLV until 2019, then resumed local newscasts in January 2021, albeit produced by
KABB in
San Antonio. This was not limited to new CBS, NBC, or ABC affiliates in New World markets. KHNL in Honolulu began airing newscasts on April 12, 1995, more than eight months before switching to NBC. The station's newscasts, however, failed to find ratings success in spite of NBC's strength in entertainment programming in the late 1990s, as well as the hiring of several notable personalities in the market. WPTY-TV's news department was hastily assembled to make the deadline for their Fox-ABC switch, with multiple technical gaffes and on-air talent misidentifying area landmarks plaguing their debut. The weeknight anchor lineup changed within two weeks, and the news director was fired after a year. Low ratings continued to plague the station through a 2013 relaunch as
WATN-TV under Nexstar ownership; the station was later sold to
Tegna Inc. in 2019. New NBC affiliate WGBA-TV in Green Bay, Wisconsin, did not begin producing newscasts until July 1, 1996; it had doubled its payroll and expanded its studios in order to accommodate its news operation. Its newscasts lagged the other three local stations in the ratings, and turnover of on-air talent was high. WNWO-TV had a single daily newscast at 6 p.m. when it switched to NBC in September 1995; the following year,
Malrite Communications purchased the station and began investing in the news department, but it failed to reap any windfall from NBC's highly rated prime time lineup. WNWO continued to experience ownership changes, poor ratings and staff turnover before newscast production was outsourced to WSBT-TV in 2017 and eliminated altogether in 2023. WEVV-TV in Evansville, Indiana, which switched from Fox to CBS, shut down their news department in July 2001 amid poor ratings; after the station was sold to
Bayou City Broadcasting, WEVV (which reclaimed the Fox affiliation on a
digital subchannel in 2011) relaunched local newscasts. In South Bend, Indiana, replacement ABC affiliate WBND-LP did not offer local news until 2008, albeit produced by WDJT, and established a staffed newsroom in April 2011. Because of its competitive and technical weakness, Weigel tried to sell WBND-LP,
WCWW-LP and
WMYS-LP to WSBT-TV owner
Schurz Communications in 2008, but the deal was abandoned in August 2009.
Effects in Mexico and Canada Fox's acquisition of football rights brought the number of Fox affiliates broadcasting from Mexico from one to three. It also resulted in changes in Canadian cable regulations. In San Diego, UPN affiliate
KUSI-TV tried unsuccessfully to take the Fox affiliation away from
Tijuana,
Baja California,
Mexico-licensed
XETV, citing FCC regulations preventing any foreign station from airing live programming from the United States to U.S. audiences without an FCC-approved permit. Fox was eventually granted the permit allowing XETV to carry the games. XETV lost its affiliation to CW affiliate
KSWB-TV in 2008 through a deal with
Tribune Broadcasting; in turn, XETV assumed the CW affiliation. The permit to carry live programming also benefited two stations set up by
Televisa with Fox programming:
XHFOX-TV in
Matamoros/
Reynosa (serving the
Harlingen–
Brownsville–
McAllen market) and
XHFTX-TV in
Nuevo Laredo (serving the
Laredo market). However, these stations continued to have to "bicycle" tapes of programming across the border. These stations dropped their Fox affiliations on February 28, 2002, due to increased
reverse compensation fees with Fox and high costs of local news production. Both stations became affiliates of Televisa's
Canal de las Estrellas. While the NFL signed Canadian rights agreements for both the NFC and AFC packages on television in
Canada with the
CanWest Global System and
Western International Communications, the switches led to increased interest by Canadian cable companies in adding a U.S. Fox station to their lineups. However, since 1978, the availability of U.S. network affiliates on Canadian cable had been governed by the
Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC)'s "3 plus 1" rule, allowing the carriage of three American network affiliates plus a
PBS station, with frequent exemptions for border towns where additional stations were receivable over-the-air. In June 1994, the CRTC stated it was unwilling to modify the rule; the next month, a group of 48 Canadian cable systems, many belonging to major operators, petitioned the CRTC to allow them to add Fox programming. Canadian broadcasters lobbied against any change, fearing that the addition of Fox would "Americanize the system further" and occupy channel capacity needed to provide new Canadian services. External pressure led the CRTC to reverse course by September, allowing Canadian cable providers to pick up a Fox affiliate without having to drop a "Big Three" affiliate.
Impact on Fox Kids Fox Kids, which had been created as a joint venture between Fox and the affiliates in 1990, continued after the realignment with a roster of affiliates considerably different from the main Fox network. WBNX-TV and
KSMO-TV saw their profiles boosted with the addition of Fox Kids: KSMO experienced dramatic viewership increases in the early afternoon, while WBNX became Cleveland's WB affiliate in 1997 owing to their success with Fox Kids. Facing increased competition from basic cable channels along with
Kids' WB and
UPN Kids, Fox Kids merged their in-house
production arm with
Saban Entertainment (who produced
Mighty Morphin Power Rangers for the program block) to form
Fox Kids Worldwide in 1996, purchased
The Family Channel the following year and relaunched it as
Fox Family Channel. By 1998, Fox Kids affiliates sold their ownership interests back to Fox in a deal where Fox affiliates would pay a combined $50 million per year for Fox's renewed NFC contract. Fox Family Channel struggled to find viewership and lost money, Fox Kids' operations were reassigned to the network proper and were ultimately replaced with
a program block from
4Kids Entertainment in 2002.
The ascendance of Fox Sports '' hosts, 2009 Fox Sports has been cited as one of the fastest start-ups in modern television history, and the most successful. Aided by a number of off- and on-air personnel that defected from CBS Sports, David Hill—who was transferred as Sky Sports president to like duties for Fox—assembled the division in less than eight months. John Madden jokingly mused upon joining Fox Sports that the "s" should be removed from the name, "... because the only sport ... we had at Fox was football, NFL football". Adopting the slogan of "same game, new attitude", the
NFL on Fox's centerpiece program was an hour-long pregame show,
Fox NFL Sunday, incorporating comedy and entertainment with co-host Terry Bradshaw quickly becoming a
breakout star.
NFL Sundays success demonstrated viewers held an appetite for football that extended beyond the game itself. Along with a theme song composed by
Scott Schreer that has since become symbolic of the entire network, technical innovations included the "
Fox Box" displaying the clock and score continuously (Hill perfected a similar on-screen bug for Sky's soccer coverage) and the use of
parabolic microphones for in-game sound. NFL on Fox also provided a launching pad for other established announcers including
Kenny Albert,
Kevin Harlan and
Joe Buck. The affiliation switches helped elevate Fox to major network status, on par with its older, established competitors. The growth of Fox Sports was as quick as its founding: on September 9, 1994, Fox secured rights to the
National Hockey League from
1995 to
1999, again outbidding CBS.
Major League Baseball followed on November 7, 1995, initially via a shared arrangement with NBC. Fox Sports extended into
regional sports networks beginning in 1996 through a joint venture with
TCI's
Liberty Media, creating
Fox Sports Net from the former
Prime Sports and
SportsChannel networks. NASCAR coverage was added in 2001, including the
Daytona 500, plus the Winston Cup and Busch Series. Along with the NFL,
NASCAR on Fox and the
MLB on Fox remain cornerstones of Fox Sports into the present day. == See also ==