Cataphatic and apophatic mysticism Within theistic mysticism two broad tendencies can be identified. One is a tendency to understand God by asserting what he is and the other by asserting what he is not. The former leads to what is called
cataphatic theology and the latter to
apophatic theology. •
Cataphatic (imaging God, imagination or words) – e.g., The Spiritual Exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola,
Julian of Norwich,
Francis of Assisi; and • Apophatic (imageless, stillness, and wordlessness) – inspired by the writings of
Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite, which forms the basis of Eastern Orthodox mysticism and hesychasm, and became influential in western Catholic mysticism from the 12th century AD onward, as in
The Cloud of Unknowing and
Meister Eckhart.
Urban T. Holmes III categorized mystical theology in terms of whether it focuses on illuminating the mind, which Holmes refers to as speculative practice, or the heart/emotions, which he calls affective practice. Combining the speculative/affective scale with the apophatic/cataphatic scale allows for a range of categories: •
Rationalism = Cataphatic and speculative •
Pietism = Cataphatic and
affective •
Encratism = Apophatic and speculative •
Quietism = Apophatic and affective
Meditation and contemplation In discursive meditation, such as
Lectio Divina, mind and imagination and other faculties are actively employed in an effort to understand Christians' relationship with
God. In contemplative prayer, this activity is curtailed, so that
contemplation has been described as "a gaze of faith", "a silent love". There is no clear-cut boundary between Christian meditation and Christian contemplation, and they sometimes overlap. Meditation serves as a foundation on which the contemplative life stands, the practice by which someone begins the state of contemplation. •
Katharsis or purification; •
Theoria or illumination, also called "natural" or "acquired contemplation;" •
Union or
Theosis; also called "infused" or "higher contemplation"; indwelling in God; vision of God; deification;
union with God The three aspects later became
purgative, illuminative, and unitive in the western churches and prayer of the lips, the mind, the heart in the eastern churches. Purification and illumination of the mind are preparations for the vision of God. Without these preparations it is impossible for man's selfish love to be transformed into selfless love. This transformation takes place during the higher level of the stage of illumination called theoria, literally meaning vision, in this case vision
by means of unceasing and uninterrupted memory of God. Those who remain selfish and self-centered with a hardened heart, closed to God's love, will not see the glory of God in this life. However, they will see God's glory eventually, but as an eternal and consuming fire and outer darkness.
Catharsis (purification) In the Orthodox Churches, theosis results from leading a pure life, practicing restraint and adhering to the commandments, putting the love of God before all else. This metamorphosis (transfiguration) or transformation results from a deep love of God. Saint
Isaac the Syrian says in his
Ascetical Homilies that "Paradise is the love of God, in which the bliss of all the beatitudes is contained," and that "the
tree of life is the love of God" (Homily 72).
Theoria is thus achieved by the pure of heart who are no longer subject to the afflictions of the passions. It is a gift from the Holy Spirit to those who, through observance of the commandments of God and
ascetic practices (see
praxis,
kenosis,
Poustinia and
schema), have achieved dispassion. Purification constitutes a turning away from all that is unclean and unwholesome. This is a purification of mind and body. As preparation for
theoria, however, the concept of purification in this three-part scheme refers most importantly to the purification of consciousness (
nous), the faculty of discernment and knowledge (wisdom), whose awakening is essential to coming out of the state of delusion that is characteristic of the worldly-minded. After the
nous has been cleansed, the faculty of wisdom may then begin to operate more consistently. With a purified
nous, clear vision and understanding become possible, making one fit for contemplative prayer. In the Eastern Orthodox ascetic tradition called
hesychasm, humility, as a saintly attribute, is called
holy wisdom or
Sophia. Humility is the most critical component to humanity's salvation. Following Christ's instruction to "go into your room or closet and shut the door and pray to your father who is in secret" (Matthew 6:6), the
hesychast withdraws into solitude in order that he or she may enter into a deeper state of contemplative stillness. By means of this stillness, the mind is calmed, and the ability to see reality is enhanced. The practitioner seeks to attain what the
apostle Paul called 'unceasing prayer'. Some Eastern Orthodox theologians object to what they consider an overly speculative, rationalistic, and insufficiently experiential nature of
Roman Catholic theology. and confusion between different aspects of the Trinity.
Theoria (illumination) – contemplative prayer worn by Orthodox monks and nuns of the most advanced degree An exercise long used among Christians for acquiring contemplation, one that is "available to everyone, whether he be of the clergy or of any secular occupation", is that of focusing the mind by constant repetition of a phrase or word. Saint
John Cassian recommended using the phrase "O God, make speed to save me: O Lord, make haste to help me". Another formula for repetition is the name of Jesus, or the
Jesus Prayer: "Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner," which has been called "the
mantra of the Orthodox Church", The author of
The Cloud of Unknowing recommended use of a monosyllabic word, such as "God" or "Love".
Contemplative prayer in the Eastern Church In the Eastern Church, noetic prayer is the first stage of
theoria, like the difference between reading about the experience of another, and reading about one's own experience. The Jesus Prayer, which, for the early Fathers, was just a training for repose, Via the Jesus Prayer, the practice of the Hesychast is seen to cultivate
nepsis, watchful attention. Sobriety contributes to this mental asceticism that rejects tempting thoughts; it puts a great emphasis on focus and attention. The practitioner of the hesychast is to pay extreme attention to the consciousness of his inner world and to the words of the Jesus Prayer, not letting his mind wander in any way at all. The Jesus Prayer invokes an attitude of humility believed to be essential for the attainment of
theoria. The Jesus Prayer is also invoked to pacify the passions, as well as the illusions that lead a person to actively express these passions. It is believed that the worldly, neurotic mind is habitually accustomed to seek pleasant sensations and to avoid unpleasant ones. This state of incessant agitation is attributed to the corruption of primordial knowledge and union with God (the
fall of man and the defilement and corruption of consciousness, or
nous). According to St.
Theophan the Recluse, though the Jesus Prayer has long been associated with the Prayer of the Heart, they are not synonymous.
Contemplative prayer in the Roman Catholic Church Methods of prayer in the Roman Catholic Church include recitation of the
Jesus Prayer, which "combines the Christological hymn of with the cry of the publican () and the blind man begging for light (). By it the heart is opened to human wretchedness and the Saviour's mercy"; invocation of the holy name of Jesus; The
Congregation for Divine Worship's directory of popular piety and the liturgy emphasizes the contemplative characteristic of the
Holy Rosary and states that the Rosary is essentially a contemplative prayer which requires "tranquility of rhythm or even a mental lingering which encourages the faithful to meditate on the mysteries of the Lord's life."
Pope John Paul II placed the Rosary at the very center of Christian spirituality and called it "among the finest and most praiseworthy traditions of Christian contemplation." In modern times,
centering prayer, which is also called "Prayer of the heart" and "Prayer of Simplicity," has been popularized by
Thomas Keating, drawing on Hesychasm and the
Cloud of Unknowing. The practice of contemplative prayer has also been encouraged by the formation of associations like
The Julian Meetings and the Fellowship of Meditation.
Unification The third phase, starting with infused or higher contemplation (or Mystical Contemplative Prayer) in the Western tradition, refers to the presence or consciousness of God. This presence or consciousness varies, but it is first and foremost always associated with a reuniting with divine
love, the underlying theme being that God, the perfect goodness, is known or experienced at least as much by the heart as by the intellect since, in the words
1 John 4:16: "God is love, and he who abides in love abides in God and God in him." Some approaches to classical mysticism would consider the first two phases as preparatory to the third, explicitly mystical experience, but others state that these three phases overlap and intertwine. In the Orthodox Churches, the highest theoria, the highest consciousness that can be experienced by the whole person, is the vision of God. God is beyond being; He is a hyper-being; God is beyond nothingness. Nothingness is a gulf between God and man. God is the origin of everything, including nothingness. This experience of God in hypostasis shows God's essence as incomprehensible, or uncreated. God is the origin, but has no origin; hence, he is
apophatic and
transcendent in
essence or being, and
cataphatic in
foundational realities,
immanence and
energies. This
ontic or
ontological theoria is the observation of God. A nous in a state of ecstasy or ekstasis, called the eighth day, is not internal or external to the world, outside of time and space; it experiences the
infinite and limitless God.
Nous is the "eye of the soul" (Matthew 6:22–34). Insight into being and becoming (called
noesis) through the intuitive truth called faith, in God (action through faith and
love for God), leads to truth through our contemplative faculties. This
theory, or speculation, as action in faith and love for God, is then expressed famously as "Beauty shall Save the World". This expression comes from a
mystical or
gnosiological perspective, rather than a scientific, philosophical or cultural one.
Alternate models Augustine In the advance to contemplation
Augustine spoke of seven stages: • the first three are merely natural preliminary stages, corresponding to the vegetative, sensitive and rational levels of human life; • the fourth stage is that of virtue or purification; • the fifth is that of the tranquillity attained by control of the passions; • the sixth is entrance into the divine light (the illuminative stage); • the seventh is the indwelling or unitive stage that is truly mystical contemplation.
Meister Eckhart Meister Eckhart did not articulate clear-cut stages, yet a number of divisions can be found in his works.
Teresa of Avila by
Josefa de Óbidos (1672) According to Jordan Aumann, Saint
Teresa of Ávila distinguishes nine grades of prayer: • vocal prayer, •
mental prayer or prayer of meditation, • affective prayer, • prayer of simplicity, or acquired contemplation or recollection, • infused contemplation or recollection, • prayer of quiet, • prayer of union, • prayer of conforming union, and • prayer of transforming union. According to Aumann, "The first four grades belong to the predominantly ascetical stage of spiritual life; the remaining five grades are infused prayer and belong to the mystical phase of spiritual life." According to Augustin Pulain, for Teresa, ordinary prayer "comprises these four degrees: first, vocal prayer; second, meditation, also called methodical prayer, or prayer of reflection, in which may be included meditative reading; third, affective prayer; fourth, prayer of simplicity, or of simple gaze." In the words of Saint
Alphonsus Maria de Liguori, acquired contemplation "consists in seeing at a simple glance the truths which could previously be discovered only through prolonged discourse": reasoning is largely replaced by intuition and affections and resolutions, though not absent, are only slightly varied and expressed in a few words. Similarly, Saint
Ignatius of Loyola, in his 30-day retreat or
Spiritual Exercises beginning in the "second week" with its focus on the life of Jesus, describes less reflection and more simple contemplation on the events of Jesus' life. These contemplations consist mainly in a simple gaze and include an "application of the senses" to the events, to further one's empathy for Jesus' values, "to love him more and to follow him more closely." It is a form of
mystical union with God, a union characterized by the fact that it is God, and God only, who manifests himself. According to Dubay: According to
Thomas Dubay, infused contemplation is the normal, ordinary development of
discursive prayer (mental prayer, meditative prayer), which it gradually replaces. Jordan Aumann considered that this idea of the two paths was "an innovation in spiritual theology and a departure from the traditional Catholic teaching". And
Jacques Maritain proposed that one should not say that every mystic necessarily enjoys habitual infused contemplation in the mystical state, since the gifts of the Holy Spirit are not limited to intellectual operations.
Mystical union According to Charles G. Herbermann, in the
Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), Teresa of Avila described four degrees or stages of mystical union: • incomplete mystical union, or the
prayer of quiet or supernatural recollection, when the action of God is not strong enough to prevent distractions, and the imagination still retains a certain liberty; • full or semi-ecstatic union, when the strength of the divine action keeps the person fully occupied but the senses continue to act, so that by making an effort, the person can cease from prayer; • ecstatic union, or ecstasy, when communications with the external world are severed or nearly so, and one can no longer at will move from that state; and • transforming or deifying union, or spiritual marriage (properly) of the soul with God. The first three are weak, medium, and the energetic states of the same grace.
The Prayer of Quiet For Teresa of Avila, the Prayer of Quiet is a state in which the soul experiences an extraordinary peace and rest, accompanied by delight or pleasure in contemplating
God as present. The Prayer of Quiet is also discussed in the writings of
Francis de Sales,
Thomas Merton and others.
Evelyn Underhill Author and mystic
Evelyn Underhill recognizes two additional phases to the mystical path. First comes the awakening, the stage in which one begins to have some consciousness of absolute or divine reality. Purgation and illumination are followed by a fourth stage which Underhill, borrowing the language of
St. John of the Cross, calls the
dark night of the soul. This stage, experienced by the few, is one of final and complete purification and is marked by confusion, helplessness, stagnation of the
will, and a sense of the withdrawal of God's presence. This dark night of the soul is not, in Underhill's conception, the Divine Darkness of the pseudo-Dionysius and German Christian mysticism. It is the period of final "unselfing" and the surrender to the hidden purposes of the divine will. Her fifth and final stage is union with the object of love, the one Reality, God. Here the self has been permanently established on a transcendental level and liberated for a new purpose. ==Eastern Orthodox Christianity==