LeRoy embarked on a period of enormous productivity and inventiveness at Warner Studios, creating "some the most polished and ambitious" films of the Thirties. His only rival at Warner's was fellow director
Michael Curtiz. Film historian John Baxter observes: In the studio's competitive crucible produced by the
Great Depression demanding profitable entertainment, LeRoy directed 36 pictures during the decade (Curtiz filmed an astounding 44 features during the same period). Baxter adds: "No genius could function without variation under such pressure." The social perspective of films favored at Warner Brothers was distinct from those of its chief rivals:
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (M-G-M), uncontested for its "technical virtuosity" aimed to serve "middle-class tastes" and
Paramount studios identified for its "sophisticated dialogue and baroque settings" that catered to European sensibilities. In contrast, Warner Brothers films carried themes appealing to the working classes. LeRoy biographer Kingsley Canham writes: LeRoy's output in the early Thirties was prodigious. The director attests to the rate of film production at the studios: LeRoy admits in retrospect that "I shot them so often and so fast that they tend to blend together in my memory." LeRoy's social realism mocked corrupt politicians, bankers and the idle rich, while celebrating the
Depression Era experiences of "hard-working chorus girls...taxi-drivers and bell-hops struggling to make ends meet in the brawl of New York...gloss and polish were considered useless affectation."
Gangster genre: Little Caesar, 1930 LeRoy first departed from his comedy-romance themed films with his drama
Numbered Men (1930), a character study of convicts shot on location at
San Quentin prison. The depiction of criminal elements had enjoyed popularity with
Josef von Sternberg's silent classic
Underworld (1927), a fantasy treatment of his lone
Byronic gangster "Bull" Weed. The gangster film as a genre was not achieved until LeRoy's 1930
Little Caesar, starring
Edward G. Robinson, the first time that "any real attempt was made by Hollywood to describe the brutal reality of the criminal world." LeRoy's
Little Caesar established the iconography of subsequent films on organized crime, emphasizing the hierarchy of family loyalties and the function of violence in advancing criminal careers. LeRoy's adroit cinematic handling of Robinson's Rico incrementally shifts initial audience response from revulsion at the character's homicidal acts to a "grudging admiration" that provides for a measure of sympathy when the gangster meets his sordid death in a back alley. LeRoy recalled the topicality of his subject in 1930: "
Al Capone was a household word and the
Saint Valentine's Day Massacre had happened only a year before." LeRoy further demonstrated his talent for delivering fast-paced and competently executed social commentary and entertainment with
Five Star Final (1931), an exposé of tabloid journalism, and
Two Seconds (1932), a "vicious and disenchanted"
cautionary tale of a death row inmate, each starring Robinson.
I Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang (1932) Warner Brothers' most explosive social critique of the 1930s appeared with LeRoy's
I Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang, dramatizing the harsh penal codes in
Georgia and starring
Paul Muni as the hunted fugitive James Allen. Historian John Baxter observes that "no director has managed to close his film on so cold a note as LeRoy." Muni's escaped convict, falsely condemned to hard labor, is reduced to furtive prey: Asked by his estranged sweetheart "how do you get along, how do you live?" he hisses "I steal" and retreats into the night. Muni continued to work effectively with LeRoy in
The World Changes (1933) with
Aline MacMahon and in
Hi, Nellie! (1934) with
Glenda Farrell. The versatile LeRoy portrayed both hard-boiled and clownish characters at Warner Brothers. His
Hard to Handle (1933),
James Cagney plays a fast-talking and remorselessly unscrupulous con-man, often to comic effect. His 1933 pictures
Tugboat Annie (with LeRoy on loan to M-G-M), with
Marie Dressler and
Elmer, the Great, the final of three pictures that LeRoy made with comic
Joe E. Brown, stand in contrast with the director's gangster melodramas. LeRoy's socially themed narrative is evident in his
Three on a Match (1932) which follows the fates of three young women: a stenographer, a showgirl and a socialite played by
Bette Davis,
Joan Blondell and
Ann Dvorak, respectively. His adroit transitions and cross-cutting provide quick and effective insights into his characters' social rise and fall. The "pitiless
mileau of grimy backstreets and cheap motels" serve as an implicit social critique without making this the theme of the picture.
The Gold Diggers of 1933 (1933) The musical
Gold Diggers of 1933 is one of the outstanding examples of the
genre that Warner Brothers released in the thirties. While the "surreal, geometric, often erotically charged" dance stagings by choreographer
Busby Berkeley dominate the picture, Warner's musicals were distinguished enough, according to historian John Baxter, "to be worth considering outside any discussion of Berkeley's dance direction.
The Gold Diggers of 1933 certainly deserves such attention." Offering more than mere
depression era escapism, the musical depicts the mass unemployment of veterans of
World War I and alludes to the then-recent
Bonus Army protests in Washington, D.C., that were suppressed by police and U.S. Army units. The movie closes with the "dark and pessimistic" number "Remember My
Forgotten Man." LeRoy's control of the comedic elements and his direction of a cast endowed with "hard-boiled" heroines
Ruby Keeler,
Joan Blondell,
Aline MacMahon and
Ginger Rogers, would provide stand-alone entertainment even if unencumbered by Berkeley's choreographed numbers. MacMahon, who plays the "ruthless" Trixie, was later cast as a murderess in the lead for LeRoy's dramatic
Heat Lightning (1934), a picture which prefigures director
Archie Mayo's
The Petrified Forest (1936). LeRoy followed with a
Happiness Ahead, a musical-like comedy for Warners in 1934 starring
Josephine Hutchinson, a society heiress who woos a window washer, played by
Dick Powell.
1935: Oil for the Lamps of China, Sweet Adeline, Page Miss Glory, and I Found Stella Parish Oil for the Lamps of China, an adaptation of the
Alice Tisdale Hobart novel, is an examination of an American oil company in China, centering on its paternalistic and humiliating treatment of an ambitious company man, played by
Pat O'Brien.
Josephine Hutchinson portrays his long-suffering wife. LeRoy effectively employed cinematic techniques of montage, structural parallels in settings, chiaroscuro lighting and musical leitmotifs to develop atmosphere and convey O'Brien's struggle, ending in his vindication. LeRoy returned to light comedy and romance in 1935 with a film adaptation of
stage production, the 1929
Jerome Kern and
Oscar Hammerstein II play, starring
Irene Dunne, followed by a
Marion Davies vehicle
Page Miss Glory, (filmed for
Hearst's Cosmopolitan Pictures), and
I Found Stella Parish,, with
Kay Francis in a sentimental, "
tour-de-force" performance.
Anthony Adverse (1936) Based on the popular twelve-hundred page
historical romance by
Hervey Allen, Warner's
Anthony Adverse (1936) was LeRoy's most prestigious undertaking to date. Only two-thirds of the vast and unwieldy
picaresque tale, set during the
Napoleonic era, is depicted onscreen (a sequel was planned but abandoned). The sheer scale of the project remains impressive, and LeRoy's ability to handle a film with high production values that possessed a "Metro-like glossiness" elevated him to becoming a protective executive producer at Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer. The "lively performances" from a large cast, which included
Fredric March,
Olivia de Havilland,
Claude Rains,
Anita Louise and
Gale Sondergaard, as well as LeRoy's "technical excellence," led to five Academy Award nominations. LeRoy reported in his 1974 memoir that "by the time 1936 arrived, I was slowing my pace somewhat. Gone were the assembly-line tactics, the grinding-them-out methods of a few years before...I was working slower, trying to achieve more beauty on film, looking for cinematic perfection." == Producer-Director at Warner Brothers: 1936–1938 ==